|
Title: Year by Year Post by: Newguy562 on December 22, 2011, 02:28:36 PM They Went Head 2 Head..What Singles Did You Prefer?
She Loves You vs. Come On I Want To Hold Your Hand vs. I Wanna Be Your Man Can`t Buy Me Love vs. Not Fade Away A Hard Day`s Night vs. It`s All Over Now I Feel Fine vs. Time Is On My Side Ticket To Ride vs. The Last Time Help! vs. Satisfaction Yesterday vs. Get Off Of My Cloud We Can Work It Out/Day Tripper vs. 19th Nervous Breakdown Paperback Writer vs. Paint It Black Yellow Submarine/Eleanor Rigby vs. Mothers Little Helper/Lady Jane Penny Lane/Strawberry Fields Forever vs. Let`s Spend The Night Together/Ruby Tuesday Hello Goodbye/I Am The Walrus vs. We Love You/Dandelion Hey Jude vs. Jumpin` Jack Flash Get Back vs. Sympathy For The Devil Something vs. Honky Tonk Woman Let It Be vs. Brown Sugar Title: Re: Beatles Singles Vs. Rolling Stones Singles!!!! (Year by Year) Post by: pixletwin on December 22, 2011, 02:30:06 PM The Beatles on every account accept for Paint It Black.
Title: Re: Beatles Singles Vs. Rolling Stones Singles!!!! (Year by Year) Post by: rab2591 on December 22, 2011, 02:38:11 PM Jumpin Jack Flash and Hey Jude are rival contenders. But I gotta go with The Beatles on this one.
I'm not a fan of the Rolling Stones (and I have tried). Idk, just not my style, so I can't really judge this one. But I LOVE jumpin jack flash. Title: Re: Beatles Singles Vs. Rolling Stones Singles!!!! (Year by Year) Post by: Newguy562 on December 22, 2011, 02:45:24 PM The Beatles on every account accept for Paint It Black. do you jsut like the beatles more period or just the singles? :)Title: Re: Beatles Singles Vs. Rolling Stones Singles!!!! (Year by Year) Post by: Newguy562 on December 22, 2011, 02:45:48 PM Jumpin Jack Flash and Hey Jude are rival contenders. But I gotta go with The Beatles on this one. why not? :/ because they do a lot of blues?I'm not a fan of the Rolling Stones (and I have tried). Idk, just not my style, so I can't really judge this one. But I LOVE jumpin jack flash. Title: Re: Beatles Singles Vs. Rolling Stones Singles!!!! (Year by Year) Post by: pixletwin on December 22, 2011, 02:55:58 PM The Beatles on every account accept for Paint It Black. do you jsut like the beatles more period or just the singles? :)I like both the Beatles and The Stones but I have always felt the Beatles were a better group. I also never really liked the Stones' productions. But I know their songs and side by side I'll choose the Beatles everytime except for Paint It Black, which is a really powerful record. Title: Re: Beatles Singles Vs. Rolling Stones Singles!!!! (Year by Year) Post by: Newguy562 on December 22, 2011, 02:58:27 PM my choices are:
She Loves You I Want To Hold Your Hand Not Fade Away A Hard Day`s Night I Feel Fine vs. Time Is On My Side = Tie Ticket To Ride vs. The Last Time = Tie Satisfaction Get Off Of My Cloud 19th Nervous Breakdown Paperback Writer Mothers Little Helper/Lady Jane Penny Lane/Strawberry Fields Forever vs. Let`s Spend The Night Together/Ruby Tuesday = Tie :) Hello Goodbye/I Am The Walrus vs. We Love You/Dandelion = Tie :) Hey Jude vs. Jumpin` Jack Flash = Tie :) Get Back Something Brown Sugar Wow i guess it's even. :) i'm still more of a beatles fan than a stones fan but the stones are definately in my top ten favorites. Title: Re: Beatles Singles Vs. Rolling Stones Singles!!!! (Year by Year) Post by: rab2591 on December 22, 2011, 03:15:49 PM Jumpin Jack Flash and Hey Jude are rival contenders. But I gotta go with The Beatles on this one. why not? :/ because they do a lot of blues?I'm not a fan of the Rolling Stones (and I have tried). Idk, just not my style, so I can't really judge this one. But I LOVE jumpin jack flash. Yeah. One day I'm sure I'll get into them - but for now I just can't do it. Idk, I like beauty in music (which is why I LOVE the Beach Boys) - but The Rolling Stones are more raw sounding than I like. Title: Re: Beatles Singles Vs. Rolling Stones Singles!!!! (Year by Year) Post by: Newguy562 on December 22, 2011, 03:30:34 PM Jumpin Jack Flash and Hey Jude are rival contenders. But I gotta go with The Beatles on this one. why not? :/ because they do a lot of blues?I'm not a fan of the Rolling Stones (and I have tried). Idk, just not my style, so I can't really judge this one. But I LOVE jumpin jack flash. Yeah. One day I'm sure I'll get into them - but for now I just can't do it. Idk, I like beauty in music (which is why I LOVE the Beach Boys) - but The Rolling Stones are more raw sounding than I like. Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: RangeRoverA1 on January 16, 2017, 05:56:20 AM Quote What Singles Did You Prefer? She Loves You vs. Come On I Want To Hold Your Hand vs. I Wanna Be Your Man - neither Can`t Buy Me Love vs. Not Fade Away A Hard Day`s Night vs. It`s All Over Now I Feel Fine vs. Time Is On My Side - neither Ticket To Ride vs. The Last Time - neither Help! vs. Satisfaction Yesterday vs. Get Off Of My Cloud We Can Work It Out/Day Tripper vs. 19th Nervous Breakdown Paperback Writer vs. Paint It Black - neither Yellow Submarine/Eleanor Rigby vs. Mothers Little Helper/Lady Jane - this is great bunch of songs! :3d Penny Lane/Strawberry Fields Forever vs. Let`s Spend The Night Together/Ruby Tuesday - bookends. SFF is overrated except that weird ending. Hello Goodbye/I Am The Walrus vs. We Love You/Dandelion Hey Jude vs. Jumpin` Jack Flash Get Back vs. Sympathy For The Devil - Mick & Paul sound really cool there! Something vs. Honky Tonk Woman - cool performance in Hyde Park by the Stones in tribute concert for Brian. Let It Be vs. Brown Sugar - neither Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: JK on January 16, 2017, 06:27:38 AM Interesting old thread you've dug up, Marianne! I did what you did (with apologies):
She Loves You vs. Come On I Want To Hold Your Hand vs. I Wanna Be Your Man Can`t Buy Me Love vs. Not Fade Away A Hard Day`s Night vs. It`s All Over Now I Feel Fine vs. Time Is On My Side Ticket To Ride vs. The Last Time Help! vs. Satisfaction - neither Yesterday vs. Get Off Of My Cloud - neither We Can Work It Out/Day Tripper vs. 19th Nervous Breakdown Paperback Writer vs. Paint It Black - neither Yellow Submarine/Eleanor Rigby vs. Mothers Little Helper/Lady Jane Penny LaneStrawberry Fields Forever vs. Let`s Spend The Night Together/Ruby Tuesday Hello Goodbye/I Am The Walrus vs. We Love You/Dandelion Hey Jude vs. Jumpin` Jack Flash Get Back vs. Sympathy For The Devil Something vs. Honky Tonk Woman - neither Let It Be vs. Brown Sugar - neither I've come to appreciate the Stones more in recent years... Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: RangeRoverA1 on January 16, 2017, 07:09:21 AM Apology accepted. :D [Btw can go by RR if it's too long name to type :)]
I've come to appreciate the Stones more in recent years... Even Mick?Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: JK on January 16, 2017, 07:27:59 AM Apology accepted. :D [Btw can go by RR if it's too long name to type :)] I've come to appreciate the Stones more in recent years... Even Mick?Mick... well, yes, I suppose so (to a degree). It was visiting Brian Jones's home town of Cheltenham and reading about his musical and other exploits that aroused my recent interest in mainly the early Stones. I tend to lose interest fast after Exile on Main Street... Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: Chocolate Shake Man on January 16, 2017, 07:30:13 AM Here's mine!
She Loves You vs. Come On I Want To Hold Your Hand vs. I Wanna Be Your Man Can`t Buy Me Love vs. Not Fade Away A Hard Day`s Night vs. It`s All Over Now I Feel Fine vs. Time Is On My Side Ticket To Ride vs. The Last Time Help! vs. Satisfaction Yesterday vs. Get Off Of My Cloud We Can Work It Out/Day Tripper vs. 19th Nervous Breakdown Paperback Writer vs. Paint It Black Yellow Submarine/Eleanor Rigby vs. Mothers Little Helper Penny Lane/Strawberry Fields Forever vs. Let`s Spend The Night Together/Ruby Tuesday Hello Goodbye/I Am The Walrus vs. We Love You/Dandelion Hey Jude vs. Jumpin` Jack Flash Get Back vs. Sympathy For The Devil Something vs. Honky Tonk Woman Let It Be vs. Brown Sugar Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: KDS on January 16, 2017, 12:17:38 PM Here are my choices. Mostly Beatles She Loves You I Want To Hold Your Hand Can`t Buy Me Love A Hard Day`s Night I Feel Fine Ticket To Ride Help! Yesterday We Can Work It Out/Day Tripper Paint It Black Mothers Little Helper/Lady Jane Penny Lane/Strawberry Fields Forever Hello Goodbye/I Am The Walrus Jumpin` Jack Flash Sympathy For The Devil Something Brown Sugar Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: The Cincinnati Kid on January 16, 2017, 12:23:21 PM Beatles on everything except for Jumpin' Jack Flash. Maybe Satisfaction over Help! depending on the day.
Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: Alex on January 16, 2017, 03:12:42 PM For a second there I thought NewGuy/ghost/nobody/summerinparadise.flac was back!
Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: pixletwin on January 16, 2017, 05:04:29 PM Nice necropost. So long as I'm here:
I pick ALL Beatles except for the one against Paint It Black. That song transcends in a way that few Stones songs ever would. Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: The Cincinnati Kid on January 16, 2017, 05:18:23 PM Nice necropost. So long as I'm here: I pick ALL Beatles except for the one against Paint It Black. That song transcends in a way that few Stones songs ever would. I see your opinion is still the same after five years. ;) Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: pixletwin on January 16, 2017, 05:49:16 PM Nice necropost. So long as I'm here: I pick ALL Beatles except for the one against Paint It Black. That song transcends in a way that few Stones songs ever would. I see your opinion is still the same after five years. ;) haha I didn't even notice that I had posted! Good to see that I wasn't lying! :lol Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: ♩♬🐸 Billy C ♯♫♩🐇 on January 16, 2017, 09:40:13 PM For a second there I thought NewGuy/ghost/nobody/summerinparadise.flac was back! Me too...why was this ancient topic bumped ?! ??? Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: RangeRoverA1 on January 17, 2017, 12:36:08 AM This is nice un-inflammatory thread about comparing Beatles & Stones songs. Do you see any harm in topic subject? Because I don't. People replied here, in nice civil way. Newguy is banned & you know it so what's the problem? Besides, lots of people bumped ancient threads over the years & somehow I get the notice. Let people talk.
Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: JK on January 17, 2017, 12:59:06 AM This is nice un-inflammatory thread about comparing Beatles & Stones songs. Do you see any harm in topic subject? Because I don't. People replied here, in nice civil way. Newguy is banned & you know it so what's the problem? Besides, lots of people bumped ancient threads over the years & somehow I get the notice. Let people talk. I agree entirely. It's a timeless subject that clearly still appeals, judging from the number of new posts. Nobody's slagging anyone or anything off, no extraneous elements have crept in to drag it down... If only all topics were like this! Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: RangeRoverA1 on January 17, 2017, 01:09:39 AM I agree entirely. It's a timeless subject that clearly still appeals, judging from the number of new posts. Thank you, john. Agree with your points, esp. the last.Nobody's slagging anyone or anything off, no extraneous elements have crept in to drag it down... If only all topics were like this! Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: KDS on January 17, 2017, 05:35:49 AM This is nice un-inflammatory thread about comparing Beatles & Stones songs. Do you see any harm in topic subject? Because I don't. People replied here, in nice civil way. Newguy is banned & you know it so what's the problem? Besides, lots of people bumped ancient threads over the years & somehow I get the notice. Let people talk. I didn't even notice it was an ancient thread. Sometimes when I pull this site up on my phone, the dates can be quite tiny. Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: ♩♬🐸 Billy C ♯♫♩🐇 on January 17, 2017, 11:57:38 AM Most other forums look down upon bumping a thread that is several years old. Not a rule here, but I've been put in "time out" on other boards for having done that. Other than that, though, I'm ok with it being revived, and yeah it's a good topic
Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: RangeRoverA1 on January 17, 2017, 12:25:52 PM Yes but it's other forums. They've got nothing to do with this board's rules. Why ask why this thread was bumped if it's a good topic?
Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: JK on January 17, 2017, 12:28:14 PM Most other forums look down upon bumping a thread that is several years old. Not a rule here, but I've been put in "time out" on other boards for having done that. Other than that, though, I'm ok with it being revived, and yeah it's a good topic Thanks, Billy. I've always assumed that time stands still out here in the icy wastes of cyberspace, lol. I've heard that too, about other boards being intolerant of bumping old stuff, and never understood the logic behind it. Anyway, onward and upward... Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: ♩♬🐸 Billy C ♯♫♩🐇 on January 17, 2017, 12:30:25 PM Yes but it's other forums. They've got nothing to do with this board's rules. Why ask why this thread was bumped if it's a good topic? Because it's force of habit. I'm a member of quite a few forums. Thanks JK for understanding. In any case, it's done now. Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: RangeRoverA1 on January 17, 2017, 12:52:30 PM Quote I've always assumed that time stands still out here in the icy wastes of cyberspace. Same here.Quote Because it's force of habit. I'm a member of quite a few forums. Well, OK. Hopefully, in future I don't get told these things again. & to Alex, that "Newguy/nobody etc." joke is very old & doesn't even make sense. ::) If it wasn't posted, this all could be avoided. Just saying.Now, carry on. Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: pixletwin on January 17, 2017, 12:56:22 PM I'd like to buoy what Billy said. Any other forum, if I had seen a necropost like that I would have locked the thread and given the member who necroposted it an infraction.
But here, yeah. A thread goes necro and repeat myself like an idiot. :lol Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: Jay on January 17, 2017, 01:15:56 PM Any other board would also give a "time out" to a poster who replies in a condescending way after a mod tells you that the matter is closed, as RR did above.
Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: ♩♬🐸 Billy C ♯♫♩🐇 on January 17, 2017, 01:20:34 PM Any other board would also give a "time out" to a poster who replies in a condescending way after a mod tells you that the matter is closed, as RR did above. Correct. Thankfully, I'm not that kind of mod....unless I'm continually pushed Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: RangeRoverA1 on January 17, 2017, 01:27:50 PM I wasn't condescending to Billy. I said "OK". What are you talking about?
I replied to Alex, that his joke was old & had nothing to do with the topic at hand. I don't even care who started thread - Newguy, nobody, whoever. I just read the OP, if it's sth. I can add, I revive it. That's all. Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: Jay on January 17, 2017, 01:30:44 PM I'm talking about every word after "ok".
Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: ♩♬🐸 Billy C ♯♫♩🐇 on January 17, 2017, 02:10:33 PM Quote Hopefully, in future I don't get told these things again. ^That part, like I'm going to forget or something. In any case, it's done now. Second time I've said that. Let's move back on topic. Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: KDS on January 17, 2017, 02:23:08 PM Looking at the list, it's quite a marvel looking at the quality of songs released by the Stones and The Beatles during the 60s. Add the rest of the British Invasion groups and The Beach Boys also.
I'm fairly confident we'll never see anything like that in music again. Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: ♩♬🐸 Billy C ♯♫♩🐇 on January 17, 2017, 02:29:21 PM And even if we did have the quality of songs, the production would kill it. And, on the offchance the production was good, there's hardly an industry these days, at least as far as physical media sales
Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: Jay on January 18, 2017, 01:19:17 PM And even if we did have the quality of songs, the production would kill it. And, on the offchance the production was good, there's hardly an industry these days, at least as far as physical media sales Ok, here's an interesting "thought experiment". If we ever did have the same quality of songs that came from the 60's, how would we know? Think about it, the people in the 60's didn't know their music was "special" until after the fact. What was that saying....hindsight is 20/20? ;DTitle: Re: Year by Year Post by: bluesno1fann on January 18, 2017, 09:12:04 PM She Loves You (as much as I love Come On)
I Wanna Be Your Man Not Fade Away It's All Over Now I Feel Fine The Last Time Satisfaction Get Off Of My Cloud (by an inch) 19th Nervous Breakdown Paint It Black Mothers Little Helper/Lady Jane Let's Spend The Night Together/Ruby Tuesday We Love You/Dandelion Jumpin' Jack Flash Sympathy For The Devil Something Brown Sugar 3 for the Beatles.... that's surprised even me actually Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: ♩♬🐸 Billy C ♯♫♩🐇 on January 18, 2017, 09:30:18 PM And even if we did have the quality of songs, the production would kill it. And, on the offchance the production was good, there's hardly an industry these days, at least as far as physical media sales Ok, here's an interesting "thought experiment". If we ever did have the same quality of songs that came from the 60's, how would we know? Think about it, the people in the 60's didn't know their music was "special" until after the fact. What was that saying....hindsight is 20/20? ;DVery good point Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: alf wiedersehen on January 18, 2017, 11:43:55 PM I blame the internet for fostering all this previous-decade-focused navel gazing.
Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: KDS on January 19, 2017, 05:49:45 AM How about this one for the Beatles and Stones
Love is Strong vs Free As a Bird You Got Me Rocking vs. Real Love Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: JK on January 19, 2017, 12:20:56 PM How about this one for the Beatles and Stones Love is Strong vs Free As a Bird You Got Me Rocking vs. Real Love I only know "FAAB" so I'll get back to this after listening to the other three... Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: KDS on January 20, 2017, 05:30:15 AM How about this one for the Beatles and Stones Love is Strong vs Free As a Bird You Got Me Rocking vs. Real Love I only know "FAAB" so I'll get back to this after listening to the other three... Out of the two Beatles tracks, I actually think Real Love is the better song. Free As a Bird is cool in that it features leads from John, Paul, and George, but I think John's vocal is stronger in Real Love, and the song has a better flow to it. Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: JK on January 20, 2017, 05:46:28 AM Love is Strong vs Free As a Bird You Got Me Rocking vs. Real Love The two splendid Beatles tracks win for me hands down. Recent Stones stuff doesn't seem to register with me----sorry, Mick and cohorts. Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: pixletwin on January 20, 2017, 08:33:38 AM Love is Strong vs Free As a Bird You Got Me Rocking vs. Real Love The two splendid Beatles tracks win for me hands down. Recent Stones stuff doesn't seem to register with me----sorry, Mick and cohorts. I'm with you. Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: KDS on January 20, 2017, 09:14:18 AM Love is Strong vs Free As a Bird You Got Me Rocking vs. Real Love The two splendid Beatles tracks win for me hands down. Recent Stones stuff doesn't seem to register with me----sorry, Mick and cohorts. I think most recent Stones albums have some decent tracks. I think You Got Me Rocking (off the uneven Voodoo Lounge) could set side by side with some of their early 70s songs. Steel Wheels and A Bigger Bang were both decent LPs. Although the less said about Bridges to Babylon, the better. Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: JK on January 21, 2017, 07:12:11 AM Love is Strong vs Free As a Bird You Got Me Rocking vs. Real Love The two splendid Beatles tracks win for me hands down. Recent Stones stuff doesn't seem to register with me----sorry, Mick and cohorts. I think most recent Stones albums have some decent tracks. I think You Got Me Rocking (off the uneven Voodoo Lounge) could set side by side with some of their early 70s songs. Steel Wheels and A Bigger Bang were both decent LPs. Although the less said about Bridges to Babylon, the better. I lose interest after the departure (and death) of Brian Jones, the one exception being the stunning Exile on Main Street... Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: RangeRoverA1 on January 25, 2017, 06:19:04 PM How about this one for the Beatles and Stones Never liked both "Free" & "Real". I pick the Stones.Love is Strong vs Free As a Bird You Got Me Rocking vs. Real Love Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: KDS on January 26, 2017, 05:58:46 AM How about this one for the Beatles and Stones Never liked both "Free" & "Real". I pick the Stones.Love is Strong vs Free As a Bird You Got Me Rocking vs. Real Love When Free as a Bird and Real Love were released, it was just a treat to have "new" Beatles songs. Over 20 years after the novelty has worn off, I think both hold up surprisingly well. Title: Re: Year by Year Post by: pixletwin on January 26, 2017, 06:47:42 AM How about this one for the Beatles and Stones Never liked both "Free" & "Real". I pick the Stones.Love is Strong vs Free As a Bird You Got Me Rocking vs. Real Love When Free as a Bird and Real Love were released, it was just a treat to have "new" Beatles songs. Over 20 years after the novelty has worn off, I think both hold up surprisingly well. Agree. Both are solid songs. However, when in certain moods, I do prefer the original home demo versions of those songs. There is something about the simplicity of them which actually enhances them. |