|
Title: My thoughts on Rock Pamplins Endless Wave Post by: Magic Transistor Radio on March 07, 2019, 08:37:50 PM First of all, I am not here to cast judgements. I have noticed many Beach Boys fans are convinced this book is as bad as Wouldn't It Be Nice, written with Eugene Landy. But I am always interested in hearing different perspectives. I don't see anything that is unbelievable in this book so far. Though he seems to give great details in stories that happened 40 years ago! Word for word conversations and specific gestures seems suspicious. Either Rocky has an amazing memory, he is paraphrasing what generally happened, or he is making stuff up. What I am curious about is if anyone has asked Marilyn about this book. If she says it's true. Brian may not be the best one to ask.
Title: Re: My thoughts on Rock Pamplins Endless Wave Post by: Magic Transistor Radio on March 12, 2019, 10:11:40 AM This was a question, I was hoping would be answered. Many have accused Rocky to make up stuff and that his book is not trustworthy. Do we know for certain this is the case? I don't think I would include getting years or certain timelines wrong. Every Beach Boys has misremembered certain details of things. I'm guessing his quotes of conversations were more a paraphrase unless he has a photographic memory or kept a journal at the time. But I am more concerned with the general events. Personally, I don't see any contradictions with The Real Beach Boy by Jon Stebbins or any other writings from that era.
Title: Re: My thoughts on Rock Pamplins Endless Wave Post by: ♩♬🐸 Billy C ♯♫♩🐇 on March 12, 2019, 10:25:58 AM I myself haven't read it, and after reading some of Rocky/Ron's posts in the other thread, I don't have any real plans to do so
Title: Re: My thoughts on Rock Pamplins Endless Wave Post by: urbanite on March 12, 2019, 12:16:06 PM Asked Marilyn about it? Wouldn't that be more than a little bit awkward.
Title: Re: My thoughts on Rock Pamplins Endless Wave Post by: Magic Transistor Radio on March 12, 2019, 03:27:51 PM Asked Marilyn about it? Wouldn't that be more than a little bit awkward. Perhaps there's something I'm missing? I haven't finished the book yet. So far, Marilyn comes across as supportive of Rocky in the book. Maybe things change later. Title: Re: My thoughts on Rock Pamplins Endless Wave Post by: Clinton on March 12, 2019, 05:33:38 PM Asked Marilyn about it? Wouldn't that be more than a little bit awkward. Perhaps there's something I'm missing? I haven't finished the book yet. So far, Marilyn comes across as supportive of Rocky in the book. Maybe things change later. From what I remember from the Heroes and Villains book, Marilyn did not describe Rocky in a positive light at all and said that the stories he shared in the book were all BS.. Title: Re: My thoughts on Rock Pamplins Endless Wave Post by: Clinton on March 12, 2019, 05:36:02 PM Asked Marilyn about it? Wouldn't that be more than a little bit awkward. Perhaps there's something I'm missing? I haven't finished the book yet. So far, Marilyn comes across as supportive of Rocky in the book. Maybe things change later. From what I remember from the Heroes and Villains book, Marilyn did not describe Rocky in a positive light at all and said that the stories he shared in the book were all BS.. Title: Re: My thoughts on Rock Pamplins Endless Wave Post by: Clinton on March 12, 2019, 05:36:31 PM Asked Marilyn about it? Wouldn't that be more than a little bit awkward. Perhaps there's something I'm missing? I haven't finished the book yet. So far, Marilyn comes across as supportive of Rocky in the book. Maybe things change later. From what I remember from the Heroes and Villains book, Marilyn did not describe Rocky in a positive light at all and said that the stories he shared in the book were all BS.. Title: Re: My thoughts on Rock Pamplins Endless Wave Post by: Magic Transistor Radio on March 12, 2019, 07:51:57 PM Asked Marilyn about it? Wouldn't that be more than a little bit awkward. Perhaps there's something I'm missing? I haven't finished the book yet. So far, Marilyn comes across as supportive of Rocky in the book. Maybe things change later. From what I remember from the Heroes and Villains book, Marilyn did not describe Rocky in a positive light at all and said that the stories he shared in the book were all BS.. Heroes and Villains was written long before this book. But I guess there are stories about him in Heroes and Villains? Title: Re: My thoughts on Rock Pamplins Endless Wave Post by: ♩♬🐸 Billy C ♯♫♩🐇 on March 12, 2019, 09:00:25 PM According to the book the two of them had an affair.* Rocky also made some disgusting comments about her in it. Of course there are several things in the book that are questionable , so who knows?
*Confirmed elsewhere, though Title: Re: My thoughts on Rock Pamplins Endless Wave Post by: Magic Transistor Radio on March 13, 2019, 07:32:43 AM According to the book the two of them had an affair.* Rocky also made some disgusting comments about her in it. Of course there are several things in the book that are questionable , so who knows? *Confirmed elsewhere, though I will say that in Endless Wave, Rocky portrays a flirtatious relationship between he and Marilyn. I am only in chapter 8, so I don't know if he mentions the affair in this book or not. Title: Re: My thoughts on Rock Pamplins Endless Wave Post by: SMiLE Brian on March 13, 2019, 08:37:38 AM H&V was groundbreaking book for 1980s despite the minor errors on musical albums.
|