Tonight's set consisted of 26 songs in 85 minutes. Here we go:
1. Little Saint Nick - Brian lead, but his voice cracked on nearly every line
2. The Man With All The Toys - Brian did fine, with Rob Bonfiglio doing the high parts
3. Santa's Beard - a bit too fast for Brian to nail
4. Merry Christmas Baby - Blondie did the first and last verse, Al did the rest. I got chills during Blondie's first verse. The crowd loved him all night. Very good.
5. Christmas Day - Al did this one, seemed a little timid.
6. Frosty the Snowman - Rob and the guys
7. Santa Claus is Coming to Town - More Rob with Brian on the "he sees you when.." parts
8. Christmasey - Surprised that Brian nailed this one given how fast the delivery is. But he actually did a good job.
9. What I Really Want For Christmas - a wonderful song, and Brian tried, but it doesn't work as well with a more spoken delivery
10. On Christmas Day - I think Brian sang most of this one. Don't remember.
11. Blue Christmas - Excellent Blondie rendition
12. We Three Kings - Rob and the gang. Brian didn't move.
13. Christmas Time Is Here Again - Al did a nice job.
14. I'll Be Home For Christmas - Another Rob lead.
15. O Holy Night - Blondie highlight
16. Run Rudolph Run - Another Blondie highlight.
After 6 straight songs without Brian opening his mouth, they did band introductions. It didn't include a brief jam for each member like it normally does. Then without a break they launched right into the hits set:
17. Wouldn't It Be Nice - More Rob. Brian did the bridge.
18. God Only Knows - Brian
19. Sloop John B - Al. Brian usually does a verse in this, but didn't bother.
20. Good Vibrations - Brian did the first 2 lines in the first two verses, then nothing else. Didn't even do Mike's "i'm picking up" part as usual.
21. Help Me Rhonda - Al
22. Barbara Ann - everyone but Brian, though Brian did look to really be playing piano for most of this and Rhonda.
23. Surfin USA - I think Brian only sang the first verse and Al did the rest
24. Fun Fun Fun - Al and group
25. White Christmas - Rob
26. Auld Lang Syne - everybody huddled around Brian singing.. including the opening act.. but Brian didn't sing.
As I mentioned, over the last word of ALS, Brian asked Paul if they were done and then hauled ass off stage. The rest of the guys stood around a bit being applauded. The crowd around me generally seemed to ignore Brian and just focus on the positive.. enjoying it more than me because I was just worried for him. It's only the 3rd date on the tour and this is not what I'm used to seeing from him. Blondie and Al really stole the show. Rob Bonfiglio did a fine job in Matt Jardine's place, but his mic was too low all night. And Nelson Bragg wasn't there, which I didn't realize beforehand.
A very bittersweet show. Brian clearly cannot perform like he used to and doesn't want to be there. As TV Forces said, before the end of ALS Brian look up and said,
"Is that it Paul"? The rest of the band took an awkward bow with out Brian there.
That being said, Al Blondie and the rest of the band were terrific. Blondie stole the show with Blue Christmas. Al was great on all his leads. While introducing Christmas Day he said "Brian and me are 2/5th of the Beach Boys. Can I say that?"
Maybe it's time to let Brian stay home and call the show Al Jardine Blondie Chaplin and the Brain Wilson band.