The Smiley Smile Message Board

Here we are at the round you all have been waiting for (and possibly dreading!!!).  :o

Vote for your LEAST FAVORITE TRACK

Votes will be tallied on October 5th.

Wouldn't It Be Nice
You Still Believe in Me
That's Not Me
Don't Talk (Put Your Head on My Shoulder)
I'm Waiting for the Day
Let's Go Away for Awhile
Sloop John B
God Only Knows
I Know There's an Answer
Here Today
I Just Wasn't Made for These Times
Pet Sounds
Caroline, No

My vote goes to... Sloop John B

That's Not Me.

voting for Pet Sounds even though I feel like an evil child-murderer for doing so

That's Not Me. Hearing Mike Love's vocals on this track bring down what is otherwise a perfect Side A

Pet Sounds

I Know There's An Answer

This is just unfair lol.

I'm Waiting for the Day is my choice.

Let's Go Away For A While

Pet Sounds

Sloop John B   ...can't even imagine what my next pick will be. 

Pet Sounds

I guess it's That's Not Me

I Know There's An Answer

Pet Sounds

Let's Go Away For a While

Let's Go Away For A While....

And it's not even close, really.

‍

Pets

Man I can tell this is already getting pretty divided. Personally I love Let's go away for a while and it's one of my favorite bb tracks ever.

My vote goes to Pet Sounds

Pet Sounds.

Let's Go Away

HERE TODAY, but only for the alternately teenybopper and mean-spirited lyrics. I like The Beach Boys for their positivity.

OK, I changed my mind.  I do like the end of That's Not Me enough to compensate for Mike's vocal.  So..

Pet Sounds

I Know There's An Answer!

Had it been called Hang On To Your Ego, I may have saved this for now. Oh well...

Here Today

I don't think anyone would have sounded better singing that one. Mike's vocals on Pet Sounds are, to me, among his very best.

Let's Go Away for Awhile

I feel like I've chopped an arm off

I'll vote for "Pet Sounds", as much as I don't want to. Great song, I just don't find myself going back to it as much as the others.

Mr.Twin, are we gonna do Smile?

I could say Sloop John B doesnt belong on the LP

But That's Not Me.  :p (this one)

ok. I am changing my vote to Run James Run.  ;D

Let's Go Away for Awhile

This is like Sophie's Choice...

"Pet Sounds"

Let's Go Away for Awhile

I was stunned to see this sweep the recent instrumental thread.  It's great (just not as great as the rest of the album) but I don't even think it's the best instrumental on Pet Sounds!

Am I the only one that doesn't like Don't Talk ?

damn you must be crazy. one of the best love songs ever written

A lot of people on this board will be saying Moz from Oz is crazy. Well they've been sayin' that for years. Ain't nothin' new about that. (Sorry, just watched the Mike Love Hall of Fame speech earlier today) But seriously, I'm all for a love song, this one just doesn't do it for me I'm afraid

Don't Talk (Put Your Head on My Shoulder)

You Still Believe In Me. I'm serious.

First round isn't so difficult for me: "Pet Sounds"

All these tracks are just so great  :'(

I'll have to go with "That's Not Me."

I Know There's An Answer

I know there's an answer

I won my first girlfriend over in high school by showing her Don't Talk. It's just so sublime. I don't know how you can like The Beach Boys and not like that magical piece of music...

Wow shaping up to be one of the most revealing threads on this board ever. Can't believe some of the votes so far!

Pet Sounds for me.

you sir, are a dangerous man!



my vote to PS(track)

Mike's vocal on That's Not Me is awesome.
That is all.

Yep.

Not to me.  Mike is great on this.  Mike was at a peak on this album.  This whole album is perfect.

I loooove That's Not Me. One of the most perfect songs in the canon.

I'm with you there. It's one of my favourites on the album. Very calm and understated.

Some passionate voting. It's only gonna get worse folks!  :lol

If a Pet goes deaf will anyone hear the Sounds it makes? (http://www.sideshowcollectors.com/forums/images/smilies/survivor.gif)

Vote for your LEAST FAVORITE TRACK

Votes will be tallied on October 29th.

Wouldn't It Be Nice
You Still Believe in Me
That's Not Me
Don't Talk (Put Your Head on My Shoulder)
I'm Waiting for the Day
Let's Go Away for Awhile
Sloop John B
God Only Knows
I Know There's an Answer
Here Today
I Just Wasn't Made for These Times
Caroline, No

Round#1 - Pet Sounds October 27

My vote goes to... Sloop John B

You Still Believe in Me

Let's Go Away For Awhile

I Know There's An Answer

That's Not Me

No passionate voting from me… can't bring myself to kill any of these.

Here Today

Let's Go Away For a While

I Know There's An Answer

i know there's an answer

Let's Go Away For Awhile

Let's Go Away For Awhile

I'm pretty sure that noboby else is going to vote for this song for another few rounds...

Caroline, No.

I don't dislike it (as I don't dislike anything on Pet Sounds), but I think this is an overrated song and I never understood why it seemed to be one of Brian's personal favorites. It's too slow, there's nothing special about the melodies or the arrangement... It just bores me a little bit. Sorry.

Let's Go Away For Awhile

Let's Go Away for Awhile

I Just Wasn't Made for These Times

Let's Go Away for a While

May as well finish this one off, as sad as it may be.

Let's Go Away For Awhile

I didn't appreciate "Let's Go Away For A While" until I was standing in a super purty place watching the sun set and it came up on random. The second half of the song is when things get really, really good. From there, I listened to it on a loop for quite a while. I encourage you guys to do the same :'( it's way too good to go this early.

I guess I'll vote for "Sloop John B". It's so good, it just holds a bit less interest for me than the rest of the songs.

Sloop John B

Okay, Sloop can wait.  I am sure it won't last long with or without my help.  And there are no bad songs here.          Why so much picking the instrumentals?

Why so much picking the shanty?

My vote: I'm Waiting For The Day

Don't Talk (Put Your Head On My Elbow).

As Carole Kaye said "it's unearthly slow."   :lol

Love that:  "Unearthly." 

Thats Not Me

But its going to happen anyways. What if one you REALLY like gets voted off next!?

I don't get the aversion that some of you have to voting. You'd think voting will erase a track from all time and space for an eternity.  :lol

Let's Go Away for a While.

A great song, like many on this greatly applauded album, but my least favourite as per the key criteria of this enjoyable online party game.

‍

HERE TODAY. Dumb, mean spirited lyrics. Definitely the slightest song on the album.

Unearthly, indeed. Otherworldly. That sort of thing. ^_______________^

I Know There's An Answer!

It might be my favorite song on Pet Sounds.

Thank goodness someone else has wimped out! Can't do it either.

Good to be in good company. Every one of these tunes has moved me at some stage, every one of them has had some meaning… even the press gang shanty.

That's Not Me

I Know There's An Answer

 did I say before, Thats Not Me?

sloop

"Let's Go Away for Awhile"

I Know There's An Answer


Hang On To Your Ego on the other hand... ;D

It's in my top three favorites on the album. I don't think Carole was being negative when she said that...

Bummed "Pet Sounds" got the boot.

My vote remains, "Let's Go Away For Awhile"

Agree ('bout CK's opinion).  The full quote is: "Pretty tune.  Unearthly slow.  Imagine playing this without any lead (like the rest of his tracks). You still had to keep good time no matter how slow.  Nice chord changes...almost classical, especially with string overdubs.  Lots of suspensions and close harmonies, something Brian was getting more and more into" - see the little green book in the PSS box - p68

Voting was spread pretty thin this round. I think every track was voted out by someone.  :o

Let's Go Away For A While has gone away.... FOR EVER!!!!! (http://www.sideshowcollectors.com/forums/images/smilies/survivor.gif)

Vote for your LEAST FAVORITE TRACK

Votes will be tallied on November 1st.

Wouldn't It Be Nice
You Still Believe in Me
That's Not Me
Don't Talk (Put Your Head on My Shoulder)
I'm Waiting for the Day
Sloop John B
God Only Knows
I Know There's an Answer
Here Today
I Just Wasn't Made for These Times
Caroline, No

Round#1 - Pet Sounds October 27
Round#2 - Let's Go Away for Awhile October 30

My vote goes to... Sloop John B

I Know There's An Answer

This feels wrong, but...

You Still Believe In Me

That's not me

I Know There's An Answer

Here Today

Here Today.

You Still Believe in Me.

I like it, but when I'm in a hurry in the car it tends to be one of the tracks I skip.  Sorry.

You Still Beliebe In me

That's not me

That's Not Me

I Just Wasn't Made for These Times

That's Not Me

I love that it features the Boys on the backing track but (maybe because of that) compared to the rest of the album, it sounds very sparse and out of place.  Also the ending just kinda goes away (to the city?) and feels kind of weak.

Don't talk (Put your head on my shoulder)

I Know There's An Answer!

‍

Wouldn't It Be Nice. Only due to overplaying it.

Sloop John B

Does anyone think that God Only Knows will NOT be the last one standing?

I'm Waiting For The Day When This Gets Voted Out

Here Today

i know there's an answer

I Know There's an Answer

I Know There's an Answer

I Know There's An Answer (though there's probably not a good one as to why this song outlasted "Let's Go Away for Awhile")

That's Not Me…interesting to see the votes now that the instrumentals have been unfairly voted out prematurely

Let's Go Away for Awhile is an underrated track IMO.

I Know There's An Answer

That's Not Me.

It sounds superb, but it just kinda doesn't really go anywhere (which perhaps was Brian's intention, but still...)

Sad to see so many votes for I Know There's An Answer - that echo-y piano just get me every time. Love it!

Sloop John B

(NOT A VOTE POST, PIXLETWIN). I realize "That's Not Me" may not be one of the strongest tracks, but I'm surprised to see it getting voted out so early. To me, that is one of those tunes that embodies the "Pet Sounds mentality" - one of the reasons this album changed my life and changed my perspective on other music and society. The instrumentation isn't sparse - I love the abstract floor hits from Dennis, and the way the tambourine alternately contrasts those hits. It's got that infamous plucked guitar and bass sound - the one that everyone goes for when they try to do a PS soundalike. The lyrics! Haven't you ever done something on your own, been scared, and realized it's not for you? You wanna go back to the way things were? Maybe you can, maybe you can't....And finally, Mike's vocals. They might not be perfect, they might not be beautiful - but they are so suited to this song. For a guy who might not have been enthused with the sessions, he puts his heart and soul into it and there's undeniable emotion and attachment in his voice. The harmony swell going into the bridge is sublime, and the vocal take-over from Mike to Brian is a moment of bliss.

Yeah.

Yeah! It's the best song on Pet Souds, IMO.  Actually, IMHO, That's not me is a bottle version of Pet Sounds in its entirety. 

Could be out next round, tho'...

Whatevs, the deal is to vote for "your" (ie, you) least fav; suck it up if the poll results aren't too your liking.

That goes doubly for those english boys who can't bring 'em 'selves to cast a vote.  You know what Mike Love would say...

Great post. However it is a post that could probably be made for every track on Pet Sounds. It's a beautiful and nearly flawless album. I think at different points in time nearly every track has been a favorite of mine. That is what is making the voting so interesting.

@Alan, we are agreed on the English boys thing.  It's almost has if they think the Sonic Police are going to crash in their brains and take away any enjoyment they ever had from a song they vote off. :p

Hearing the isolated vocals from the PS box set is really something. For all of the beauty in the harmonies and orchestration through the whole album, the song with just a couple instruments and one voice really is wonderful - and effective.

I read a Rolling Stone article from 1966 criticizing the album for it's lush nature throughout...maybe they didn't hear this one?

I've always thought of it as a perfect counterpoint to the rest of the the songs.

I Know Theres An Answer and it's "GOOD DAY SIR!"(http://www.sideshowcollectors.com/forums/images/smilies/survivor.gif)

Vote for your LEAST FAVORITE TRACK

Votes will be tallied on November 3rd.

Wouldn't It Be Nice
You Still Believe in Me
That's Not Me
Don't Talk (Put Your Head on My Shoulder)
I'm Waiting for the Day
Sloop John B
God Only Knows
Here Today
I Just Wasn't Made for These Times
Caroline, No

Round#1 - Pet Sounds October 27
Round#2 - Let's Go Away for Awhile October 30
Round#3 - I Know There's an Answer November 1

My vote goes to... Sloop John B. Still.

I'm Waiting for the Day

Still waiting for the day.

Don't Talk (Put Your Head On My Shoulder)

You guys off your meds?  :o

You Still Believe In Me

Still voting for Here Today.

Same as always, "I Just Wasn't Made for These Times."

Don't Talk (Put Your Head on My Shoulder)

Sloop John B    Changed to help save a favorite.   

Here Today

Don't Talk (Put Your Head on My Shoulder)

That's Not Me

Beautiful, but it just goes... nowhere...

Sloop John B

either Here Today or That's Not Me.
I guess I'll vote for That's Not Me

Wow this is getting hard

Sloop john b

Here Today...u so gud...

You Still Believe In Me (I guess  :()

Caroline, No[t that great]

Yep.  And, lovin' it!

Don't talk (Put your head, on my, shoulder)

Sloop John B

I'm waiting for the day

Are YOU off YOUR meds voting for the second best song* on the album, EcoHanger?

*imo


wot? The contrast between Mike and Brian's parts was always totally unexpected, to me, as was the ending. Holy sh*t, that ending.

Also, I vote for "Sloop John B" I GUESS

Sloop John B
Ick

I'm Waiting For The Day

Here Today

That's Not Me

That's Not Me

WIBN

‍

Caroline, No

Pretty little song, but kind of overrate, imo

You cut that out this instant!

That's Not Me

I will if you stop voting for Sloop!  ;D

That's Not Me

You just lost your opinion privileges.

No one objected when I voted for WIBN  in the last round (and motivated why).

I'm waiting for the day

That Snot Me has been wiped out. (http://www.sideshowcollectors.com/forums/images/smilies/survivor.gif)

Vote for your LEAST FAVORITE TRACK

Votes will be tallied on November 5th

Wouldn't It Be Nice
You Still Believe in Me
Don't Talk (Put Your Head on My Shoulder)
I'm Waiting for the Day
Sloop John B
God Only Knows
Here Today
I Just Wasn't Made for These Times
Caroline, No

Round#1 - Pet Sounds October 27
Round#2 - Let's Go Away for Awhile October 30
Round#3 - I Know There's an Answer November 1
Round#4 - That's Not Me

My vote goes to... Sloop John B. Still.

Gotta be either Here Today because I never cared for that song, or Sloop John B because it doesn't fit in at all.
I choose Here Today for now

Shoot I'd gone away for a while or I would have voted Thats Not Me once again.

Well I'm, Here Today. < (this one)

This hurts, but.. "Here Today"

You Still Believe In Me.

"Here Today" has a great set of lyrics - not sure what's not to like about them.

Right now you think that she's perfection,
this time is really an exception,
well you know...I hate to be a downer,
but I'm the guy she left before you found her.

Don't Talk (Put Your Head On My Shoulder)

wow.

That's Not Me is one of my favorite songs of all-time by anyone. whoever said it goes nowhere is not hearing what i hear. the multiple key changes are classic BW and some of his best. the sentiment is quite relatable, full of longing and personal revelation. And the vocal trade-off between Brian and Mike is pretty unique.

how anyone would pick it over a cover of a folk tune, regardless of the fabulous arrangement, is beyond me.

She made me feel so bad
She made my heart feel sad
She made my days go wrong
and made my nights so long


not so great.

I like those, too. Haven't you ever been in that situation? Rhyme scheme is a bit simple....but that's exactly what it feels like.

Don't Talk (Put Your Head on My Shoulder)

Sloop John B

Still Caroline, No

Still overrated, IMnotsohumbleO

I Just Wasn't Made for These Times

sloop

Caroline No (I never listen to PS version... I prefer '73 Carl's lead)

You Still Believe In Me.

Gonna have to go with You Still Believe in Me.

My daughter likes Sloop John B too much to vote that one out yet.

WIBN

Sloop John B

Slooooooooooooop John Bee

Can't believe "That's Not Me" was voted off already, nor can I believe so many votes for "You Still Believe In Me" and "I Just Wasn't Made For These Times" in the last few rounds, those are by far my two favorite songs on the album. :'( I'm no expert and I realize it doesn't guarantee a good song, but I don't know if Brian ever wrote anything more technically complex and interesting as the stuff that's going on in "These Times" before or after.

Exactly. I'd say those four lines are about as accurate a description of heartache/break as has ever been put to song.

I'm waiting for the day

Caroline No

Sloop John B

Caroline, Nope

Don't Talk (Put Your Head on My Shoulder)

Sloop

Sloop Dogg

Nearly impossible to decide.  All these tracks and the next three in my order are extremely close and probably change, day to day.  That said:

Don't Talk (Put Your Head on My Shoulder)

Caroline, No.

Here Today.

I Just Wasn't Made For These Times.

And heed how they match the music… building up, snatches of thought, no time to dwell… leading to the "gotta keep in mind LOVE IS HERE TODAY AND IT'S GONE TOMORROW…"crescendo… It's perfect.

How you folks can vote off even one of these songs is beyond me!

It's just not as good as the remaining songs. Even Sloop John B, which doesn't fit in, is a better song
But once Here Today is gone, My vote will be the Sloop

agree fully.


I vote for I Know There's An Answer. I place Sloop and That's Not Me above that one. I love Hang On To Your Ego however.

SLOOP JOHN B GONE!(http://www.sideshowcollectors.com/forums/images/smilies/survivor.gif)

Vote for your LEAST FAVORITE TRACK

Votes will be tallied on November 7th

Wouldn't It Be Nice
You Still Believe in Me
Don't Talk (Put Your Head on My Shoulder)
I'm Waiting for the Day
God Only Knows
Here Today
I Just Wasn't Made for These Times
Caroline, No

Round#1 - Pet Sounds October 27
Round#2 - Let's Go Away for Awhile October 30
Round#3 - I Know There's an Answer November 1
Round#4 - That's Not Me November 3
Round#5 - Sloop John B November 5

My vote goes to... Here Today.

Here Today

I'm Waiting For The Day, yet again

The instrumental break in Here Today is, to me, one of the highlights of the album - which, as it's one of the greatest albums ever made, makes it one hell of a f**king highlight!!

I Just Wasn't Made For These Times.

You Still Believe In Me is the last one I can vote out without feeling like a terrible human being.

Don't f--kin' talk, ok.  Put your head on my shoulder, would ya, baby.

Car-o-line No

You Still Believe in Me

Here Today, Tomorrow It's Gone!!!

Caroline, No
The lack of backing vocals did it for me.

Here Today

You Still Believe In Me

Caroline, No

Its getting tougher now.

Here Today I suppose.

Don't talk

Here Today

In an effort to save my beloved "Don't Talk"... I vote "Here Today"

Caroline No

"Sloop John B" is gone??!!?  I can't believe that so many people chose one of the Beach Boys all time best songs as their "LEAST FAVORITE TRACK" on this album.  Not "which one fits least" or whatever but the TRACK (recording or a song) they like LEAST of all the ones that remained. 
Rocks.  In.  Heads.

 :p


Anyway, my vote goes (again) to "Don't Talk (Put Your Head on My Shoulder)".  It's a FANTASTIC song but I actually do like it less than all the other remaining tracks on the list.

I agree with leggo, this just got a lot tougher for me too.

Don't Talk (PYHOMS)

Don't talk

I Just Wasn't Made for These Times

you serious Clark? (from christmas vacation)...

Wow.  I can understand the Instrumentals going first (which were actually my favorites on the album when I was a kid!!) but That's Not Me? and I Know There's An Answer?

What's next, You Still Believe In Me?  Wasn't Made For These Times?

 >:(

I don't want to play with you guys anymore  :'(

I know Carole wasn't being overtly negative when she said that.  But she did say that.  As in it was challenging to get her groove on to.  And I agree.  For me as a listener, it weights down the proceedings.  Busts the mojo, a tad.  Yes, it develops and blossoms into a wonderful flower  :-D -- but it weighs "unearthly" on me after the righteous, bitchin' That's Not Me.  Fcking love That's Not Me.

I'm stickin' with my vote.  

I shouldn't like "Don't Talk" because I'm generally not into slow songs at all, but that one is just so hypnotic. It can't go yet.

Tell me about it. If it were up to me Sloop John Be would have been out in round#2 and I Know There's An Answer would still be in the running.  :'(

Here Today                  That's Not Me is the one I miss the most, from what's gone.  I had nothing to do with voting off those instrumentals either.

Amen!

Even though I'm a mono guy, there's many moments on the stereo that just have to be cranked.  I Know There's An Answer is one of 'em.  Even the backing track (from the session box) is a highlight.  What an insane production!  The off-kilter piano riff.  The clarinet/oboe(?) breaks (just what are those chords?!) The banjo.  And the harmonica!  O' the blessed harmonica!

 :thud

IWFTD

Caroline, No.  (Can't stand how it's sped up....it is sped up, right?)

Yeah, but it's hardly the munchkins.

Here Today (and by great coincidence) Gone Today! (http://www.sideshowcollectors.com/forums/images/smilies/survivor.gif)

Vote for your LEAST FAVORITE TRACK

Votes will be tallied on November 9th

Wouldn't It Be Nice
You Still Believe in Me
Don't Talk (Put Your Head on My Shoulder)
I'm Waiting for the Day
God Only Knows
I Just Wasn't Made for These Times
Caroline, No

Round#1 - Pet Sounds October 27
Round#2 - Let's Go Away for Awhile October 30
Round#3 - I Know There's an Answer November 1
Round#4 - That's Not Me November 3
Round#5 - Sloop John B November 5
Round#6 - Here Today November 7

My vote goes to... Don't Talk.

Don't Talk (Put Your Head on My Shoulder)

I remain constant -- I Just Wasn't Made for These Times

Don't Talk (Put Your Head On My Shoulder).  It's a beautiful song, but it does the least for me of the remaining tracks.

HEY! WAITADADGONEMINIT - I didnt get enough time to vote FOUL FOUL FOUL

I would have dumped Here Today though.  >:D

And now a regretable,,, yea with great regret, yes I do regret that I will regreatfully make this
regretamongus choice to off load

Dont Talk  :'( :'(

I'm waiting for the day (when I get to vote for a different song)

I Just Wasn't Made For These Times.

DT (PYHOMS)

Don't talk

You Still Believe In Me.

Don't Talk (Put Your Head on My Shoulder)

You Still Believe In Me

Caroline No

Hmm.  If I'm picking from my least favorite remaining tracks it would have to be between You Still Believe in Me and Don't Talk. 

I'm going with Don't Talk this time. 

Don't Talk should last a bit longer.
I'm Waiting For The Day!

Edit:  Listened to Don't Talk & You Still Believe in Me...

Changing my vote to You Still Believe in Me

I still don't believe in You Still Believe in Me

Don't Talk

carol i know

Caroline No

It looks like "Don't Talk" is leaving...  :-[

I vote "I'm Waiting for the Day"

Based on how this is going, I might have to call both Let's Go Away for Awhile and Sloop John B underrated Pet Sounds tracks, if that's possible.

My vote goes Don't Talk.

I just wasn't made for these times.

Caroline, No.

MODS: is it possible to ban anyone who tries to vote off a Pet Sounds track please. This is a fan forum, not a British care home…

For the sake of God, John!  What would Churchill think of you crying off to the mods over some damm yank tunes?

Cast your bloody vote, Manning.  I say good-day to you, Sir!

( :lol, and with the utmost respect to your valued opinions)

Caroline, No

Don't Talk (Put Your Head on My Shoulder)

CARE OH LINE OH!

You Still Believe In Me.

I'm waiting for the day

I'm Waiting for the Day

I'm Waiting for the Day

I'm Waiting For The Day

Don't Talk Out Your Votes to the Next Round. (http://www.sideshowcollectors.com/forums/images/smilies/survivor.gif)

Vote for your LEAST FAVORITE TRACK

Votes will be tallied on November 11th

Wouldn't It Be Nice
You Still Believe in Me
I'm Waiting for the Day
God Only Knows
I Just Wasn't Made for These Times
Caroline, No

Round#1 - Pet Sounds October 27
Round#2 - Let's Go Away for Awhile October 30
Round#3 - I Know There's an Answer November 1
Round#4 - That's Not Me November 3
Round#5 - Sloop John B November 5
Round#6 - Here Today November 7
Round#7 - Don't Talk (Put Your Head on My Shoulder) November 9

My vote goes to... Caroline No.

you scumbags of the earth! damn you and your families to the eternal flames. arrgh T_T


I'm Waiting For The Day (because it it half the song Don't Talk is)

damnit Damnit DAMNIT!!!
I'M WAITING FOR THE DAY WHEN I GET AN EXPLANATION
TO WHY DON'T TALK WAS VOTED OUT!!!

Because 11 people voted for it.
3 voted for IJWMFTT
7 voted for IWFTD
5 voted for YSBIM
and 6 voted for Caroline No.

 ;D

That's just sad.
Anyway, IWFTD gets my vote. Easily the weakest remaining track

caroline no! (I mean... yes! it must go!)

Caroline, No

Damn straight.

a complete travesty of justice!

I'm Waiting for the Day
I'm Waiting for the Day
I'm Waiting for the Day
I'm Waiting for the Day
I'm Waiting for the Day

Rinse and repeat.

Caroline, No NO NO NO NO NO!!!!!!!

Well I know which three I would hope to be in the final three.

IWFTD isnt one them so I dont mind dumping it.

I'm guessing the final three are God Only Knows, IJWMFTT, and Caroline No!

Ouch!  These are all great tracks but I guess I have to go with "I'm Waiting for the Day".

Caroline No

Day

Staying consistent -- I Just Wasn't Made for These Times

Caroline No

I'm Waiting for the Day

I'm Waiting for the Day

Caroline, No.

I personally rate Don't Talk above IJWMFTD, IWFTD and Caroline No.

Still, it's gone now (you vicious bastards!!) so my vote goes for I Just Wasn't Made For These Times.

I would be very surprised if Wouldn't It Be Nice wouldn't make it to the final three.

You Still Believe In Me

Caroline, No

I'm Waiting For The Day       

There seem to be a lot of people voting for "Caroline, No" already, so I'm not sure it will make it to the last round (much as I would like it to…)

Caroline, No

 Just wasn't made for these times

I'm waiting for the day

‍

It's attitudes like this that saw Pet Sounds voted off in round one.

Fight them on the beaches? The beaches were theirs all along!

Never in the field of human conflict have so many good songs been dumped by so few.

You Still Believe in Me

You Still Believe In Me.

You Still Believe in Me

By one measely vote:

I'm Waiting For The Day when you will vo-hote agai-hen! (http://www.sideshowcollectors.com/forums/images/smilies/survivor.gif)

Vote for your LEAST FAVORITE TRACK

Votes will be tallied on November 13th

Wouldn't It Be Nice
You Still Believe in Me
God Only Knows
I Just Wasn't Made for These Times
Caroline, No

Round#1 - Pet Sounds October 27
Round#2 - Let's Go Away for Awhile October 30
Round#3 - I Know There's an Answer November 1
Round#4 - That's Not Me November 3
Round#5 - Sloop John B November 5
Round#6 - Here Today November 7
Round#7 - Don't Talk (Put Your Head on My Shoulder) November 9
Round#8 - I'm Waiting for the Day November 11

My vote goes to... Caroline No.

You still believe in me

Wouldn't It Be Nice!

Caroline, No

Caroline, No

You Still Believe In Me

Caroline No…again

Ohmygoodness this is difficult.

I don't know which one to vote off at this point.

Caroline, No

You Still Believe in Me

‍

I change my vote to You Still Believe In Me.
I prefer that over WIBN, no contest. But Caroline No must be saved!

Can't believe I'm voting for it but "I Just Wasn't Made for These Times"

Oh man.

Count it out for me too. But it seems to go against the flow.

 I like Still You Believe in Me...I WANNA CRYYYY-IIIII-III-III-IIIII

…

psst, Pixletwin - that's John's way of saying he's voting for God Only Knows

You Still Believe In Me

I Just Wasn't Made for These Times

caroline no

Believe

I Just Wasn't Made for These Times


That just goes to show you how good the OTHER remaining songs are!

I just wasn't made for these times

Caroline, No

I Just Wasn't Made For These Times.

You Still Believe in Me

YSBIM

Caroline, No

‍

Caroline, No     This is down to insane voting now, only a multi-tie will work.  Maybe we should just go to the beach...

You Still Believe in Me

I was feeling bad about voting for the song, but now I'm kind of mad at it.

I Just Wasn't Made for These Times

Caroline, No.

I Just Wasn't Made For These Times

Looks like YSBIM may be history.  Dang.

I voted for it in round 1...

Caroline, Bro.

Care Oh Whino is in the drunk tank. (http://www.sideshowcollectors.com/forums/images/smilies/survivor.gif)

Vote for your LEAST FAVORITE TRACK

Votes will be tallied on November 15th

Wouldn't It Be Nice
You Still Believe in Me
God Only Knows
I Just Wasn't Made for These Times

Round#1 - Pet Sounds October 27
Round#2 - Let's Go Away for Awhile October 30
Round#3 - I Know There's an Answer November 1
Round#4 - That's Not Me November 3
Round#5 - Sloop John B November 5
Round#6 - Here Today November 7
Round#7 - Don't Talk (Put Your Head on My Shoulder) November 9
Round#8 - I'm Waiting for the Day November 11
Round#9 - Caroline, No November 13

My vote goes to... I Just Wasn't Made for These Times.

Wouldn't be nice

Wouldn't It Be Nice!
I know, I voted for You Still Believe In Me last round, but that was only because I was trying to save Caroline No. Really, I prefer YSBIN over WIBN

I Just Wasn't Made for These Times

You Still Believe In Me.

YSBIM

I Just Wasn't Made for These Times is no longer on the list...a bit premature, perhaps???

Woopsy I must have cut instead of copied and pasted.  :o

You still believe in me

You Still Believe in Me--this has gotten so much tougher now for me personally. Pet Sounds is a revered album of course but for me on a personal level it ranks behind SMiLE, Friends, Today!, Sunflower, All Summer Long, and Love You. As a BB fan who came in through The SMiLE Sessions I like Pet Sounds because by that time I was reading so much about the Boys I was basically told to love it. The four tracks that remain are all classics--tracks like Caroline, No, That's Not Me, Don't Talk, and some others are not as sacred to me as they are to most Smiley Smilers. I know I am in the extreme minority here but this is a message board to express opinions, so that's mine….

YSBIM

You Still Believe In Me

I Just Wasn't Made For These Times

You Still Believe in Me

Just Wasn't Made for These Times

You Still Believe in Me

‍

Aaargghh..  That's Not Me gone, and now Caroline No... This is not fun.

Anyway...  I just wasn't made for these times

Tough one.

I Just Wasn't Made for These Times

YSBIM

i just wasn't made for these times

You Still Believe in Me

I don't really understand how anyone could vote for YSBIM when WIBN is still there  ???
















                  
Then again, it is just my opinion

You Still Believe In Me

YSBIM

Believe

‍

I meant YSBIM is a better track than WIBN and it should make it to the finals instead.
IMHO it's no contest

You Still Believe In Me

I Just Wasn't Made for These Times


*Don't shoot*

‍

And I was the other one and I SAID it was merely due to over-exposure! ;)

I Just Wasn't Made for These Times.

You still believe in me

You Still Believe in Me

You Still Believe in Me

You Still Believe in Me.

Sorry to see "Caroline" go.

I continue voting to boot "I Just Wasn't Made for These Times."

I just wasn't made for these times

You Still Believe In Me

I just wasn't made for these times.

I Just Wasn't Made For These Times.

...     I'm taking John's stand in this round.  Watching my favorites vanish, they're really all too good to vote away, was even harder than Today.  But, my very favorite is still standing, for now. 

talley...man?

Im ready to get this one over.  ;)

You Still Believe in Me

...more like..."Caroline, Go".


;D

Pun intended!  :lol

Wow. Prolly the most disappointing round for me.  :'(

You Still Believe In Me didn't have enough believers. (http://www.sideshowcollectors.com/forums/images/smilies/survivor.gif)

Vote for your FAVORITE TRACK

Votes will be tallied on November 18th

Wouldn't It Be Nice
God Only Knows
I Just Wasn't Made for These Times

Round#1 - Pet Sounds October 27
Round#2 - Let's Go Away for Awhile October 30
Round#3 - I Know There's an Answer November 1
Round#4 - That's Not Me November 3
Round#5 - Sloop John B November 5
Round#6 - Here Today November 7
Round#7 - Don't Talk (Put Your Head on My Shoulder) November 9
Round#8 - I'm Waiting for the Day November 11
Round#9 - Caroline, No November 13
Round#10 - You Still Believe in Me November 16

My fave... GOD ONLY KNOWS (as if you had to ask).  ;D

VOTE FOR YOUR FAVORITE TRACK!!!!

Wouldn't It Be Nice

God Only Knows

WOULDN'T IT BE NICE

I Just Wasn't Made For These Times

God Only Knows

God Only Knows!
I'd be fine if either that or IJWMFTT wins, but GOK is my preference

I Just Wasn't Made For These Times   

God Only Knows

god only knows...

what i'd be without smart girls!

God Only Knows

God Only Knows

God Only Knows WILL win, but my vote is for Wouldn't It Be Nice….I just absolutely love that track and I generally prefer peppier tunes to ballads, even if GOK is the best ballad of all time

God Only Knows what I'd be without this song.

God Only Knows

God Only Knows

GOK, of course!

I may be spitting in the wind but "Wouldn't It be Nice" is my all time favorite Beach Boys song so it's obviously my favorite track from Pet Sounds.

Oh man, oh geez. ah heck, I can't believe I have to vote, for like, my favourite song off of an album that is just so, gosh, you know heart-breakingly era-definingly soul- shakingly and stuff and I can't possibly vote for anything 'cos it will be likle shooting my kids in the back and I won't be able to look my face in the eye and my favourite songs went rounds ago, mofo's, so I guess I Just Wasn't Made For These Times...

‍

So close I had to just re-listen to all three songs back-to-back to be sure.

God Only Knows it is.

IJWMFTT

IJWMFTT

I Just Wasn't Made for These Times

I Just Wasn't Made For These Times   

My first vote so far in this entire series.

WIBN.

But I expect a different winner, and it will also be more than worthy.

I Just Wasn't Made For These Times   

Even though God Only Knows was the song to the first dance at my wedding, I'm still going to select..

Wouldn't It Be Nice

God Only Knows!

God Only Knows. The best song ever, by anyone, by a landslide.

GOK

Well I lunched out after round 1 so don't really feel like I deserve to participate now but what the hell - god only know has to win this. It's the greatest song of all time FFS!!

I just wasn't made for these times

"Wouldn't It Be Nice"--my favorite song of all time.  The vocals are INSANE on this track.  And my wife & I walked down the aisle at the end of our wedding ceremony to this song.  :)

IJWMFTT

God Only Knows....nothing could even come close

Its not over till its over but I have a good feeling about this round....  ;D

I Just Wasn't Made for These Times

Wouldn't It Be Nice

Here we are, at the end of what has been the toughest round of Survivor yet.

With 8 votes, woudn't it have been Nice if Wouldn't It Be Nice had gotten more votes? (http://www.sideshowcollectors.com/forums/images/smilies/survivor.gif)

With 11 votes, Al sang "I guess he just wasn't made for these times". (http://www.sideshowcollectors.com/forums/images/smilies/survivor.gif)

With 20 votes even, the Winner of Smiley Smiley Dot Net's Beach Boys Survivor #10 is...



Thanks for playing one and all!



Round#1 - Pet Sounds October 27
Round#2 - Let's Go Away for Awhile October 30
Round#3 - I Know There's an Answer November 1
Round#4 - That's Not Me November 3
Round#5 - Sloop John B November 5
Round#6 - Here Today November 7
Round#7 - Don't Talk (Put Your Head on My Shoulder) November 9
Round#8 - I'm Waiting for the Day November 11
Round#9 - Caroline, No November 13
Round#10 - You Still Believe in Me November 16
Round#11 - Wouldn't It Be NiceNovember 18
Round#11 - I Just Wasn't Made for These Times November 18

Did you read the posts? Like no other album so far, people were agonizing about what cuts to make (or couldn't make at all).  In any case, what a peculiar thing for you to latch on to.  :lol

Everything is okey-dokey rover. :)