Title: Alternate studio versions of BB songs performed live? Post by: CenturyDeprived on May 06, 2016, 11:58:33 AM How many examples of known alternate studio versions of BB songs have been performed live?
For example, the Love & Mercy version with an extra verse (that was performed at least once in the late '80s) does not have a known studio version counterpart, does it? Or perhaps it does, but it's not been booted. How many songs that have known alternate studio versions were ever performed live with the same alternate arrangement/parts? Title: Re: Alternate studio versions of BB songs performed live? Post by: You Kane, You Commanded, You Conquered on May 06, 2016, 12:00:53 PM How many examples of known alternate studio versions of BB songs have been performed live? For example, the Love & Mercy version with an extra verse (that was performed at least once in the late '80s) does not have a known studio version counterpart, does it? Or perhaps it does, but it's not been booted. How many songs that have known alternate studio versions were ever performed live with the same alternate arrangement/parts? Not sure if it counts but occasionally when doing Good Vibrations they would sing the discarded "hum dee dum" part. Title: Re: Alternate studio versions of BB songs performed live? Post by: CenturyDeprived on May 06, 2016, 12:04:39 PM How many examples of known alternate studio versions of BB songs have been performed live? For example, the Love & Mercy version with an extra verse (that was performed at least once in the late '80s) does not have a known studio version counterpart, does it? Or perhaps it does, but it's not been booted. How many songs that have known alternate studio versions were ever performed live with the same alternate arrangement/parts? Not sure if it counts but occasionally when doing Good Vibrations they would sing the discarded "hum dee dum" part. Good one. How many times was this performed live before this alternate version was released/booted/known about? I believe it was done in the late '70s at some point, right? I assume that nobody outside of the band would have known at the time (in the late '70s) that this part was from an alternate studio version? Title: Re: Alternate studio versions of BB songs performed live? Post by: You Kane, You Commanded, You Conquered on May 06, 2016, 12:10:04 PM Good one. How many times was this performed live before this alternate version was released/booted/known about? I believe it was done in the late '70s at some point, right? I assume that nobody outside of the band would have known at the time (in the late '70s) that this part was from an alternate studio version? IIRC the infamous drunk Carl performance of GV has the hum dee dums and it's from the late 70's. I think it was mostly done during that period because of stuff like the aforementioned drunken Carl. Title: Re: Alternate studio versions of BB songs performed live? Post by: KDS on May 06, 2016, 12:43:23 PM Help Me Rhonda has changed a bit.
There's the version from In Concert that's slower. There's also "Help You, Rhonda" from MiC. Title: Re: Alternate studio versions of BB songs performed live? Post by: Joel Goldenberg on May 06, 2016, 08:47:40 PM Was the alternate (first) lyrics version of Good Vibrations performed by Brian during the Smile tour?
Title: Re: Alternate studio versions of BB songs performed live? Post by: The Real Barnyard on May 08, 2016, 01:20:10 AM They have always played live the alternate version of Summer In Paradise.
|