I prefer CDs and vinyl over iTunes so this is not entirely representative, but according to my iTunes:
I have the same problem - I basically just play records, and asa such my itunes come to:
From There To Back Again: 40 plays
Isn't It Time: 38
Shelter: 36
All because TWGMTR took so long to come out on vinyl - basically the whole album is in my top 25 most played (bar summers gone - simply because it hasn't run to the final second due to the extended fade...