Surf's Up (Part 2)

[onkster]

Didn't Dom claim at one point that he actually HEARD the pt. 2 studio track? Or...if I recall a little better...he talked to someone who SAID they heard the track (probably erroneously), which then sent him off on a sanctimonious rant that it therefore had to exist?

My guess is that the session was booked but either not used, or if it was used, was something that wasn't completed. I seem to recall words to that effect somewhere.

[Roger Ryan]

Didn't Dom claim at one point that he actually HEARD the pt. 2 studio track? Or...if I recall a little better...he talked to someone who SAID they heard the track (probably erroneously), which then sent him off on a sanctimonious rant that it therefore had to exist?...

As I mentioned in the other thread on this topic, Dom stated in his 2005 MAKING OF SMiLE book that a completed version of "Surf's Up" from Jan. '67 resides in the vaults unreleased. I would take the quote regarding a part two with the same grain of salt.

[Andrew G. Doe]

Didn't Dom claim at one point that he actually HEARD the pt. 2 studio track? Or...if I recall a little better...he talked to someone who SAID they heard the track (probably erroneously), which then sent him off on a sanctimonious rant that it therefore had to exist?

My guess is that the session was booked but either not used, or if it was used, was something that wasn't completed. I seem to recall words to that effect somewhere.

I recall that being on the old Cabin Essence MB. I also recall it didn't end at all well.