The Smiley Smile Message Board

County Fair or I Do
Cotton Fields (Brian's cut) or Cotton Fields (Al's cut)
Land Ahoy or Cherry Cherry Coupe
Big Sur (Holland) or Big Sur (early version)
This Whole World (Sunflower)or This Whole World (IJWMFTT) or This Whole World (live@Roxy)or American Spring version
Morning Beat or Walkin'
Funky Pretty (Holland) or Funky Pretty (live)
Hawaii or Kona Coast  ::)
Only with You (Holland/Carl lead) or Only with You (POB bonus track/Dennis lead)
Holidays (Smile) or On a Holiday (BWPS)
Catch a Wave or Sidewalk Surfin'
Marcella (So Tough) or Marcella (live In Concert) or Marcella (performed live by BW and his band)
Darlin' (WH) or Darlin' (live in Knebworth)
Be True to Your School (single) or LDC version
Thinkin' About You baby (Sharon Marie) or American Spring Version
Help Me Rhona or Ronda or alt. version on EH soundtrack
Little Honda vs. alternate version on 2-fer
Vega-tables (Smile) or Vegetables (Smiley)
Live Let Live (TLOS) or Live Let Live (Soundtrack version)
Don't Back Down vs. alternate version on 2-fer
Airplane (LY studio cut) or Airplane (live version with Charles Lloyd flute solo)
Baby Blue Eyes  (LA) or early version from Bamboo rarity
Back Home (early 63 cut) or Back Home (Sunflower cut) or Back Home (15 Big Ones) or Back Home (live at Roxy)
Keep an Eye On Summer or BRian's version on Imagination
Feel Flows (SU studio cut) or Feel Flows (live in later 70s)
Let Him Run Wild or "Imagination version or the alt. version from the 2-fer
Santa Ana Winds (KTSA) or Santa Ana Winds (early version with no stupid spoken intro)
Sandy or Sherri Shhe Needs Me or She Says that She Needs Me
Wind Chimes (Smile) or Wind Chimes (Smiley)
Graduation Day (studio) or Live version
Pamela Jean or Car Crazy Cutie
Papa-Oom-Mow-Mow (live) or Papa-Oom-Mow-Mow (Party!)  ;)
Little St. Nick or "  " (with Drive In backing)
Here today (regular version) or Here Today (Brian vocal only)
Keepin the Summer Alive (studio) or KTSA (live at Knebworth)
Loop De Loop or Santa's Got an Airplane
Aren't You Glad (WH) or Aren't You Glad (live in London)
Bells of Christmas or Bells of Paris
Let's Go to Heaven in My Car or Water Builds Up
Let the Wind Blow (WH) or the live version on the Concert album
The Little Girl I once Knew (single) or version on Hawthorne
Lay Down Burden (Imagination) or Lay Down Burden (Live @ Roxy)
Surfer Girl (studio) or Surfer Girl (Lei'd in Hawaii rehearsal)
Good Time (Love You) or Good Time (American Spring)
Wild Honey (album cut) or Wild Honey (Live version with Blondie on lead)
I'm Bugged at My ol Man (Summer Days) or the version in the It's Ok special where Brian starts coughing up a lung
Til I die or Til I Die (Desper long mix)
Endless harmony (KTSA) or 10 Years of Harmony
Sacramento (Usher) or That's Just the Way I feel (Usher)
Wake the World or Wake the World (live in London)
You're So Good to me (Studio) or You're So Good to Me (lei'd In Hawaii)
Dance Dance Dance or early take of the song
Lady (DW) or Fallin' in Love(American Spring)
Shortenin' Bread (LA) or Shortenin' Bread (Adult Child) or Metal Beach
Look or Song for the Children
Bull Session with Big Daddy (on the album) or the 20 minute version
All I want To Do (20/20) or All I want to Do (live in London outtake)
Come go with Me (MIU) or Come Go with Me (early 15 Big Ones outtake)
I'm So Young or early take of the song with Flute added
Breakaway (single) or alt. mix on Hawthorne or early version on EH soundtrack
I Know There's an Answer or Hang On To Your Ego
Lady Lynda (LA) or Lady Lynda (early version from MIU era) or Lady Lynda (Live at Knebworth)
Surfin' or Surfin' on SIP or Surfin' (Lei'd in Hawaii)
Island Fever original SIP release or Island Fever (UK release)
She's Just Out to Get Ya (American Spring) or How's About a Little Bit of your Sweet Love
Girl Don't Tell Me (SD) or Girl Don't Tell Me (Live with Al in Vegas)
Trombone Dixie or Had to Phone Ya
Had to Phone Ya (15 Big Ones) or Had to Phone Ya (American Spring)
Kiss Me Baby or vocals only version
Sail On Sailor (Holland cut) or Sail On sailor (live In Concert)
Do it Again or live in London or early version on EH
The Man with All the Toys (BB version) or Man with All the Toys (BW version)
Love to Say Dada/Water or Cool Cool Water or In Blue Hawaii
Trader (Holland) or Trader (live in Concert)
Summertime (Sharon Marie) or Summertime (BWRG)
Time to Get Alone (20/20) or Time to Get Alone (Redwood) or Time to Get Alone (alt. version on Hawthorne)
Sweet Sunday Kinda Love (MIU) or Sweet Sunday Kinda Love (American Spring)
Oh Darling (KTSA) or Oh Darling (alt. version on Get the Boot/Brian vocal)

Added:
Black Widow or Let's Do it Again
Don't Worry Baby studio vs. Don't Worry Baby from the In Concert LP
Cuddle Up (C&tP) vs Cuddle Up (45rpm mix)
That Same Song (15BO) v That Same Song (TV Special w/Double Rock Baptist Choir)
Midnight's Another Day (TLOS) v Midnight's Another Day (demo)
Heroes and Villains (Smiley) or Heroes and Villians (Lei'd in Hawaii) or H&V (live In Concert) or H&V (BWPS)
Thinkin Bout You Baby - Sharon Marie or Thinkin Bout You Baby (American Spring)
Vegetables (Laughing Gravy) or Vegetables (Smiley)
Sloop John B (album cut) or Sloop John B (other vocal, you specify)
God Only Knows (album) or GOK w/ sax solo or GOK with Brian on lead and vocal round at the end or GOK rehearsal in Hawaii on EH
Pet Sounds instrumental (studio) or Pet Sounds (live)
Caroline No (PS studio) or Caroline No (In Concert with Carl's lead)
Bluebirds Over the Mountain (20/20 or Bluebirds Over the Mountain (Live in London)
Caroline No (single/sped up/regular) or Caroline No (slowed down, "original")
Gettin' Hungry (Smiley) or Gettin' Hungry (Lei'd in Hawaii)
Do you Like Worms (Smile) or Roll Plymouth Rock (BWPS)
Wonderful (Smile) or Wonderful (Smiley) or "Wonder Bill" (Live on EH) or Wonderful (IJWMFTT) or Wonderful (BWPS)
Let's Go Trippin' (Surfin' USA) or Let'Go Trippin (Concert)
Desert Drive (Paley Sessions) or Desert Drive (GIOMH(
Their Hearts Were Full of Spring (Original demo/Hite Morgan recording) or A Young Man is Gone or Their Hearts were Full of Spring (Rehearsal in Hawaii) or Their Hearts Were Full of Spring (Live in London)
School Days (KTSA) or School Days (Live at Knebworth)
We Got Love (Holland outtake) or We Got Love (In Concert)
You Still Believe in Me (album) or YSBIM (In Concert)
Let's Stick Together (Sweet Insanity) or The Waltz (GIOMH)
Melt Away (BW 88) or Melt Away (IJWMFTT) or Melt Away (Demo from BW 88 re-release)
Spirit of Rock and Roll (early Usher version) or Spirit of Rock and Roll (live from 80s tv special) or Spirit of Rock and Roll (Sweet Insanity with Bob Dylan or Spirit of Rock and Roll (BW from Songs from here and back)
Loop De Loop (Landlocked early mix) or Loop De Loop (Al's newer mix from EH)
Save the day (Sweet Insanity) or Fairy Tale (GIOMH)
Hey Little Tomboy (MIU) or Hey Little Tomboy (Adult Child)
Still I Dream of It (Adult Child) Still I Dream of It (demo/IJWMFTT)
California Feeling (Beach Boys/MIU-LA era/most notably vocals are Carl and Al in my opinion) or California Feeling (American Spring) or California Feeling (newest BW version)
Don't Let Her Know She's an Angel (Sweet Insanity) or Don't Let Her Know She's an Angel (GIOMH)
Can't Wait too Long (snippet from Hawthorne) or Can't Wait too Long (TLOS)
Make A Wish (Sweet Insanity) or Make a Wish(GIOMH)
There's So Many (BW 88) or There's So Many (Early demo on BW88 reissue)
Rainbow Eyes (Sweet Insanity) or Rainbow Eyes (GIOMH)
Love and Mercy (BW 88) or L&M (IJWMFTT) or L&M (live at the Roxy0
Gettin In Over My Head (Paley Sessions) or Gettin' in Over My Head (GIOMH)
Walkin' the Line (Usher demo) or walkin' the Line (BW 88)



I'll respond with my answers in the next couple of days

Whoa. That's long. I'll just pick a few for which I have a stronger preference:

- Cotton Fields (Al's cut)
- Aren't You Glad (Live in London)
- Break Away (alternate mix on Hawthorne, CA)
- Trombone Dixie
- Cool Cool Water

And -- if I may add one -- Wouldn't It Be Nice with Brian on the bridge. *prepares for dissent*

County Fair or I Do
Cotton Fields (Brian's cut) or Cotton Fields (Al's cut)
Land Ahoy or Cherry Cherry Coupe
Big Sur (Holland) or Big Sur (early version)
This Whole World (Sunflower)or This Whole World (IJWMFTT) or This Whole World (live@Roxy)or American Spring version
Morning Beat or Walkin'
Funky Pretty (Holland) or Funky Pretty (live)
Hawaii or Kona Coast  
Only with You (Holland/Carl lead) or Only with You (POB bonus track/Dennis lead)
Holidays (Smile) or On a Holiday (BWPS)
Catch a Wave or Sidewalk Surfin'
Marcella (So Tough) or Marcella (live In Concert) or Marcella (performed live by BW and his band)
Darlin' (WH) or Darlin' (live in Knebworth)
Be True to Your School (single) or LDC version
Thinkin' About You baby (Sharon Marie) or American Spring Version
Help Me Rhonda or Ronda or alt. version on EH soundtrack
Little Honda vs. alternate version on 2-fer
Vega-tables (Smile) or Vegetables (Smiley)
Live Let Live (TLOS) or Live Let Live (Soundtrack version)
Don't Back Down vs. alternate version on 2-fer
Airplane (LY studio cut) or Airplane (live version with Charles Lloyd flute solo)
Baby Blue Eyes  (LA) or early version from Bamboo rarity
Back Home (early 63 cut) or Back Home (Sunflower cut) or Back Home (15 Big Ones) or Back Home (live at Roxy)
Keep an Eye On Summer or BRian's version on Imagination
Feel Flows (SU studio cut) or Feel Flows (live in later 70s)
Let Him Run Wild or "Imagination version or the alt. version from the 2-fer
Santa Ana Winds (KTSA) or Santa Ana Winds (early version with no stupid spoken intro)
Sandy or Sherri She Needs Me or She Says that She Needs Me
Wind Chimes (Smile) or Wind Chimes (Smiley)
Graduation Day (studio) or Live version
Pamela Jean or Car Crazy Cutie
Papa-Oom-Mow-Mow (live) or Papa-Oom-Mow-Mow (Party!)  
Little St. Nick or "  " (with Drive In backing)
Here today (regular version) or Here Today (Brian vocal only)
Keepin the Summer Alive (studio) or KTSA (live at Knebworth)
Loop De Loop (1969 version) or Santa's Got an Airplane
Aren't You Glad (WH) or Aren't You Glad (live in London)
Bells of Christmas or Bells of Paris
Let's Go to Heaven in My Car or Water Builds Up
Let the Wind Blow (WH) or the live version on the Concert album
The Little Girl I once Knew (single) or version on Hawthorne
Lay Down Burden (Imagination) or Lay Down Burden (Live @ Roxy)
Surfer Girl (studio) or Surfer Girl (Lei'd in Hawaii rehearsal)
Good Time (Love You) or Good Time (American Spring)
Wild Honey (album cut) or Wild Honey (Live version with Blondie on lead)
I'm Bugged at My ol Man (Summer Days) or the version in the It's Ok special where Brian starts coughing up a lung
Til I die or Til I Die (Desper long mix)
Endless harmony (KTSA) or 10 Years of Harmony
Sacramento (Usher) or That's Just the Way I feel (Usher)
Wake the World or Wake the World (live in London)
You're So Good to me (Studio) or You're So Good to Me (lei'd In Hawaii)
Dance Dance Dance or early take of the song
Lady (DW) or Fallin' in Love(American Spring)
Shortenin' Bread (LA) or Shortenin' Bread (Adult Child) or Metal Beach
Look or Song for the Children
Bull Session with Big Daddy (on the album) or the 20 minute version
All I want To Do (20/20) or All I want to Do (live in London outtake)
Come go with Me (MIU) or Come Go with Me (early 15 Big Ones outtake)
I'm So Young or early take of the song with Flute added
Breakaway (single) or alt. mix on Hawthorne or early version on EH soundtrack
I Know There's an Answer or Hang On To Your Ego
Lady Lynda (LA) or Lady Lynda (early version from MIU era) or Lady Lynda (Live at Knebworth)Surfin' or Surfin' on SIP or Surfin' (Lei'd in Hawaii)
Island Fever original SIP release or Island Fever (UK release)
She's Just Out to Get Ya (American Spring) or How's About a Little Bit of your Sweet Love
Girl Don't Tell Me (SD) or Girl Don't Tell Me (Live with Al in Vegas)
Trombone Dixie or Had to Phone Ya
Had to Phone Ya (15 Big Ones) or Had to Phone Ya (American Spring)
Kiss Me Baby or vocals only version
Sail On Sailor (Holland cut) or Sail On sailor (live In Concert)
Do it Again or live in London or early version on EH
The Man with All the Toys (BB version) or Man with All the Toys (BW version)
Love to Say Dada/Water or Cool Cool Water or In Blue Hawaii
Trader (Holland) or Trader (live in Concert)
Summertime (Sharon Marie) or Summertime (BWRG)
Time to Get Alone (20/20) or Time to Get Alone (Redwood) or Time to Get Alone (alt. version on Hawthorne)
Sweet Sunday Kinda Love (MIU) or Sweet Sunday Kinda Love (American Spring)
Oh Darling (KTSA) or Oh Darling (alt. version on Get the Boot/Brian vocal)

I made a list like this a few years ago for the Shut Down Board. A part of this list could be the premise of another thread - "Which Version Do You Like Most  - Studio or live?" Same goes for "Original Version or Alternate Mixes?"

But it's a good list!  How 'bout a morpher?  "All Dressed Up For School/I Just Got My Pay/Marcella". And another - "Darlin'/Thinkin' Bout You Baby". "I Get Around" studio or live/studio (Ha Ha!).

How about............"Black Widow/Let's Do It Again". "Walkin' The Line" BW version or version w/Terence D' Arby. "Meet Me In My Dreams Tonight" ver. 1 & 2, etc, etc.

You forgot one very important one: Don't Worry Baby studio vs. Don't Worry Baby from the In Concert LP. To which I would pick the latter.

Cotton Fields (Brian's cut)
Big Sur (early version)
This Whole World (Sunflower)
Morning Beat
Funky Pretty (Holland)
Holidays (Smile)
Marcella (live In Concert)
Darlin' (WH)
Help Me Rhonda
Vega-tables (Smile)
Airplane (live version with Charles Lloyd flute solo)
Back Home (early 63 cut)
Let Him Run Wild original
Sherri She Needs Me
Wind Chimes (Smile)
Pamela Jean or Car Crazy Cutie
Papa-Oom-Mow-Mow (live) or Papa-Oom-Mow-Mow (Party!)  ;)
Here today (regular version)
Keepin the Summer Alive (studio) )
Loop De Loop or Santa's Got an Airplane I prefer Sail Plane Song
Aren't You Glad (live in London)
Let the Wind Blow live version on the Concert album
The Little Girl I once Knew (single)
Surfer Girl (studio)
Wild Honey (album cut)
I'm Bugged at My ol Man (Summer Days)
Til I die (Surf's Up version)
Wake the World (friends)
You're So Good to me (Studio)
Dance Dance Dance (final)
Lady (DW)
Shortenin' Bread (Adult Child)
Song for the Children
All I want To Do (20/20)
Breakaway early version on EH soundtrack
Hang On To Your Ego
Had to Phone Ya
Had to Phone Ya (15 Big Ones)
Sail On sailor (live In Concert)
Do it Again
Cool Cool Water
Trader (live in Concert)
Time to Get Alone (20/20)

I thought about it but i didnt know how big of a difference there was & I honestly thought it was a no-brainer: the studio cut

I did think about that...kinda just stuck to basic differences.

I did forget about Black Widow and some other choices for Brian solo, it was getting late & I couldn't remember em all.  ;D

Cotton Fields (Brian's cut) or Cotton Fields (Al's cut)
Land Ahoy or Cherry Cherry Coupe
This Whole World (Sunflower)or This Whole World (IJWMFTT) or This Whole World (live@Roxy)or American Spring version
Hawaii or Kona Coast  Roll Eyes
Catch a Wave or Sidewalk Surfin'
Marcella (So Tough) or Marcella (live In Concert) or Marcella (performed live by BW and his band)
Darlin' (WH) or Darlin' (live in Knebworth)
Be True to Your School (single) or LDC version
Help Me Rhonda or Ronda or alt. version on EH soundtrack
Little Honda vs. alternate version on 2-fer
Vega-tables (Smile) or Vegetables (Smiley)
Don't Back Down vs. alternate version on 2-fer
Airplane (LY studio cut) or Airplane (live version with Charles Lloyd flute solo)
Back Home (early 63 cut) or Back Home (Sunflower cut) or Back Home (15 Big Ones) or Back Home (live at Roxy)
Feel Flows (SU studio cut) or Feel Flows (live in later 70s)
Let Him Run Wild or Imagination version or the alt. version from the 2-fer
Graduation Day (studio) or Live version
Little St. Nick or "  " (with Drive In backing)
Here today (regular version) or Here Today (Brian vocal only)
Keepin the Summer Alive (studio) or KTSA (live at Knebworth)
Surfer Girl (studio) or Surfer Girl (Lei'd in Hawaii rehearsal)
Good Time (Love You) or Good Time (American Spring)
Til I die or Til I Die (Desper long mix)
Endless harmony (KTSA) or 10 Years of Harmony
You're So Good to me (Studio) or You're So Good to Me (lei'd In Hawaii)
Dance Dance Dance or early take of the song or Dance Dance Dance (Songs From Here and Back)
Come go with Me (MIU) or Come Go with Me (early 15 Big Ones outtake)
Breakaway (single) or alt. mix on Hawthorne or early version on EH soundtrack
Lady Lynda (LA) or Lady Lynda (early version from MIU era) or Lady Lynda (Live at Knebworth)
Surfin' or Surfin' on SIP or Surfin' (Lei'd in Hawaii)
Island Fever original SIP release or Island Fever (UK release)
Kiss Me Baby or vocals only version
Sail On Sailor (Holland cut) or Sail On sailor (live In Concert)
Do it Again or live in London or early version on EH

Two screaming omissions:

That Same Song (15BO) v That Same Song (TV Special w/Double Rock Baptist Choir)

Midnight's Another Day (TLOS) v Midnight's Another Day (demo)

I always forget that version of That Same Old Song, i think it's only on one of my rarities comps.


I haven't listened to the demop of Midnight in a while...what major differences are there between it and the album cut?

Album cut is exact same lead vocal & basic instrumentation, with added bvs, percussion & strings.

Cuddle Up (C&tP) vs Cuddle Up (45rpm mix)

I'm zeroing in on "Help Me Rhonda" and choosing the early alternate mix found in ENDLESS HARMONY. Brian's falsetto counterpoint, the alternate guitar solo and the heavier piano make this one the superior version for me; I never need to hear the '65 single (or the TODAY version) ever again.

 I Do
 Cotton Fields (Al's cut)
 Cherry Cherry Coupe
 Big Sur (early version)
This Whole World (Sunflower)
 Walkin'
Funky Pretty (Holland)
Hawaii
Only with You (POB bonus track/Dennis lead)
Holidays (Smile)
Catch a Wave
Marcella (performed live by BW and his band)
Darlin' (WH)
 LDC version
 American Spring Version
Help Me RhondA
Little Honda
Vegetables (Smiley)
Live Let Live (TLOS)
Neither
Airplane (LY studio cut)
Baby Blue Eyes 
Back Home (15 Big Ones)
Keep an Eye On Summer
Feel Flows (SU studio cut)
Let Him Run Wild
 Santa Ana Winds (early version with no  spoken intro)
 Sherri She Needs Me
Wind Chimes (Smiley)
Graduation Day
Car Crazy Cutie
Papa-Oom-Mow-Mow (live)
Little St. Nick
Here today
 KTSA (live at Knebworth)
Loop De Loop
Aren't You Glad (WH)
Bells of Paris
Let's Go to Heaven in My Car
Let the Wind Blow (WH)
The Little Girl I once Knew
Lay Down Burden (Live @ Roxy)
Surfer Girl (Lei'd in Hawaii rehearsal)
Good Time (Love You)
Wild Honey (album cut)
 the version in the It's Ok special where Brian starts coughing up a lung ( I hate the original)
Til I die
Endless harmony (KTSA) or 10 Years of Harmony- Neither (never heard the latter and I hate the former)
Sacramento (Usher) or That's Just the Way I feel (Usher)- never heard either
Wake the World
You're So Good to me (Studio)
Dance Dance Dance
Lady (DW)
 Shortenin' Bread (Adult Child)
Look
Bull Session with Big Daddy (on the album) or the 20 minute version- neither
All I want To Do (20/20)
Come go with Me (MIU)
I'm So Young
Breakaway (single)
I Know There's an Answer
 Lady Lynda (Live at Knebworth)
 Surfin' (Lei'd in Hawaii)
Island Fever original SIP release
She's Just Out to Get Ya (American Spring) or How's About a Little Bit of your Sweet Love- Not the same thing
Girl Don't Tell Me (SD)
Had to Phone Ya
 Had to Phone Ya (American Spring)
Kiss Me Baby
Sail On Sailor (Holland cut)
Do it Again
Man with All the Toys (BW version)
Love to Say Dada/Water
Trader (Holland)
 Summertime (BWRG)
Time to Get Alone (20/20) o
Sweet Sunday Kinda Love (MIU)
Oh Darling (alt. version on Get the Boot/Brian vocal)

No love for Big Sur (Holland)? I think Mike Love's lead vocal is even better on the released version and the humming backing vocals are just gorgeous.

Oh there's love for it allright, but it's up against one of their, imo, twenty best songs they ever did.

Cotton Fields (Brian's cut) or Cotton Fields (Al's cut)
Big Sur (Holland) or Big Sur (early version)
This Whole World (Sunflower) or This Whole World (IJWMFTT) or This Whole World (live@Roxy)or American Spring version
Morning Beat or Walkin'
Funky Pretty (Holland) or Funky Pretty (live)
Holidays (Smile) or On a Holiday (BWPS)
Darlin' (WH) or Darlin' (live in Knebworth)
Help Me Rhonda or Ronda or alt. version on EH soundtrack
Vega-tables (Smile) or Vegetables (Smiley)
Live Let Live (TLOS) or Live Let Live (Soundtrack version)
Airplane (LY studio cut) or Airplane (live version with Charles Lloyd flute solo)
Back Home (early 63 cut) or Back Home (Sunflower cut) or Back Home (15 Big Ones) or Back Home (live at Roxy)
Feel Flows (SU studio cut) or Feel Flows (live in later 70s)
Let Him Run Wild or "Imagination version or the alt. version from the 2-fer
Wind Chimes (Smile) or Wind Chimes (Smiley)
Graduation Day (studio) or Live version
Pamela Jean or Car Crazy Cutie
Papa-Oom-Mow-Mow (live) or Papa-Oom-Mow-Mow (Party!) 
Little St. Nick or "  " (with Drive In backing)
Here today (regular version) or Here Today (Brian vocal only)
Loop De Loop or Santa's Got an Airplane or Sail Plane Song!
Aren't You Glad (WH) or Aren't You Glad (live in London)
Let the Wind Blow (WH) or the live version on the Concert album
Surfer Girl (studio) or Surfer Girl (Lei'd in Hawaii rehearsal)
Good Time (Love You) or Good Time (American Spring)
Wild Honey (album cut) or Wild Honey (Live version with Blondie on lead)
I'm Bugged at My ol Man (Summer Days) or the version in the It's Ok special where Brian starts coughing up a lung
Til I die or Til I Die (Desper long mix)
Wake the World or Wake the World (live in London)
You're So Good to me (Studio) or You're So Good to Me (lei'd In Hawaii)
Dance Dance Dance or early take of the song
Lady (DW) or Fallin' in Love(American Spring)
Look or Song for the Children
Bull Session with Big Daddy (on the album) or the 20 minute version
All I want To Do (20/20) or All I want to Do (live in London outtake)
Come go with Me (MIU) or Come Go with Me (early 15 Big Ones outtake)
I'm So Young or early take of the song with Flute added
Breakaway (single) or alt. mix on Hawthorne or early version on EH soundtrack
I Know There's an Answer or Hang On To Your Ego - can't believe anyone'd prefer IKTAA
Surfin' or Surfin' on SIP or Surfin' (Lei'd in Hawaii)
Trombone Dixie or Had to Phone Ya - trombone dixie
Had to Phone Ya (15 Big Ones) or Had to Phone Ya (American Spring)
Kiss Me Baby or vocals only version
Sail On Sailor (Holland cut) or Sail On sailor (live In Concert)
Do it Again or live in London or early version on EH
The Man with All the Toys (BB version) or Man with All the Toys (BW version)
Love to Say Dada/Water or Cool Cool Water or In Blue Hawaii
Time to Get Alone (20/20) or Time to Get Alone (Redwood) or Time to Get Alone (alt. version on Hawthorne)

I thought about added that, but I didn't know how much of a difference it made...like adding the single mix to Cool Cool Water, I feel like the single mix takes more away....if I'm not mistaken

And of course the mixing/mastering is noticeably different; in particular the lead vocal is a lot drier sounding in comparison to the demo where it is far more reverberant.

added some

trying to think of alternate versions...I didn't know if it'd be nessesary to add tracks from the PS Sessions Box set...either a preference of vocals only or just the track, I could add em or whichever track you wanted.
Same goes with alternate versions from that set....I don't see many alternate versions being favored over the original, but I'm sure someone out there likes Carl singing Sloop ("I feel so BREAK up") better...perhaps some prefer the original speed to Caroline No....I'll go addy!

Is that enough for a while?
haha,
I literally just thought about this in about 30 minutes here at work.

I don't know where to start!

If it's on CATP or Holland, odds are I prefer it on In Concert. Apart from Funky Pretty, but I never really got with that song anyway - BW on autopilot. And Let The Wind Blow off that LP is one of my top BB's moments.

The Forever acapella track is, to me, the definitive version of that song - the backing track is unspectactular, really, and those harmonies are so stunning.

Aren't You Glad really kicks ass on the Big Sur Festival boot, but any take with the horns is fantastic. Denny really swings into that one.

Darlin' really deserves a slow, lopin' bossa cover.

Still no Help Me Ronda vrs Rhonda?

Black Widow or Let's Do it Again
Don't Worry Baby studio vs. Don't Worry Baby from the In Concert LP
Cuddle Up (C&tP) vs Cuddle Up (45rpm mix)
That Same Song (15BO) v That Same Song (TV Special w/Double Rock Baptist Choir)
Midnight's Another Day (TLOS) v Midnight's Another Day (demo)
Heroes and Villains (Smiley) or Heroes and Villians (Lei'd in Hawaii) or H&V (live In Concert) or H&V (BWPS)
Thinkin Bout You Baby - Sharon Marie or Thinkin Bout You Baby (American Spring)
Vegetables (Laughing Gravy) or Vegetables (Smiley)
Sloop John B (album cut) or Sloop John B (other vocal, you specify)
God Only Knows (album) or GOK w/ sax solo or GOK with Brian on lead and vocal round at the end or GOK rehearsal in Hawaii on EH
Pet Sounds instrumental (studio) or Pet Sounds (live)
Caroline No (PS studio) or Caroline No (In Concert with Carl's lead)
Bluebirds Over the Mountain (20/20 or Bluebirds Over the Mountain (Live in London)
Caroline No (single/sped up/regular) or Caroline No (slowed down, "original")
Gettin' Hungry (Smiley) or Gettin' Hungry (Lei'd in Hawaii)
Do you Like Worms (Smile) or Roll Plymouth Rock (BWPS)
Wonderful (Smile) or Wonderful (Smiley) or "Wonder Bill" (Live on EH) or Wonderful (IJWMFTT) or Wonderful (BWPS)
Let's Go Trippin' (Surfin' USA) or Let'Go Trippin (Concert)
Desert Drive (Paley Sessions) or Desert Drive (GIOMH(
Their Hearts Were Full of Spring (Original demo/Hite Morgan recording) or A Young Man is Gone or Their Hearts were Full of Spring (Rehearsal in Hawaii) or Their Hearts Were Full of Spring (Live in London)
School Days (KTSA) or School Days (Live at Knebworth)
We Got Love (Holland outtake) or We Got Love (In Concert)
You Still Believe in Me (album) or YSBIM (In Concert)
Let's Stick Together (Sweet Insanity) or The Waltz (GIOMH)
Melt Away (BW 88) or Melt Away (IJWMFTT) or Melt Away (Demo from BW 88 re-release)
Spirit of Rock and Roll (early Usher version) or Spirit of Rock and Roll (live from 80s tv special) or Spirit of Rock and Roll (Sweet Insanity with Bob Dylan or Spirit of Rock and Roll (BW from Songs from here and back)
Loop De Loop (Landlocked early mix) or Loop De Loop (Al's newer mix from EH)
Save the day (Sweet Insanity) or Fairy Tale (GIOMH)
Hey Little Tomboy (MIU) or Hey Little Tomboy (Adult Child)
Still I Dream of It (Adult Child) Still I Dream of It (demo/IJWMFTT)
California Feeling (Beach Boys/MIU-LA era/most notably vocals are Carl and Al in my opinion) or California Feeling (American Spring) or California Feeling (newest BW version)
Don't Let Her Know She's an Angel (Sweet Insanity) or Don't Let Her Know She's an Angel (GIOMH)
Can't Wait too Long (snippet from Hawthorne) or Can't Wait too Long (TLOS)
Make A Wish (Sweet Insanity) or Make a Wish(GIOMH)
There's So Many (BW 88) or There's So Many (Early demo on BW88 reissue)
Rainbow Eyes (Sweet Insanity) or Rainbow Eyes (GIOMH)
Love and Mercy (BW 88) or
Gettin In Over My Head (Paley Sessions) or Gettin' in Over My Head (GIOMH)
Walkin' the Line (Usher demo) or walkin' the Line (BW 88)

Yeah, I think so, look for underlined and bolded

Oops missed the Ronda part

When I'm satisifed with what "songs" that are being added...I'll start rating them.

HAWD DAMN IT RANGE ROVER.

*deep breath* boy, that was a task!

It's not on the list, and I know a lot of people HATE it, but the bluesy Help Me Rhonda on In Concert is a secret favorite of mine.

Revisiting this great topic. My choices will be:

County Fair or I Do
Cotton Fields (Brian's cut) or Cotton Fields (Al's cut)
Land Ahoy or Cherry Cherry Coupe (both)
Big Sur (Holland) or Big Sur (early version)
This Whole World (Sunflower)or This Whole World (IJWMFTT) or This Whole World (live@Roxy)or American Spring version
Morning Beat or Walkin'
Funky Pretty (Holland) or Funky Pretty (live)
Hawaii or Kona Coast
Only with You (Holland/Carl lead) or Only with You (POB bonus track/Dennis lead) (none)
Holidays (Smile) or On a Holiday (BWPS)
Marcella (So Tough) or Marcella (live In Concert) or Marcella (performed live by BW and his band)
Be True to Your School (single) or LDC version
Thinkin' About You baby (Sharon Marie) or American Spring Version
Help Me Rhonda or Ronda or alt. version on EH soundtrack
Little Honda vs. alternate version on 2-fer
Vega-tables (Smile) or Vegetables (Smiley) (both)
Don't Back Down vs. alternate version on 2-fer
Back Home (early 63 cut) or Back Home (Sunflower cut) or Back Home (15 Big Ones) or Back Home (live at Roxy)
Keep an Eye On Summer or Brian's version on Imagination
Feel Flows (SU studio cut) or Feel Flows (live in later 70s) (both)
Let Him Run Wild or "Imagination version or the alt. version from the 2-fer
Santa Ana Winds (KTSA) or Santa Ana Winds (early version with no stupid spoken intro)
Sandy or Sherri She Needs Me or She Says that She Needs Me
Wind Chimes (Smile) or Wind Chimes (Smiley)
Graduation Day (studio) or Live version
Pamela Jean or Car Crazy Cutie
Papa-Oom-Mow-Mow (live) or Papa-Oom-Mow-Mow (Party!) (none, I hate it)
Little St. Nick or "  " (with Drive In backing) (both, the latter is funny!)
Here today (regular version) or Here Today (Brian vocal only)
Keepin the Summer Alive (studio) or KTSA (live at Knebworth)
Loop De Loop or Santa's Got an Airplane (def. the former, the other is boooorrring!)
Aren't You Glad (WH) or Aren't You Glad (live in London) (both, the last one is interesting)
Bells of Christmas or Bells of Paris
Let the Wind Blow (WH) or the live version on the Concert album
The Little Girl I once Knew (single) or version on Hawthorne
Surfer Girl (studio) or Surfer Girl (Lei'd in Hawaii rehearsal) (def. the former, the other is booorrring!)
Good Time (Love You) or Good Time (American Spring)
Wild Honey (album cut) or Wild Honey (Live version with Blondie on lead) (both; Blondie rocks!)
I'm Bugged at My ol Man (Summer Days) or the version in the It's Ok special where Brian starts coughing up a lung (none)
Til I die or Til I Die (Desper long mix)
Endless harmony (KTSA) or 10 Years of Harmony (none)
Sacramento (Usher) or That's Just the Way I feel (Usher)
Wake the World or Wake the World (live in London) (both; lovely number)
You're So Good to me (Studio) or You're So Good to Me (lei'd In Hawaii) (both; one of my favorite BBs songs ever!)
Dance Dance Dance [single] or early take of the song
Lady (DW) or Fallin' in Love(American Spring) (none, never liked it)
Shortenin' Bread (LA) or Shortenin' Bread (Adult Child) or Metal Beach
I'm So Young or early take of the song with Flute added
Breakaway (single) or alt. mix on Hawthorne or early version on EH soundtrack
I Know There's an Answer or Hang On To Your Ego
Lady Lynda (LA) or Lady Lynda (early version from MIU era) or Lady Lynda (Live at Knebworth) (all 3 versions, really. Al's shining gem)
Surfin' or Surfin' on SIP or Surfin' (Lei'd in Hawaii)
Island Fever original SIP release or Island Fever (UK release)
Kiss Me Baby or vocals only version
Sail On Sailor (Holland cut) or Sail On sailor (live In Concert)
Do it Again or live in London or early version on EH
The Man with All the Toys (BB version) or Man with All the Toys (BW version)
Trader (Holland) or Trader (live in Concert)
Summertime (Sharon Marie) or Summertime (BWRG)
Oh Darlin (KTSA) or Oh Darlin (alt. version on Get the Boot/Brian vocal)

Added:
Black Widow or Let's Do it Again
Don't Worry Baby studio vs. Don't Worry Baby from the In Concert LP
That Same Song (15BO) v That Same Song (TV Special w/Double Rock Baptist Choir)
Heroes and Villains (Smiley) or Heroes and Villians (Lei'd in Hawaii) or H&V (live In Concert) or H&V (BWPS)
Vegetables (Laughing Gravy) or Vegetables (Smiley)
Sloop John B (album cut) or Sloop John B (other vocal, you specify):Al
God Only Knows (album) or GOK w/ sax solo or GOK with Brian on lead and vocal round at the end or GOK rehearsal in Hawaii on EH
Pet Sounds instrumental (studio) or Pet Sounds (live)
Caroline No (PS studio) or Caroline No (In Concert with Carl's lead)
Bluebirds Over the Mountain (20/20 or Bluebirds Over the Mountain (Live in London) (none; it's corny as hell)
Caroline No (single/sped up/regular) or Caroline No (slowed down, "original")
Gettin' Hungry (Smiley) or Gettin' Hungry (Lei'd in Hawaii)
Wonderful (Smile) or Wonderful (Smiley) or "Wonder Bill" (Live on EH) or Wonderful (IJWMFTT) or Wonderful (BWPS)
Let's Go Trippin' (Surfin' USA) or Let's Go Trippin (Concert)
Desert Drive (Paley Sessions) or Desert Drive (GIOMH)
Their Hearts Were Full of Spring (Original demo/Hite Morgan recording) or A Young Man is Gone or Their Hearts were Full of Spring (Rehearsal in Hawaii) or Their Hearts Were Full of Spring (Live in London)
We Got Love (Holland outtake) or We Got Love (In Concert) (the studio cut is just not lively enough imo)
You Still Believe in Me (album) or YSBIM (In Concert) (both are tremendous!)
Melt Away (BW 88) or Melt Away (IJWMFTT) or Melt Away (Demo from BW 88 re-release)
Save the day (Sweet Insanity) or Fairy Tale (GIOMH)
Hey Little Tomboy (MIU) or Hey Little Tomboy (Adult Child)
Still I Dream of It (Adult Child) Still I Dream of It (demo/IJWMFTT) (nothing - it's boring, simple as that)
California Feeling (Beach Boys/MIU-LA era/most notably vocals are Carl and Al in my opinion) or California Feeling (American Spring) or California Feeling (newest BW version) v California Feeling (Postcard From California)
Don't Let Her Know She's an Angel (Sweet Insanity) or Don't Let Her Know She's an Angel (GIOMH)
There's So Many (BW 88) or There's So Many (Early demo on BW88 reissue) (both; the early demo is interesting)
Rainbow Eyes (Sweet Insanity) or Rainbow Eyes (GIOMH)
Love and Mercy (BW 88) or L&M (IJWMFTT) or L&M (live at the Roxy) (all 3, tho now I slightly prefer minimal arr. version on IJWMFTT. Great song anyways)
Gettin In Over My Head (Paley Sessions) or Gettin' in Over My Head (GIOMH)
Walkin' the Line (Usher demo) or Walkin' the Line (BW 88)
Lookin' Down the Coast (unreleased) v. Lookin' Down the Coast (Postcard From California)
Soul Searchin' (Brian on lead) v. Soul Searchin' (Carl on lead)
He Couldn't Get His Poor Old Body to Move vs. He Couldn't Get His Poor... (with weird synth claps & chimes)
Someone to Love (loud mix) v. Someone to Love (w/ spoken bits)
Christine vs. Living Doll (Barbie)

I totally forgot I did this!

These.
Also-Funky Pretty from Holland-I love the production of it.

How about:

Isn't It Time (TWGMTR album version) v  Isn't It Time (Single Version) 

Selective picks:

I Do
Cotton Fields (Al's cut)
Cherry Cherry Coupe
This Whole World (Sunflower)
Only with You (Holland/Carl lead)
Catch a Wave
Darlin' (WH) or Darlin' (live, any version with Carl on lead) = both!
Be True to Your School (LDC version)
Thinkin' About You Baby (American Spring version)
Little Honda (album version)
Don't Back Down (album version)
Baby Blue Eyes (LA) or early version from Bamboo rarity = both
Keep an Eye on Summer (BB version)
Feel Flows (SU studio cut) or Feel Flows (live) = both!
Let Him Run Wild (BB version)
Graduation Day (live version -- DAYYYYY!)
Car Crazy Cutie
Papa-Oom-Mow-Mow (live) or Papa-Oom-Mow-Mow (Party!) = both
Little St. Nick (single)
Keepin the Summer Alive (studio) or KTSA (live at Knebworth) = both
Loop De Loop
Aren't You Glad (WH) or Aren't You Glad (Live in London) = both
Let the Wind Blow (WH) or the live version on the Concert album = both!
Surfer Girl (studio)
Good Time (American Spring)
Wild Honey (album cut) -- but live versions are good too!
Til I Die or Til I Die (Desper long mix) = both
Wake the World (Live in London)
You're So Good to Me (studio)
Dance Dance Dance (BB version)
Shortenin' Bread (Adult Child)
Come Go with Me (MIU)
Breakaway (early version on EH soundtrack)
I Know There's an Answer or Hang on to Your Ego = NEITHER!
Lady Lynda (Live at Knebworth)
How's About a Little Bit of Your Sweet Love (Celebration)
Kiss Me Baby
Sail On Sailor (Holland cut) or Sail On Sailor (live In Concert)
Do it Again or live = both
The Man with All the Toys (BB version)
Trader (Holland) or Trader (live in Concert) = both
Time to Get Alone (20/20)
Oh Darling (KTSA)

Added:
Don't Worry Baby (studio)
That Same Song (TV Special w/Double Rock Baptist Choir)
Heroes and Villains (Smiley) or H&V (live In Concert) -- or any live version = these three
Vegetables (Smiley) -- and Smile Sessions = both
God Only Knows (any live version sung by Carl)
Caroline No (PS studio) or Caroline No (In Concert with Carl's lead) = both!
Gettin' Hungry (Celebration's reggae version)
Do You Like Worms (Smile)
Wonderful (Smile) or Wonderful (Smiley) or "Wonder Bill" (Live on EH) = these three
Desert Drive (GIOMH)
YSBIM (In Concert)
Spirit of Rock and Roll (live from 80s TV special)
Hey Little Tomboy (MIU) or Hey Little Tomboy (Adult Child) = NEITHER!
Can't Wait Too Long (snippet from Hawthorne) or Can't Wait Too Long (TLOS) = both!
Love and Mercy (BW 88) or L&M (IJWMFTT) or L&M (live at the Roxy) = none, not a fan of L&M song

County Fair or I Do
Cotton Fields (Brian's cut) or Cotton Fields (Al's cut)
Land Ahoy or Cherry Cherry Coupe
Big Sur (Holland) or Big Sur (early version)
This Whole World (Sunflower) or This Whole World (IJWMFTT) or This Whole World (live@Roxy) or American Spring version
Morning Beat or Walkin'
Funky Pretty (Holland) or Funky Pretty (live)
Hawaii or Kona Coast
Only with You (Holland/Carl lead) or Only with You (POB bonus track/Dennis lead)
Holidays (Smile) or On a Holiday (BWPS)
Catch a Wave or Sidewalk Surfin'
Marcella (So Tough) or Marcella (live In Concert) or Marcella (performed live by BW and his band)
Darlin' (WH) or Darlin' (live in Knebworth)
Be True to Your School (single) or LDC version
Thinkin' About You baby (Sharon Marie) or American Spring Version
Help Me Rhonda or Ronda or alt. version on EH soundtrack
Little Honda vs. alternate version on 2-fer
Vega-tables (Smile) or Vegetables (Smiley)
Live Let Live (TLOS) or Live Let Live (Soundtrack version)
Don't Back Down vs. alternate version on 2-fer
Airplane (LY studio cut) or Airplane (live version with Charles Lloyd flute solo)
Baby Blue Eyes (LA) or early version from Bamboo rarity
Back Home (early 63 cut) or Back Home (Sunflower cut) or Back Home (15 Big Ones) or Back Home (live at Roxy)
Keep an Eye On Summer or Brian's version on Imagination
Feel Flows (SU studio cut) or Feel Flows (live in later 70s)
Let Him Run Wild or Imagination version or the alt. version from the 2-fer
Santa Ana Winds (KTSA) or Santa Ana Winds (early version with no stupid spoken intro)
Sandy or Sherry She Needs Me or She Says that She Needs Me
Wind Chimes (Smile) or Wind Chimes (Smiley)
Graduation Day (studio) or Live version
Pamela Jean or Car Crazy Cutie
Papa-Oom-Mow-Mow (live) or Papa-Oom-Mow-Mow (Party!)
Little St. Nick or "  " (with Drive In backing)
Here Today (regular version) or Here Today (Brian vocal only)
Keepin the Summer Alive (studio) or KTSA (live at Knebworth)
Loop De Loop or Santa's Got an Airplane
Aren't You Glad (WH) or Aren't You Glad (live in London)
Bells of Christmas or Bells of Paris
Let's Go to Heaven in My Car or Water Builds Up
Let the Wind Blow (WH) or the live version on the Concert album
The Little Girl I once Knew (single) or version on Hawthorne
Lay Down Burden (Imagination) or Lay Down Burden (Live @ Roxy)
Surfer Girl (studio) or Surfer Girl (Lei'd in Hawaii rehearsal)
Good Time (Love You) or Good Time (American Spring)
Wild Honey (album cut) or Wild Honey (Live version with Blondie on lead)
I'm Bugged at My ol Man (Summer Days) or the version in the It's Ok special where Brian starts coughing up a lung
Til I Die or Til I Die (Desper long mix)
Endless harmony (KTSA) or 10 Years of Harmony
Wake the World or Wake the World (live in London)
You're So Good to me (Studio) or You're So Good to Me (lei'd In Hawaii)
Dance Dance Dance or early take of the song
Lady (DW) or Fallin' in Love (American Spring)
Shortenin' Bread (LA) or Shortenin' Bread (Adult Child) or Metal Beach
Look or Song for Children
Bull Session with Big Daddy (on the album) or the 20 minute version
All I want To Do (20/20) or All I want to Do (live in London outtake)
Come go with Me (MIU) or Come Go with Me (early 15 Big Ones outtake)
I'm So Young or early take of the song with Flute added
Breakaway (single) or alt. mix on Hawthorne or early version on EH soundtrack
I Know There's an Answer or Hang On To Your Ego
Lady Lynda (LA) or Lady Lynda (early version from MIU era) or Lady Lynda (Live at Knebworth)
Surfin' or Surfin' on SIP or Surfin' (Lei'd in Hawaii)
Girl Don't Tell Me (SD) or Girl Don't Tell Me (Live with Al in Vegas)
Trombone Dixie or Had to Phone Ya
Had to Phone Ya (15 Big Ones) or Had to Phone Ya (American Spring)
Kiss Me Baby or vocals only version
Sail On Sailor (Holland cut) or Sail On sailor (live In Concert)
Do it Again or live in London or early version on EH
The Man with All the Toys (BB version) or Man with All the Toys (BW version)
Love to Say Dada/Water or Cool Cool Water or In Blue Hawaii
Trader (Holland) or Trader (live in Concert)
Summertime (Sharon Marie) or Summertime (BWRG)
Time to Get Alone (20/20) or Time to Get Alone (Redwood) or Time to Get Alone (alt. version on Hawthorne)
Sweet Sunday Kinda Love (MIU) or Sweet Sunday Kinda Love (American Spring)
Oh Darling (KTSA) or Oh Darling (alt. version on Get the Boot/Brian vocal)

Added:
Black Widow or Let's Do it Again
Don't Worry Baby studio vs. Don't Worry Baby from the In Concert LP
That Same Song (15BO) v That Same Song (TV Special w/Double Rock Baptist Choir)
Midnight's Another Day (TLOS) v Midnight's Another Day (demo)
Heroes and Villains (Smiley) or Heroes and Villians (Lei'd in Hawaii) or H&V (live In Concert) or H&V (BWPS)
Vegetables (Laughing Gravy) or Vegetables (Smiley)
Sloop John B (album cut) or Sloop John B (other vocal, you specify)
God Only Knows (album) or GOK w/ sax solo or GOK with Brian on lead and vocal round at the end or GOK rehearsal in Hawaii on EH
Pet Sounds instrumental (studio) or Pet Sounds (live)
Caroline No (PS studio) or Caroline No (In Concert with Carl's lead)
Bluebirds Over the Mountain (20/20 or Bluebirds Over the Mountain (Live in London)
Caroline No (single/sped up/regular) or Caroline No (slowed down, "original")
Gettin' Hungry (Smiley) or Gettin' Hungry (Lei'd in Hawaii)
Do you Like Worms (Smile) or Roll Plymouth Rock (BWPS)
Wonderful (Smile) or Wonderful (Smiley) or "Wonder Bill" (Live on EH) or Wonderful (IJWMFTT) or Wonderful (BWPS)
Desert Drive (Paley Sessions) or Desert Drive (GIOMH)
Their Hearts Were Full of Spring (Original demo/Hite Morgan recording) or A Young Man is Gone or Their Hearts were Full of Spring (Rehearsal in Hawaii) or Their Hearts Were Full of Spring (Live in London)
School Days (KTSA) or School Days (Live at Knebworth)
We Got Love (Holland outtake) or We Got Love (In Concert)
You Still Believe in Me (album) or YSBIM (In Concert)
Melt Away (BW 88) or Melt Away (IJWMFTT) or Melt Away (Demo from BW 88 re-release)
Spirit of Rock and Roll (early Usher version) or Spirit of Rock and Roll (live from 80s tv special) or Spirit of Rock and Roll (Sweet Insanity with Bob Dylan) or Spirit of Rock and Roll (BW from Songs from here and back)
Loop De Loop (Landlocked early mix) or Loop De Loop (Al's newer mix from EH)
Hey Little Tomboy (MIU) or Hey Little Tomboy (Adult Child)
Still I Dream of It (Adult Child) Still I Dream of It (demo/IJWMFTT)
California Feeling (Beach Boys/MIU-LA era/most notably vocals are Carl and Al in my opinion) or California Feeling (American Spring) or California Feeling (newest BW version)
Don't Let Her Know She's an Angel (Sweet Insanity) or Don't Let Her Know She's an Angel (GIOMH)
Can't Wait too Long (snippet from Hawthorne) or Can't Wait too Long (TLOS)
Make A Wish (Sweet Insanity) or Make a Wish(GIOMH)
There's So Many (BW 88) or There's So Many (Early demo on BW88 reissue)
Rainbow Eyes (Sweet Insanity) or Rainbow Eyes (GIOMH)
Love and Mercy (BW 88) or L&M (IJWMFTT) or L&M (live at the Roxy0
Gettin In Over My Head (Paley Sessions) or Gettin' in Over My Head (GIOMH)
Walkin' the Line (Usher demo) or walkin' the Line (BW 88)

Isnt it Time (album version)

I should do a revised add on since the release of Made in California set, plus the few iTunes sets releases.

Just the ones where I know both versions well and have a strong preference, and where it doesn't feel "needless to say".

County Fair or I Do
Funky Pretty (Holland) or Funky Pretty (live)
Hawaii or Kona Coast
Be True to Your School (single) or LDC version
Thinkin' About You baby (Sharon Marie) or American Spring Version
Little Honda vs. alternative version on 2-fer
Don't Back Down vs. alternative version on 2-fer
Back Home (early 63 cut) or Back Home (Sunflower cut) or Back Home (15 Big Ones) or Back Home (live at Roxy)
Wind Chimes (Smile) or Wind Chimes (Smiley)
Pamela Jean or Car Crazy Cutie
Little St. Nick or "  " (with Drive In backing)
Bells of Christmas or Belles of Paris
Let the Wind Blow (WH) or the live version on the Concert album (hate the live version)
Good Time (Love You) or Good Time (American Spring)
Wild Honey (album cut) or Wild Honey (Live version with Blondie on lead)
Wake the World or Wake the World (live in London)
Lady (DW) or Fallin' in Love (American Spring)
Breakaway (single) or alt. mix on Hawthorne or early version on EH soundtrack
I Know There's an Answer or Hang On To Your Ego
Trombone Dixie or Had to Phone Ya (15 Big Ones) or Had to Phone Ya (American Spring)
That Same Song (15BO) v That Same Song (TV Special w/Double Rock Baptist Choir)
Caroline No (PS studio) or Caroline No (In Concert with Carl's lead)
Wonderful (Smile) or Wonderful (Smiley) or "Wonder Bill" (Live on EH) or Wonderful (IJWMFTT) or Wonderful (BWPS)
Still I Dream of It (Adult Child) Still I Dream of It (demo/IJWMFTT)

used to be fan; today I seem to think the single is better. on merits of Mike's bass.

Yes, revision should be done. I look fwd. :3d

2unreleased bcgrs: out of interest - what makes you "hate" the live version of LTWB?

I Do
Cotton Fields (Al's cut)
Land Ahoy
Big Sur (Holland)
This Whole World (Sunflower)
HATE ALL
Funky Pretty (live)
Kona Coast
Only with You (Holland/Carl lead)
Holidays (Smile)
Catch a Wave
Marcella (live In Concert)
Darlin' (live in Knebworth)
LDC version
Thinkin' About You baby (Sharon Marie)
Help Me Rhona or Ronda or alt. version on EH soundtrack
Little Honda
Vega-tables (Smile)
HATE ALL
Don't Back Down
HATE ALL
Baby Blue Eyes  (LA)
Back Home (live at Roxy)
Keep an Eye On Summer
Feel Flows (live in later 70s)
Let Him Run Wild
Santa Ana Winds (KTSA)
She Says that She Needs Me
Wind Chimes (Smile)
Live version
HATE ALL
Papa-Oom-Mow-Mow (live)
Little St. Nick
Here today (regular version)
KTSA (live at Knebworth)
HATE ALL
Aren't You Glad (live in London)
Bells of Paris
Let's Go to Heaven in My Car
live version on the Concert album
version on Hawthorne
Lay Down Burden (Imagination)
Surfer Girl (studio)
Good Time (Love You)
Wild Honey (Live version with Blondie on lead)
I'm Bugged at My ol Man (Summer Days)
Til I die
10 Years of Harmony
Sacramento (Usher)
Wake the World (live in London)
You're So Good to me (Studio)
Dance Dance Dance
Lady (DW)
HATE ALL
Look
20 minute version
All I want to Do (live in London outtake)
Come go with Me (MIU)
I'm So Young
Breakaway (single)
Hang On To Your Ego
Lady Lynda (Live at Knebworth)
Surfin'
Island Fever (UK release)
HATE ALL
Girl Don't Tell Me (Live with Al in Vegas)
Trombone Dixie
Had to Phone Ya (15 Big Ones)
Kiss Me Baby
Sail On sailor (live In Concert)
live in London
The Man with All the Toys (BB version)
Love to Say Dada/Water
Trader (live in Concert)
Summertime (BWRG)
Time to Get Alone (alt. version on Hawthorne)
Sweet Sunday Kinda Love (MIU)
Oh Darling (KTSA)

Added:
Let's Do it Again
Don't Worry Baby from the In Concert LP
Cuddle Up (C&tP)
HATE ALL VERSIONS
Midnight's Another Day (demo)
H&V (live In Concert)
Thinkin Bout You Baby - Sharon Marie
Vegetables (Smiley)
Sloop John B (album cut)
God Only Knows (album)
Pet Sounds instrumental (studio)
Caroline No (In Concert with Carl's lead)
Bluebirds Over the Mountain (Live in London)
Caroline No (slowed down, "original")
Gettin' Hungry (Lei'd in Hawaii)
Do you Like Worms (Smile))
"Wonder Bill" (Live on EH)
Let's Go Trippin' (Surfin' USA)
HATE ALL VERSIONS
Their Hearts were Full of Spring (Rehearsal in Hawaii)
School Days (Live at Knebworth)
We Got Love (In Concert)
 YSBIM (In Concert)
HATE ALL
Melt Away (IJWMFTT)
Spirit of Rock and Roll (early Usher version)
HATE ALL VERSIONS
HATE ALL
HATE ALL VERSIONS
Still I Dream of It (Adult Child)
California Feeling (Beach Boys/MIU-LA era/most notably vocals are Carl and Al in my opinion)
HATE ALL
Can't Wait too Long (snippet from Hawthorne)
HATE ALL REMAINING

Cheesy bluesy guitar in the early verses 'answering' the lead vocal instead of the backing vocal line.
Then a completely unnecessary bluesy guitar solo.
It's just a short beautiful fragile thing in the studio version, it doesn't need bluesifying or lengthening.
It was probably a ball if you were there though.