Here are mine, at the moment:

1. The Format - Dog Problems
2. Pet Shop Boys - Fundamental
3. The Strokes - First Impressions of Earth
4. Belle & Sebastian - The Life Pursuit
5. The Pipettes - We Are the Pipettes
6. Sloan - Never Hear the End of It
7. The Divine Comedy - Victory for the Comic Muse
8. Ratatat - Classics
9. Bob Dylan - Modern Times
10. Drive-By Truckers - A Blessing and a Curse

Hon. mention to Band of Horses, the Legends, Keene Brothers, Curtains, Girl Talk, Arctic Monkeys, Sonic Youth

What a perfect hipster shell of a list -- overrated pap at the top, substantial stuff in the middle, obscurities at the bottom.  Good placement of BWPS, though.