The Smiley Smile Message Board
Welcome,
Guest
. Please
login
or
register
.
1 Hour
1 Day
1 Week
1 Month
Forever
Login with username, password and session length
If you like this message board, please help with the hosting costs!
681378
Posts in
27636
Topics by
4082
Members - Latest Member:
briansclub
June 05, 2024, 07:29:56 AM
The Smiley Smile Message Board
|
Smiley Smile Stuff
|
General On Topic Discussions
|
Did Brian ruin Heroes and Villains by adding the "Bicycle Rider" chorus?
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
« previous
next »
Pages:
[
1
]
2
3
4
Author
Topic: Did Brian ruin Heroes and Villains by adding the "Bicycle Rider" chorus? (Read 15813 times)
Jukka
Smiley Smile Associate
Offline
Posts: 739
Did Brian ruin Heroes and Villains by adding the "Bicycle Rider" chorus?
«
on:
October 02, 2013, 01:25:24 AM »
I'm sure this has been discussed before, but hey, what isn't?
Anyway, what do you think? I had a proper Heroes and Villains listening marathon just recently, and I noticed that he got it right in the early 1967. The cantina version that's on Smiley Smile, or part one... That's it right there. A compact musical cartoon, with not a a dull second included. Sure, it didn't have a catchy chorus, but it didn't really need one. The bicycle rider chorus just kills the track's momentum. The moment he decided to add it the song lost its original idea.
Logged
"Surfing and cars were okay but there was a war going on."
Iron Horse-Apples
Guest
Re: Did Brian ruin Heroes and Villains by adding the \
«
Reply #1 on:
October 02, 2013, 01:29:56 AM »
No. The finished single is just sublime. The cantina version is a work in progress. I love it, I love all H&V sessions, but the single is perfect, we're lucky to have it.
«
Last Edit: October 02, 2013, 01:32:44 AM by (Stephen Newcombe)
»
Logged
Please delete my account
Smiley Smile Associate
Offline
Posts: 872
Please delete my account
Re: Did Brian ruin Heroes and Villains by adding the \
«
Reply #2 on:
October 02, 2013, 01:32:37 AM »
I wouldn't say "ruin", but I do like it better without. Never too fond of that part of the song. On the album reconstructions it is annoying having two songs back-to-back with the same chorus, too.
Logged
Please delete my account
Nile
Smiley Smile Associate
Offline
Posts: 158
Re: Did Brian ruin Heroes and Villains by adding the \
«
Reply #3 on:
October 02, 2013, 02:17:41 AM »
I agree that it kind of ruins the momentum.. I personally like the cantina version with some minor changes...
Dont need to point out that I think that Chorus is a great piece of work, both vocally and instrumentally..that wouldn`t exist in January 67 Smile album!:)
I myself in my Smile mixes put it somewhere, apart from HV, in the end..maybe just a snipett in the end, after the Surfs up finishes..you know Surfs up...silence..HV chosrus snippet.. gone, slience... Think that it kinda closes the album in a nice way..
Logged
Micha
Smiley Smile Associate
Offline
Gender:
Posts: 3133
Re: Did Brian ruin Heroes and Villains by adding the \
«
Reply #4 on:
October 02, 2013, 03:06:50 AM »
My favorite own version of H&V has the instrumental chorus after "You're under arrest!". Works great, actually takes up momentum instead of destroying it. It wasn't a good idea to add the bizarre vocals and organ drone and leave the bass and most of the percussion out. That's what ruins the momentum.
In case you're interested:
http://www.michael-fredrich.de/HeroesAndVillainsMicha.mp3
(pre-TSS.) Tell me what you think.
Logged
Ceterum censeo SMiLEBrianum OSDumque esse excludendos banno.
ash
Smiley Smile Associate
Offline
Posts: 121
Re: Did Brian ruin Heroes and Villains by adding the \
«
Reply #5 on:
October 02, 2013, 03:13:54 AM »
I don't think ruin is the right word but Brian clearly had trouble deciding what should happen after the first two verses given the amount of part 2's and other sections that followed . Also the transition from the end of verse 2 to whatever part 2 would be was a problem.
I would still love to hear the v1/v2/great shape/my children/3 score/barnyard? version (if that is indeed what was intended in October 1966). Those Durrie Parks acetates auctioned earlier this year must be heard as they apparently contained a Great Shape/My Children edit. That's a feature piece of the jigsaw.
I never felt the Cantina version was THE one but close. Funnily enough i was always underwhelmed by it but a few years back it came on in my local pub and sounded amazing. I was on my first pint so it wasn't the alcohol !
Apart from the momentum somehow being lost with the Bicycle Rider insert for Heroes it also left Do You Like Worms in trouble.
If anyone has a line to Al we should persuade him to get BW to play the Great Shape Heroes and sort out that original melody for Worms and play them on tour. I bet Al could sing the heck out of those two. That'd be 2 key parts of Smile essentially sorted. Then we could get on with arguing about The Elements and the Child Is Father lead vocal.
BTW I'm also intrigued as to how the part 3 from December on the Smile box fits in or joins on and to what. It's in E and seemingly lost in the mystery that is Heroes and Villains.
Logged
Cabinessenceking
Smiley Smile Associate
Offline
Posts: 2164
Re: Did Brian ruin Heroes and Villains by adding the \
«
Reply #6 on:
October 02, 2013, 03:21:59 AM »
Tbh, I think the 'cantina section' is the boring part. I agree the chorus could be considered tedious, but if he shortened it there would be no problem, but because he goes 2x D#m G#m it loses it's momentum. Which is why I mixed out of my mix!
Logged
Gabo
Smiley Smile Associate
Offline
Gender:
Posts: 1162
Re: Did Brian ruin Heroes and Villains by adding the \
«
Reply #7 on:
October 02, 2013, 04:16:11 AM »
The main problem of the Smile sessions was that Brian wasn't writing finished songs. I think the song would have been better if he actually wrote a chorus that logically followed the melody of the verse.
I do love the Smiley Smile Heroes and Villains, though. I agree that it's the best version of the song.
Logged
ash
Smiley Smile Associate
Offline
Posts: 121
Re: Did Brian ruin Heroes and Villains by adding the \
«
Reply #8 on:
October 02, 2013, 05:34:10 AM »
I disagree. I think for the most part the songs as compositions were essentially finished. It was during the recording process that BW went back re-recording sections/replacing sections. I believe that in almost every case at the beginning of sessions for heroes/worms/cabin/child/wonderful/wind chimes/surfs up/master painter-sunshine/vegatables/look/holidays BW could have sat down and played through the whole tune for the assembled musicians. Maybe the words weren't completely finalised but i think they were at the very least mostly there.
The Heroes version played for Humble Harv shows there was (at least initially) a clear plan.
I wish there were some composing demos knocking around.
Logged
Phoenix
Smiley Smile Associate
Offline
Gender:
Posts: 1212
Re: Did Brian ruin Heroes and Villains by adding the \
«
Reply #9 on:
October 02, 2013, 05:37:37 AM »
He didn't ruin it. He finished it! Without it, the song had NO chorus. Even as far out as "Good Vibrations" was at the time, it wouldn't have went to #1 without having a good hook in the refrain.
Logged
Disney Boy (1985)
Guest
Re: Did Brian ruin Heroes and Villains by adding the \
«
Reply #10 on:
October 02, 2013, 10:07:45 AM »
In answer to the question... No.
Logged
Rotat
Smiley Smile Associate
Offline
Gender:
Posts: 178
Re: Did Brian ruin Heroes and Villains by adding the \
«
Reply #11 on:
October 02, 2013, 10:39:44 AM »
I always preferred the Smiley version by far. It finishes the song nicely, the vocals are incredible and the bicycle rider part I always thought was a perfect chorus. I don't see how that could stifle the songs momentum at all. On the original versions, sections changed randomly into each other and didn't have much of a flow to begin with! So how could the single version ruin the songs momentum when it didn't have a straight momentum to begin with? I love the Smile versions with the different sections. I love how Smile in general is modular and changes from section to section randomly, even if it sounded unexpected and out of left field. There's no way that the public would get that Cantina version of H&V and it wouldn't have topped the charts as far as I'm concerned. Just look at the charts in '66 and '67. There were still lots of catchy pop songs high on the charts. GV was still a catchy pop song through & through ( even though the production was beyond what most other artists were doing).
I personally think it says a lot how well H&V did on the charts after SMile was abandoned. It didn't hit top 10 but it still hit top 20, not too shabby. I doubt any other version that was done for Smile would have done as well as GV as a single. Vegetables however I think would of had potential.
Logged
SonicVolcano
Smiley Smile Associate
Offline
Gender:
Posts: 279
Re: Did Brian ruin Heroes and Villains by adding the \
«
Reply #12 on:
October 02, 2013, 11:42:40 AM »
I'm not a big fan of the studio version, any studio version. Mostly because of the muddy mix.
Give me the In Concert version instead.
Logged
DonnyL
Smiley Smile Associate
Offline
Gender:
Posts: 1990
Re: Did Brian ruin Heroes and Villains by adding the \
«
Reply #13 on:
October 02, 2013, 12:09:48 PM »
The final Smiley version is the only one that sounds like a record to me. I remember hearing it on the radio when I was about 12 or 13 and really loving it. Let's not forget it WAS a hit. Bigger hit than 'Do It Again' or 'Darlin', and their biggest until 'Rock and Roll Music'.
Logged
http://www.trounrecords.com
bonnevillemariner
Smiley Smile Associate
Offline
Posts: 479
Re: Did Brian ruin Heroes and Villains by adding the \
«
Reply #14 on:
October 02, 2013, 12:58:03 PM »
Quote from: SonicVolcano on October 02, 2013, 11:42:40 AM
I'm not a big fan of the studio version, any studio version. Mostly because of the muddy mix.
Here Here! I can't take the mix. All those beautiful sessions and intricate instrumentation-- and we get that horrible mix. I've asked the question here a few times before but can never get a good answer: how did that mix result from those sessions? Was it just a matter of recording a recording of a recording? How could anybody not notice how muddy the finished product sounded. Or did they? Whenever I bring it up, nobody echoes my complaint.
My favorite H&V version is the one I made myself using the BWPS instrumental version with fly-in vocals from the sessions and other released versions.
Logged
Freddie French-Pounce
Smiley Smile Associate
Offline
Gender:
Posts: 1571
A.K.A. mrmoustachioto
Re: Did Brian ruin Heroes and Villains by adding the \
«
Reply #15 on:
October 02, 2013, 01:14:24 PM »
Quote from: DonnyL on October 02, 2013, 12:09:48 PM
The final Smiley version is the only one that sounds like a record to me. I remember hearing it on the radio when I was about 12 or 13 and really loving it. Let's not forget it WAS a hit. Bigger hit than 'Do It Again' or 'Darlin', and their biggest until 'Rock and Roll Music'.
I always read things like that and get briefly confused, being used to Do it Again being a Number 1 hit here.
God I see that thing EVERYWHERE. And Barbara Ann. Every single flippin' singles box.
Logged
Check out the Mono/Stereo Mix Breakdown podcast Mixology here:
https://mixology.podbean.com/
soniclovenoize
Smiley Smile Associate
Offline
Gender:
Posts: 422
Re: Did Brian ruin Heroes and Villains by adding the \
«
Reply #16 on:
October 02, 2013, 01:59:28 PM »
For some reason I went my whole life without every hearing the Smiley Smile version of H&V. So my very first exposure to
any
incarnation of the song was the Cantina mix on a friend's SMiLE mix sometime in 2001. I was astounded and dumbfounded! It was one of the most amazing songs I'd ever heard!
So when I eventually heard the Smiley Smile version of H&V I was really let down, because I felt that chorus belonged in Do You Like Worms, not H&V, and then the overall flow of the song seemed more disjointed, as compared to the Cantina version which I felt was more cohesive, even without an actual chorus. I also thought the vocal performances was flimsy and too whimsical (as compared to the "strong" vocals of the Cantina version) and the vocals were incredibly dry and didn't seem to match the beauty of the backing tracks (thanks to home-studio recording).
So yeah, I felt it was ruined, but not
just
by the chorus. But of course that's because my first exposure of it was the Cantina version.
Logged
My SMiLE "1967 Mix" -
https://albumsthatneverwere.blogspot.com/2018/12/the-beach-boys-smile-upgrade.html
Jukka
Smiley Smile Associate
Offline
Posts: 739
Re: Did Brian ruin Heroes and Villains by adding the \
«
Reply #17 on:
October 02, 2013, 06:06:22 PM »
Been listening to both versions now... If your goal is to make a "three-minute musical comedy", you go with the cantina version. If your goal is to make a hit single you go with the Smiley version.
Logged
"Surfing and cars were okay but there was a war going on."
RangeRoverA1
Smiley Smile Associate
Offline
Posts: 4336
I drink expired tea. wanna sip or spit?
Re: Did Brian ruin Heroes and Villains by adding the \
«
Reply #18 on:
October 03, 2013, 07:52:50 AM »
Quote from: Phoenix on October 02, 2013, 05:37:37 AM
He didn't ruin it. He finished it! Without it, the song had NO chorus. Even as far out as "Good Vibrations" was at the time, it wouldn't have went to #1 without having a good hook in the refrain.
I agree with everything you said, Phoenix! The song would've been monotonous without the "Bicycle Rider" segment.
There
where we hear grains of creativity that Brian had in mind - it's a vocal masterwork! One of the finest examples of the BBs' harmonizing. I like the verses a little bit more, though.
GV without Mike's famous hook=No.2 at most. And that'd be quite disappointing (esp. to Brian), taking into account how long they were recording it & how much money it cost them in total. At different studios, mind you also.
Logged
Short notice: the cat you see to the left is the best. Not counting your indoor cat who might have habit sitting at your left side when you post at SmileySmile.
Who is Lucille Ball & Vivian Vance Duet Fan Club CEO? Btw, such Club exists?
Zany zealous Zeddie eats broccoli at brunch break but doesn't do's & don't's due to duties.
Les P
Smiley Smile Associate
Offline
Posts: 598
Cheese Pizza and Apple Pie
Re: Did Brian ruin Heroes and Villains by adding the \
«
Reply #19 on:
October 03, 2013, 08:04:13 AM »
Quote from: Jukka on October 02, 2013, 06:06:22 PM
If your goal is to make a "three-minute musical comedy", you go with the cantina version. If your goal is to make a hit single you go with the Smiley version.
Agree. A version w/o Bicycle Rider might have worked for his early conception of a series of movements along with IIGS, Barnyard, etc, but only as an ambitious album track, not a single.
Logged
JK
Smiley Smile Associate
Offline
Posts: 6053
Maybe I put too much faith in atmosphere
Re: Did Brian ruin Heroes and Villains by adding the \
«
Reply #20 on:
October 03, 2013, 09:26:11 AM »
No.
Logged
"Ik bun moar een eenvoudige boerenlul en doar schoam ik mien niet veur" (Normaal, 1978)
You're Grass and I'm a Power Mower: A Beach Boys Orchestration Web Series
the Carbon Freeze | Eclectic Essays & Art
Gabo
Smiley Smile Associate
Offline
Gender:
Posts: 1162
Re: Did Brian ruin Heroes and Villains by adding the \
«
Reply #21 on:
October 03, 2013, 10:00:46 AM »
Quote from: ash on October 02, 2013, 05:34:10 AM
I disagree. I think for the most part the songs as compositions were essentially finished. It was during the recording process that BW went back re-recording sections/replacing sections. I believe that in almost every case at the beginning of sessions for heroes/worms/cabin/child/wonderful/wind chimes/surfs up/master painter-sunshine/vegatables/look/holidays BW could have sat down and played through the whole tune for the assembled musicians. Maybe the words weren't completely finalised but i think they were at the very least mostly there.
The Heroes version played for Humble Harv shows there was (at least initially) a clear plan.
I wish there were some composing demos knocking around.
Do you really think that "Barnyard" and "I'm In Great Shape" are a part of the
song
"Heroes and Villains?" They are completely individual songs, albeit part of the original conception of the "Heroes and Villains"
suite
, but completely individual compositions, no matter how short they are.
«
Last Edit: October 03, 2013, 01:31:50 PM by Gabo
»
Logged
Smilin Ed H
Guest
Re: Did Brian ruin Heroes and Villains by adding the \
«
Reply #22 on:
October 03, 2013, 10:55:36 AM »
Yep. And Gershwin should never have used woodwinds on Rhapsody in Blue.
Logged
Jukka
Smiley Smile Associate
Offline
Posts: 739
Re: Did Brian ruin Heroes and Villains by adding the \
«
Reply #23 on:
October 03, 2013, 12:17:08 PM »
Quote from: Smilin Ed H on October 03, 2013, 10:55:36 AM
Yep. And Gershwin should never have used woodwinds on Rhapsody in Blue.
Word. Some people just never get it right!
Logged
"Surfing and cars were okay but there was a war going on."
Smilin Ed H
Guest
Re: Did Brian ruin Heroes and Villains by adding the \
«
Reply #24 on:
October 03, 2013, 01:03:29 PM »
Word? Word! Brother... Or is that bro'? I was agreeing with you. Never mind...
Logged
Pages:
[
1
]
2
3
4
Jump to:
Please select a destination:
-----------------------------
Smiley Smile Stuff
-----------------------------
=> BRIAN WILSON Q & A
=> Welcome to the Smiley Smile board
=> General On Topic Discussions
===> Ask The Honored Guests
===> Smiley Smile Reference Threads
=> Smile Sessions Box Set (2011)
=> The Beach Boys Media
=> Concert Reviews
=> Album, Book and Video Reviews And Discussions
===> 1960's Beach Boys Albums
===> 1970's Beach Boys Albums
===> 1980's Beach Boys Albums
===> 1990's Beach Boys Albums
===> 21st Century Beach Boys Albums
===> Brian Wilson Solo Albums
===> Other Solo Albums
===> Produced by or otherwise related to
===> Tribute Albums
===> DVDs and Videos
===> Book Reviews
===> 'Rank the Tracks'
===> Polls
-----------------------------
Non Smiley Smile Stuff
-----------------------------
=> General Music Discussion
=> General Entertainment Thread
=> Smiley Smilers Who Make Music
=> The Sandbox
Powered by SMF 1.1.21
|
SMF © 2015, Simple Machines
Page created in 0.241 seconds with 21 queries.
Helios Multi
design by
Bloc
Loading...