I'd like to add:
Brian Wilson's Greatest Vibrations! (Mojo, 1998)
Based on votes from Timothy White, David Leaf, Don Was, David Dalton, Chris White, Peter Buck, Barney Hoskyns, John Cale, Andrew G. Doe, Kingsley Abbott, Steven Page, Joe Thomas, Mike Grant and Sean O'Hagan.
Nice. No Breakaway, though.
I'm surprised that Pet Sounds only made #11, in that collective bestalbums list.