With old concert reviews lost, here is something to kick things off: a review I did of Smile as seen in March 2004, written for a webzine I contribute to. I did this right away upon my return, months before the album (or even official word of the album). I would do it differently now, but hey, that's life.
http://www.30music.com/etc.php?feat=13&action=searchFeat&term=