The Smiley Smile Message Board

Smiley Smile Stuff => General On Topic Discussions => Topic started by: AKA on June 13, 2018, 12:37:30 PM



Title: Tom Petty tried to sing like Carl in “Room at the Top.”
Post by: AKA on June 13, 2018, 12:37:30 PM
I’ve always been fascinated by Carl’s contributions to Tom Petty’s mid-‘90s music. Today, while Googling to try and learn a bit more about their relationship, I stumbled upon this, from 1999:

http://www.nydailynews.com/tom-petty-personal-rocker-emerges-post-divorce-funk-hard-rocking-first-person-album-article-1.828436

Quote
The result brought out a new heaviness in Petty's voice, epecially in the opening track, "Room at the Top." The artist says he was trying to ape the plaintive singing style of his friend Carl Wilson (of the Beach Boys), who had just died. "It was my hopeless attempt to sound like Carl," Petty explains. "I'm just pleased that more voices keep showing up because if you've got to sing a whole album it's good to have different sounds on it."

Tom doesn’t sound like Carl in “Room at the Top”; he sounds like Tom, but it’s one of my favorite Heartbreakers tunes.

An aside, during the making of that album (Echo), Tom was struggling with a crippling heroin addiction, a fact that wasn’t revealed publicly until a few years ago in Warren Zaines’ Tom Petty biography — which I highly recommend if you’re a Tom Petty fan.


Title: Re: Tom Petty tried to sing like Carl in “Room at the Top.”
Post by: Toursiveu on June 13, 2018, 02:20:09 PM
And we can hear Carl sing on "Hung Up and Overdue" from TP & the Heartbreakers' "She's the One" soundtrack, one of my favorite Tom Petty songs.


Title: Re: Tom Petty tried to sing like Carl in “Room at the Top.”
Post by: AKA on June 14, 2018, 08:08:02 AM
He’s also on “Honey Bee,” but he’s too low in the mix to hear.


Title: Re: Tom Petty tried to sing like Carl in “Room at the Top.”
Post by: KDS on June 14, 2018, 08:57:36 AM
I’ve always been fascinated by Carl’s contributions to Tom Petty’s mid-‘90s music. Today, while Googling to try and learn a bit more about their relationship, I stumbled upon this, from 1999:

http://www.nydailynews.com/tom-petty-personal-rocker-emerges-post-divorce-funk-hard-rocking-first-person-album-article-1.828436

Quote
The result brought out a new heaviness in Petty's voice, epecially in the opening track, "Room at the Top." The artist says he was trying to ape the plaintive singing style of his friend Carl Wilson (of the Beach Boys), who had just died. "It was my hopeless attempt to sound like Carl," Petty explains. "I'm just pleased that more voices keep showing up because if you've got to sing a whole album it's good to have different sounds on it."

Tom doesn’t sound like Carl in “Room at the Top”; he sounds like Tom, but it’s one of my favorite Heartbreakers tunes.

An aside, during the making of that album (Echo), Tom was struggling with a crippling heroin addiction, a fact that wasn’t revealed publicly until a few years ago in Warren Zaines’ Tom Petty biography — which I highly recommend if you’re a Tom Petty fan.


I remember reading that Room at the Top was a tribute to Carl, but I didn't know he was trying to sound like Carl, which is not really possible since their voices are so distinctly different. 


Title: Re: Tom Petty tried to sing like Carl in “Room at the Top.”
Post by: Tony S on June 15, 2018, 03:17:26 AM
I remember when I heard that Carl did background vocals on Honey Bee, I ran out and bought a copy of Petty's CD. Remember how dissappointed I was when it was impossible to discern that Carl was even on it, his voice was completely buried in the mix.


Title: Re: Tom Petty tried to sing like Carl in “Room at the Top.”
Post by: Rocker on June 15, 2018, 04:58:33 AM
I remember when I heard that Carl did background vocals on Honey Bee, I ran out and bought a copy of Petty's CD. Remember how dissappointed I was when it was impossible to discern that Carl was even on it, his voice was completely buried in the mix.


Yeah, it's hard to hear. This live performance (without Carl) gives an idea at what point to listen for him:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XtlBnxyXNGI


Title: Re: Tom Petty tried to sing like Carl in “Room at the Top.”
Post by: AKA on June 15, 2018, 11:45:27 PM
Tom talked a few years back about releasing a companion album to Wildflowers that would include songs that would have been on the originally envisioned two-disc version of Wildflowers. I wonder if Tom completed the project prior to his death and, if so, if Carl is on any of those tracks.


Title: Re: Tom Petty tried to sing like Carl in “Room at the Top.”
Post by: Toursiveu on June 16, 2018, 07:28:38 AM
Yes, the project, called "Widflowers : All the Rest" was finished. And has been finished for at least two years. It was supposed to come out in 2016 after the release of "Mudcrutch 2"... and then nothing happened. Fans have been waiting. We were told it would come out after TP & the Heartbreaker's tour in 2017. Then we thought that Tom's death would encourage Warner to release it... but we're still waiting.


Title: Re: Tom Petty tried to sing like Carl in “Room at the Top.”
Post by: RangeRoverA1 on June 16, 2018, 04:03:39 PM
[...] I didn't know he was trying to sound like Carl, which is not really possible since their voices are so distinctly different. 
Yes, apples & oranges.