I gave it four. I think I have a nostalgic bias towards "An American Band" though

I'm satisfied that this harmony analysis is right, so I'll change it accordingly. If anyone has anything to contribute to this friendly "argument" then feel free. I shan't be doing CATP: ST just yet, but soon...

Edit: Whoops, I can't edit it, since it was under my previous screen name. I'll work something out...!

I just want to intterupt and thank everyone, especially adamghost, for their work so far. This thread needs to become the standard reference!

I don't seem to have the other two on my IPod...what albums are they on?  I can look for 'em when I get home.

Wow, thanks!

A Young Man is Gone is on Little Deuce Coupe and the Lord's Prayer is on Hawthorne or (I think) the 1990 Christmas album CD.

Adam, can you please lend that harmony-defining ear of yours to the accapellas and confirm who's on 'em? Thanks!

A Young Man Is Gone
The Lord's Prayer
Auld Lang Syne
And Your Dream Comes True
Mama Says

Aha! I'm glad I was right about Bruce as well. 

Desper had gone into it I think in his book but definately online. I think David Marks talked about Brian drinking Melon liquer and singing it laying down tipsey.

I think that's Long Promised Road.

I was sure I heard Bruce on Feel Flows, but I could be wrong; oh, and I'll alter "Feet".

I think it's Al on the Feet middle-eight, too. Al is definitely the hardest guy to idenify - he can sounds identical to Brian, Carl and Mike at various times.

Edited - please see Page 38 for the corrected version.

Me too. That sounds like Bruce.


I'm gonna still be fairly scarce for a short while, but I'll get onto these, and address each point as they come up.

Aegir is right about the Bruce part in I Just Got My Pay, and I'll do a close up on Add Some Music...good idea.

This needs a lot of work, guys, particularly in the terminology of some of these vocals. Help!

Edited - please see corrected version on Page 38.

 

Sorry guys, still snowed under for a few more days....

Soon - sorry about this; bit busy and as you can tell, having computer / log-in problems - hopefully should be back to normal after the weekend, we'll do it then...