Do You Think The Beach Boys Can/Will Ever Perform...

[JohnMill]

"Pet Sounds" and/or "SMiLE" in their entirety? 

Given the warm reception the reunion tour has gotten, it's reasonable to think that perhaps this might not be the final Beach Boys tour inclusive of all the band members.  I'm wondering if they might consider giving one of those two records a go in their entirety maybe in a one night only special event type setting?  Thoughts?

[baseball95]

In one WORD..................................


NO !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Justin]

Pet Sounds - 40% chance they would.

SMiLE - 10% chance they would but only after they do Pet Sounds first.  So in a word..no?

[SMiLE Brian]

Hope so, but Mike Love isn't one to perform pet sounds or SMiLE.

[Nicko1234]

Could they?

Yes, of course. They would need some strings and horns for Smile but there`s no reason why these musicians couldn`t play those songs.

Would they?

No. The reason Brian played them is because his management new it would sell tickets and now that he`s done it that novelty has gone. The ticket-buying public wouldn`t be that interested so neither would Mike.

[Ron]

I doubt they will, because it would be a bad idea.  Pet Sounds & Smile are largely "Brian" dependent, and he's already done them.  They'd make much more money doing either new material or travelling jukebox stuff.  


Now I would like to see Brian & Mike do "I'm Waiting For the Day" or something.  HELL YEAH

[Jon Stebbins]

I don't know...do you think Brian Wilson could become a popular solo performer, and record and perform Smile, not to mention a string of solo CDs', and Dennis Wilson have a reissue of the year in Rolling Stone and Mojo, and a top 20 CD in the UK, and the Beach Boys release a Smile sessions box with a completed Smile LP edit which is also a reissue of the year in Rolling Stone, and the Beach Boys reunite for a wildly successful world tour and record and release a hit album of new material produced by Brian which becomes their highest charting debut of their career and highest charting LP of new material since 1965? I'll never say never again.

[Sheriff John Stone]

I don't think they'd do SMiLE, simply because I don't think very many of them, including Brian, would WANT to.

Now, Pet Sounds is different. I'm not holding out much hope for Brian to be touring with The Beach Boys after this reunion tour. But, because Brian calls the shots as to if and when The Beach Boys are reuniting, if - IF - he would ever want to do some shows with the guys again, I could see him wanting to do something other than a "hits" show (been there, done that), and could be inspired to resurrect old Pet Sounds.

[Chocolate Shake Man]

I don't know...do you think Brian Wilson could become a popular solo performer, and record and perform Smile, not to mention a string of solo CDs', and Dennis Wilson have a reissue of the year in Rolling Stone and Mojo, and a top 20 CD in the UK, and the Beach Boys release a Smile sessions box with a completed Smile LP edit which is also a reissue of the year in Rolling Stone, and the Beach Boys reunite for a wildly successful world tour and record and release a hit album of new material produced by Brian which becomes their highest charting debut of their career and highest charting LP of new material since 1965? I'll never say never again.

It's been an awesome 12 years or so, hasn't it?

[SBonilla]

No, and/or no.

[Ron]

I don't think they'd do SMiLE, simply because I don't think very many of them, including Brian, would WANT to.

Now, Pet Sounds is different. I'm not holding out much hope for Brian to be touring with The Beach Boys after this reunion tour. But, because Brian calls the shots as to if and when The Beach Boys are reuniting, if - IF - he would ever want to do some shows with the guys again, I could see him wanting to do something other than a "hits" show (been there, done that), and could be inspired to resurrect old Pet Sounds.

I think the chance would be much, much, much, much higher that he'd want to do a new album live.  Think about his Modus Oporandi, he does that all the time.  He did Pet Sounds live.  He did Smile live.  He did TLOS live... He did Gerswin Live, and I think he did the Disney album live as well! 

It's completely possible, and I'd say it's HIGHLY PROBABLE that in the future Brian will write, produce, and then tour with the Beach Boys a new concept album ala Smile, or TLOS. 

[oldsurferdude]

Hope so, but Mike Love isn't one to perform pet sounds or SMiLE.

Good-and you know they can do it very well without him.

[keysarsoze001]

In one of the pre-tour interviews, I remember Brian being asked if they would play SMiLE because of the success of the recent box set, and he said no way, he wouldn't want to do that. Then Mike said something like, "well, we should at least do 'Heroes and Villains', Brian", and Brian clarified that he wouldn't want to play the whole album. As for Pet Sounds, frankly they'd need to reassign the songs, or you'd end up with Brian singing, what, seven of the songs, at least. More, if he did all of Carl's parts, with Al doing WIBN, part of "I Know There's an Answer", and Mike doing maybe a verse here and there and then "Here Today"? And what would the Boys be doing during the two instrumentals? I don't think Brian would even want to ATTEMPT "Don't Talk" given how much of the higher notes he's delegated to Jeff over the last five years. If he doesn't want to try singing WIBN live anymore, I doubt he'd try "Don't Talk". So I think the real reason why not to do that album straight through would be how little of the rest of the band would be on there.

[AndrewHickey]

Bruce actually wanted the band to do Pet Sounds live in the late 90s, so I could see it happening.

[The Shift]

I hope they tour back-catalogue albums only once they've exhausted their ability to make new albums. On current form, I can't see them getting around to it!   

[keysarsoze001]

Unless they chose totally arbitrary albums to perform in full. Shut Down, Vol. 2 for example.

[SMiLE Brian]

Unless they chose totally arbitrary albums to perform in full. Shut Down, Vol. 2 for example.

filler songs would awesome live!

[Ron]

Sufer Girl Album Live?  I'm there dude. 

[SamMcK]

Unless they chose totally arbitrary albums to perform in full. Shut Down, Vol. 2 for example.

Sh*t "Cassius" Love Vs. "Sonny" Wilson would be amazing live!

[keysarsoze001]

Unless they chose totally arbitrary albums to perform in full. Shut Down, Vol. 2 for example.

Sh*t "Cassius" Love Vs. "Sonny" Wilson would be amazing live!

Actually, I would give a kidney to see that.

[SMiLE Brian]

Unless they chose totally arbitrary albums to perform in full. Shut Down, Vol. 2 for example.

Sh*t "Cassius" Love Vs. "Sonny" Wilson would be amazing live!

That skit would be the highlight of the tour. Bull Session with Big Daddy in the encore!

[Chocolate Shake Man]

Unless they chose totally arbitrary albums to perform in full. Shut Down, Vol. 2 for example.

Sh*t "Cassius" Love Vs. "Sonny" Wilson would be amazing live!

That skit would be the highlight of the tour. Bull Session with Big Daddy in the encore!

Absolutely. Dick Rising is right!

Sorry, that was really low brow.

[PhilSpectre]

Unless they chose totally arbitrary albums to perform in full. Shut Down, Vol. 2 for example.

My vote goes to The Beach Boys Perform Summer in Paradise Live in full tour. Brian takes Carl's vocal parts  .

[SMiLE Brian]

Unless they chose totally arbitrary albums to perform in full. Shut Down, Vol. 2 for example.

My vote goes to The Beach Boys Perform Summer in Paradise Live in full tour. Brian takes Carl's vocal parts  .

Don't forget KTSA and LA light concert with the full HCTN.

[SMiLE Brian]

Unless they chose totally arbitrary albums to perform in full. Shut Down, Vol. 2 for example.

Sh*t "Cassius" Love Vs. "Sonny" Wilson would be amazing live!

That skit would be the highlight of the tour. Bull Session with Big Daddy in the encore!

Absolutely. Dick Rising is right!

Sorry, that was really low brow.

Not at all rockandroll.