I wouldn't be surprised if both versions started out with Brian singing "I'm Goin Home!" over the Shortenin Bread riff on loop to his respective collaborators, and then from there Andy & Scott took the songs where they felt they should go.
Andy was like hell no dude, no Shortenin Bread on our soon to be unreleased album. We're turning this into some cowboy shizz
Scott was like.. Shortenin Bread it is sir!
The paley version has that change that I like thats missing fron TLOS..so I like it slightly better.
Agreed. If I had to choose, I'd also go with the Paley version. The B section is incredible. Great chords, and the sound effects add a nice emotion to it. I could hear Carl singing the hell out of that version.
Btw, both versions also share the "tag", kinda.