I remember when I got BWPS, I was in college. I skipped class to go to Best Buy to get the CD. I came right home and sat on my bed with headphone and listened. I was big into the SMiLE sessions and knew what I wanted to hear. But when I heard all of the created "links" that I assume Brian and Darian and maybe VDP put together....some of the magic went out. Those little snippets just seemed to far fetched to me to see part of what I wanted Smile to be.
When Brian said he created a whole "new third movement" I knew there had to be some creating....but like the start of the 3rd movement seems so out of place with the feeling of the songs. Now I doubt anybody who listened to it without hearing the original sessions could tell what music is newly created. But as a die hard fan, it seemed odd to me.
But to me it's Smile in the best form we can get it. We probably are never going to get a box set or anything close. So BWPS works for me.