The Smiley Smile Message Board

I had no idea this existed.

Scroll down and you'll see it.

http://obscuresound.com/?p=423

I'd love to see Brian tackle one of Dan's songs.

Hmm...when one of my two favorite artists covers my other favorite...  :smokin

That's pretty cool. My favorite one was the Pet Sounds cover.

This is actually pretty awful. Here Today is cool because of the bassline, but like the blogger stated, expected duds. Pet Sounds is the only acceptable one, imo.

-edit-
I gotta admit, Im diggin the 'Dont Talk' cover, possibly because its one of my favoritest songs. Has that Plastic Ono Band feel to it. Sort of like idigworm's cover of 'Little Bird'

lol. i can say with glee that it sounds exactly like i guessed it might.

I liked it. Then again, Dan's voice is an acquired  taste. Don't think that was the best song for him out of Brian's catalogue, but I still liked it.

I like Daniel, too, somewhat (although not as much as you, based on your avatar). I certainly don't think of him as the genius many people do. In fact, I think his illness causes people to overrate his abilities--I believe that's a common thing for people to do with artists. But I do like some of his performances and plenty of his songs. It says a lot about my feelings about him, though, that I prefer the Discovered Covered tribute disc to his own work most of the time.

I actually liked his music before I knew his story. But, yeah, you're right...I've noticed that too, and it annoys the hell out of me. Same thing with Brian.

What I love about Daniel's music  (esp. the earlier work) is the wordplay (he comes up with some real zingers, i.e. "I caught a flat down memory lane") and the fact the he does write some catchy as hell songs.

Maybe my admiration for him music has something to do with why Brian's mid-late 70s demos are my favorite music he's done besides SMiLE/BWPS.

I like Daniel Johnston, but I absolutely hate that cover of God Only Knows.

This is probably for two reasons:
1) I'm only familiar with his earlier stuff, so to hear him not singing in that high-pitched voice, not backed by just piano is odd
2) It sounds like he never heard the song before and this is the first take of him trying to record it. They must've got him on a really bad day or something.

I'd say about half of his recorded output could be described that way.

Also, according to his bandmates in the recent documentary about him, that may be close to tue--they claim when they met him, Daniel claimed he had never heard pet sounds.

True, but if you hear it with the director commentary, the director laughs at that point because there is  one of Daniel's "audio diaries" that mentions how much he loves the Beach Boys, esp. "In My Room". It would be odd for him not to have heard PS. Of course, "odd" is par for the course, but hey...

BTW...here's an interesting thing about the doc. There's a small section where they actually talk about Brian (complete with a ripoff of Sloop John B in the background), and the director  AND DANIEL'S PARENTS start talking about Brian's Landy-written bio as if it were written by Brian! I had to :lol at that.

Oh, I agree taht daniel had to be putting them on about having never heard ps. That''s why I said they claimed it...as much a student of classic pop as he was, there is no way he'd be unaware.

As for the scene about the book...I had the same reaction. Those poor people, I suppose (as is the case with many who just take things at face value), they'd have no idea how bogus that book is.

that cover is terrible......and i like daniel johnston..........at least his early stuff.......i guess he really deteriorated or something..........fu***** awful

Daniel Johnston IS just as much as musical genius as Brian Wilson... at least his early stuff. "Living Life" is classic! =)

Amen to that.

Honestly, I never heard of the guy. But, when I read things like the above post, maybe I oughta find out! :police:

Check out his early stuff...

a lot of it was recorded in his home with minimal and cheap equipment; very scratchy, very coarse.... but sh*t, something about his music that just grabs you and you just fall in love with it no matter how sad or true it is. His music is not something you'll like at first listen, but giving it enough time, it'll take control of your heart.

If you are looking for well-performed and well-produced music or anything in the style of Brian Wilson, you'll be disappointed. I am a semi-fan of D.J. and not trying to dissuade you (although I strongly would disagree with the DJ is a genius idea); I'm just warning you, it has nothing musically in common. Daniel sings mostly out of key, plays piano/keys or guitar in uneven time and basic (although catchy and clever) progressions and writes simple songs. They are sometimes very effective and catchy, and are done with all the heart DJ has been able to muster at any given moment, but they are a far cry technically from what many fans of Beach Boys music might be looking for--hence the various posts on this thread and others we've done about his work.

You might want to go to allmusic or something and listen to some of the preview snippets before buying.

If a sonic comparison between Dan & Brian can be made, it'd be the Love You-era demos.

Sheriff...I recommend watching the DVD "The Devil & Daniel Johnston" first. Even if you end up not liking the music, it is a very good story. Be warned,though...Brian is briefly discussed, and the way it is so might piss you off, or at the very least make you roll your eyes...

Good call, The What of Whom. If nothing else, I think most music fans would like the story of the documentary. And Brian fans might relate to certain aspects of Daniel's illness. But you're right about the part when they discuss BBs/BW...

Well of course he is no 'brian wilson'... but seriously, he's one hell of an artist of many abilities; art, film and of course, music...

He's the only guy that can't play an instrument or sing worth merda... but foda, the way his art comes together, it's magic to my ears. Like a 'brian wilson', Johnston's stuff ranges anywhere from the adorable Surf's Up (Living Life, Speeding Motorcycle) to the rigid cornball of Johnny Carson (The Lennon Song, Casper the Friendly Ghost).

Again, and just like the artsiest of BW stuff, it's not for everyone. So don't hate when you think it's worst music you've ever heard. And yes, that God Only Knows cover blows.

Living Life:

Hold me like a mother would
Like I always knew somebody should
though tomorrow don't look that good
Well, it just goes to show
Though people say we're an unlikely couple
I'm seeing double of you

Oh.
This is life
This is life
And everything's all right
Living living living living living living living living life

Oh
I'm hoping though
because I'm learning to cope
with the emotion-less mediocrity
Oh.
Day-to-day living

Oh
I can't help being restless
When everything's so tasteless
And all the colors seem to have faded away.

Oh.
This is life
This is life
And everything's all right
Living living living living living living living living life

Hold me like a mother would
Like I always knew somebody should, yeah.
though tomorrow don't look that good
Well, just goes to show
Though people say we're an unlikely couple
Doris Day, and Mott the Hoople
 
Ohhh,..

Ahh...

Life!