The Smiley Smile Message Board

Smiley Smile Stuff => General On Topic Discussions => Topic started by: Iron Horse-Apples on March 19, 2011, 12:50:06 PM



Title: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: Iron Horse-Apples on March 19, 2011, 12:50:06 PM
Hello everyone. I am a long time SMilE lover and sometime browser of this board. The excited news has prompted many a first time poster I would imagine.

Anyhow - From the 93 boxset through to each new compilation, we have got used to the hidden tracks at the end of the disks. I wonder what surprises we have coming on the new boxset. What do people hope will be there?

Personally I would love to hear the Truck Driving Man vocal isolated. Maybe it's been on a boot, but I've never heard it. Maybe it doesn't even exist as a multitrack, but I'm really hoping it's there (Mark- if you're reading!)

Take care folks


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: rab2591 on March 19, 2011, 01:30:21 PM
Personally I would love to hear the Truck Driving Man vocal isolated.

That would be a great hidden track!

I'd like to see an a cappella version of 'Wonderful' outro one of the discs.


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: Rocker on March 19, 2011, 01:34:30 PM
Personally I would love to hear the Truck Driving Man vocal isolated.

That would be a great hidden track!




Indeed !

The Hawthorne-set had a acapella Boys-Girls-part from Heroes & Villains as a hidden track. whic was very beautiful.


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: OneEar/OneEye on March 19, 2011, 01:36:58 PM
I'd second that re: the "Truck Driving Man" vocals.   As well I'd love to have a good selection of 'studio chat' bits (maybe that would be included with the sessions).   Things like the Smog Rant and the Vegetables Arguments and all the weird little chants Brian did with his friends - an edited version of the Smile Era Party might be cool too.   It'd be nice to have the Smile promo too.


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: Jonas on March 19, 2011, 05:16:04 PM
Indeed !

The Hawthorne-set had a acapella Boys-Girls-part from Heroes & Villains as a hidden track. whic was very beautiful.

My current ringtone. :D


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: rab2591 on March 19, 2011, 06:24:12 PM
Indeed !

The Hawthorne-set had a acapella Boys-Girls-part from Heroes & Villains as a hidden track. whic was very beautiful.

My current ringtone. :D

Do you know what track that it is on? (I want to download it) Thanks!


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: hypehat on March 19, 2011, 06:51:49 PM
The very last track of disc 2. But buy the set, man! It's out of print, still worth the cash. A wonderful comp.


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: rab2591 on March 19, 2011, 07:00:27 PM
The very last track of disc 2. But buy the set, man! It's out of print, still worth the cash. A wonderful comp.

haha I know I should! Money is tight, and any money spent on the Beach Boys will be for the box set. Damn you Capitalism!! *shaking fist at the air* :lol

Thanks for the info, btw!


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: Mike's Beard on March 20, 2011, 03:05:34 AM
Hello everyone. I am a long time SMilE lover and sometime browser of this board. The excited news has prompted many a first time poster I would imagine.

Anyhow - From the 93 boxset through to each new compilation, we have got used to the hidden tracks at the end of the disks. I wonder what surprises we have coming on the new boxset. What do people hope will be there?

Personally I would love to hear the Truck Driving Man vocal isolated. Maybe it's been on a boot, but I've never heard it. Maybe it doesn't even exist as a multitrack, but I'm really hoping it's there (Mark- if you're reading!)

Take care folks

Can anyone tell me just what Dennis is singing there? I have listened to that section over and over again on earphones trying to pick it out but to no avail.


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: smile-holland on March 20, 2011, 06:05:43 AM
Can anyone tell me just what Dennis is singing there? I have listened to that section over and over again on earphones trying to pick it out but to no avail.

www.surfermoon.com (lyrics-section)

Truck driving man do what you can
High-tail your load off the road
Out of night-life-it's a gas man
I don't believe I gotta grieve
In and out of luck
With a buck and a booth
Catchin' on to the truth
In the vast past, the last gasp
In the land, in the dust, trust that you must
Catch as catch can


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: sockittome on March 20, 2011, 10:15:17 AM
I think a vocal only of Dennis on You Are My Sunshine would be a breathtaking hidden track....if only it were possible.  I understand the only mix with his vocal was found on an acetate, right?


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: BJL on March 20, 2011, 05:37:42 PM
I think a vocal only of Dennis on You Are My Sunshine would be a breathtaking hidden track....if only it were possible.  I understand the only mix with his vocal was found on an acetate, right?

I hadn't realized that those vocals were only on an acetate, but oddly enough, knowing it gives me a lot of hope for un-booted stuff, because there you have a real life example of a missing lead vocal sourced only from an acetate.  In what universe would it make sense to delete that vocal off the multi-track?  But if that acetate had remained in the hands of, say, Bruce or Al or Van Dyke Park's ex wife, all we'd have now would be a sort of incomplete sounding instrumental take and a vague rumor that maybe Dennis was supposed to sing it...  It's a weirdly optimistic moment for me!


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: ? on March 20, 2011, 06:30:23 PM
Can anyone tell me just what Dennis is singing there? I have listened to that section over and over again on earphones trying to pick it out but to no avail.

www.surfermoon.com (lyrics-section)

This is more accurate:

Truck driving man do what you can
High-tail your load off the road
Out of night-life-I'm a gas man
I don't believe I gotta grieve
I'm out of luck
With a buck and a booth
Catchin' on to the truth
In the vast past, the last gasp
Ride (Write?) in the dust, trust what you must
Catch as catch can

Please Mention if you need a better listen to this part.


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: pixletwin on March 20, 2011, 06:47:19 PM
And the award goes to..... Todd.

*applause*

 ;D


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: Jay on March 20, 2011, 07:09:04 PM
Can anyone tell me just what Dennis is singing there? I have listened to that section over and over again on earphones trying to pick it out but to no avail.

www.surfermoon.com (lyrics-section)

This is more accurate:

Truck driving man do what you can
High-tail your load off the road
Out of night-life-I'm a gas man
I don't believe I gotta grieve
I'm out of luck
With a buck and a booth
Catchin' on to the truth
In the vast past, the last gasp
Ride (Write?) in the dust, trust what you must
Catch as catch can

Please Mention if you need a better listen to this part.
Perhaps maybe I could use a better listen to the section in question...


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: SMiLEY on March 20, 2011, 09:49:32 PM
I think a vocal only of Dennis on You Are My Sunshine would be a breathtaking hidden track....if only it were possible.  I understand the only mix with his vocal was found on an acetate, right?

I hadn't realized that those vocals were only on an acetate, but oddly enough, knowing it gives me a lot of hope for un-booted stuff, because there you have a real life example of a missing lead vocal sourced only from an acetate.  In what universe would it make sense to delete that vocal off the multi-track?  But if that acetate had remained in the hands of, say, Bruce or Al or Van Dyke Park's ex wife, all we'd have now would be a sort of incomplete sounding instrumental take and a vague rumor that maybe Dennis was supposed to sing it...  It's a weirdly optimistic moment for me!

This is why so many of us are excited -- the acetates represent a possible cache of unheard SMiLE goodies like that.


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: Don_Zabu on March 20, 2011, 10:00:25 PM
Can anyone tell me just what Dennis is singing there? I have listened to that section over and over again on earphones trying to pick it out but to no avail.

www.surfermoon.com (lyrics-section)

This is more accurate:

Truck driving man do what you can
High-tail your load off the road
Out of night-life-I'm a gas man
I don't believe I gotta grieve
I'm out of luck
With a buck and a booth
Catchin' on to the truth
In the vast past, the last gasp
Ride (Write?) in the dust, trust what you must
Catch as catch can

Please Mention if you need a better listen to this part.
Perhaps maybe I could use a better listen to the section in question...
Pardon me, but you've piqued my interest as well.


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: Mikie on March 20, 2011, 10:18:31 PM
While we're on the subject of the "Truck Drivin' Man" lyrics. And maybe this belongs on one of the other Smile-o-Phile threads here, but does anybody know if that Dennis part was mixed down or was it more up front in the vocals in the original version of Cabinessence intended for Smile? Or was that section later buried down behind "Who Ran The Iron Horse" in the middle of the song for inclusion on 20/20? I probably read about this somewhere before Priore LLVS?) but I forgot how the truck drivin' man lyrics were orginally suppose to fit into the song. Maybe it was intended to be mixed down deep! I always thought it was a shame that it was buried on the released version of the song.

And yes, this would be a great hidden track!  Or they could add "Denny, got any hash joints?" just before the run-out groove. Or the water chant in the middle of "Cool Cool Water". Or a 15 Khz high frequency tone at the end...........wait, no, that's been done.

I'm sure it's a given that my favorite "Three Score and Five", "Cantina", and "Cornicopia" lyrics will be included in all their glory!


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: Mikie on March 20, 2011, 10:37:16 PM

This is more accurate:

Truck driving man do what you can
High-tail your load off the road
Out of night-life-I'm a gas man
I don't believe I gotta grieve
I'm out of luck
With a buck and a booth
Catchin' on to the truth
In the vast past, the last gasp
Ride (Write?) in the dust, trust what you must
Catch as catch can

Please Mention if you need a better listen to this part.

Truck driving man do what you can
High-tail your load off the road
Out of night life it's a gas man
I don't believe I gotta grieve
In and out of luck
With a buck and a booth
Catchin' on to the truth
In the vast past, the last gasp
In the land, in the dust, trust that you must
Catch as catch can



Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: ? on March 20, 2011, 11:06:00 PM
Revised slightly...  Nothing better to do tonight than listen to the isolated vocal. :lol

I'll concede "Land" is in there, but it's definitely "I'm a gas man" and "I'm out of luck"!

Truck driving man do what you can
High-tail your load off the road
Out of night-life-I'm a gas man
I don't believe I gotta grieve
I'm out of luck
With a buck and a booth
Catchin' on to the truth
In the vast past, the last gasp
Land in the dust, trust what you must
Catch as catch can

How is it that we have the "reconnected telephone" lyrics but not this part that was actually recorded?  Where did the telephone lyrics originate from, Frank Holmes?



Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: Bicyclerider on March 21, 2011, 06:40:46 AM
I think a vocal only of Dennis on You Are My Sunshine would be a breathtaking hidden track....if only it were possible.  I understand the only mix with his vocal was found on an acetate, right?

I remember an old article in ICE (remember that magazine/newsletter?) where Mark Linnett was interviewed about the GV box set Smile stuff and said that they had found a better quality tape of Old Master Painter/Sunshine.  Hopefully this will be on the new release! 


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: sockittome on March 21, 2011, 05:42:56 PM
I think a vocal only of Dennis on You Are My Sunshine would be a breathtaking hidden track....if only it were possible.  I understand the only mix with his vocal was found on an acetate, right?

I remember an old article in ICE (remember that magazine/newsletter?) where Mark Linnett was interviewed about the GV box set Smile stuff and said that they had found a better quality tape of Old Master Painter/Sunshine.  Hopefully this will be on the new release! 

If that means complete with vocal, that in itself will be worth the price of admission!  :happydance


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: Andrew G. Doe on March 22, 2011, 06:47:23 AM
Revised slightly...  Nothing better to do tonight than listen to the isolated vocal. :lol

I'll concede "Land" is in there, but it's definitely "I'm a gas man" and "I'm out of luck"!

Truck driving man do what you can
High-tail your load off the road
Out of night-life-I'm a gas man
I don't believe I gotta grieve
I'm out of luck
With a buck and a booth
Catchin' on to the truth
In the vast past, the last gasp
Land in the dust, trust what you must
Catch as catch can

How is it that we have the "reconnected telephone" lyrics but not this part that was actually recorded?  Where did the telephone lyrics originate from, Frank Holmes?

Who says it wasn't recorded ?  Granted we don't have a copy of it... but to my sure knowledge, no-one in the collector's world has a copy of "(Wouldn't It Be Nice To) Live Again" - but it exists. :)


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: JohnMill on March 22, 2011, 01:35:56 PM
Getting off the "Truck Driving Man" topic for a minute.  Does anyone think the "Vosse Posse" segments have a place on this boxset?  I obviously don't expect them to include full length segments of these recordings but short excerpts here and there could add to the overall quality of this release.  Sort of like how they've included some radio promos on other box sets?

Thoughts?


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: Rocker on March 22, 2011, 01:51:02 PM
Getting off the "Truck Driving Man" topic for a minute.  Does anyone think the "Vosse Posse" segments have a place on this boxset?  I obviously don't expect them to include full length segments of these recordings but short excerpts here and there could add to the overall quality of this release.  Sort of like how they've included some radio promos on other box sets?

Thoughts?


I don't think I have heard of the Vosse Posse segments. What are they?


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: JohnMill on March 22, 2011, 01:57:03 PM
Getting off the "Truck Driving Man" topic for a minute.  Does anyone think the "Vosse Posse" segments have a place on this boxset?  I obviously don't expect them to include full length segments of these recordings but short excerpts here and there could add to the overall quality of this release.  Sort of like how they've included some radio promos on other box sets?

Thoughts?


I don't think I have heard of the Vosse Posse segments. What are they?

You probably have heard them as they've all been around for quite a few years now.  They go by the titles on bootleg as "SMiLE Era Party", "Vega-tables Arguments" and all of the stuff encompassed on the "Psychedelic Sounds" bootleg.  They are basically tapes of Brian, Michael Vosse,  Jules Siegel and various others making experimental recordings during the "SMiLE" sessions.


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: The Shift on March 22, 2011, 02:01:16 PM
Revised slightly...  Nothing better to do tonight than listen to the isolated vocal. :lol

I'll concede "Land" is in there, but it's definitely "I'm a gas man" and "I'm out of luck"!

Truck driving man do what you can
High-tail your load off the road
Out of night-life-I'm a gas man
I don't believe I gotta grieve
I'm out of luck
With a buck and a booth
Catchin' on to the truth
In the vast past, the last gasp
Land in the dust, trust what you must
Catch as catch can

How is it that we have the "reconnected telephone" lyrics but not this part that was actually recorded?  Where did the telephone lyrics originate from, Frank Holmes?

Who says it wasn't recorded ?  Granted we don't have a copy of it... but to my sure knowledge, no-one in the collector's world has a copy of "(Wouldn't It Be Nice To) Live Again" - but it exists. :)

Are you saying....


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: rab2591 on March 22, 2011, 02:08:43 PM
Getting off the "Truck Driving Man" topic for a minute.  Does anyone think the "Vosse Posse" segments have a place on this boxset?  I obviously don't expect them to include full length segments of these recordings but short excerpts here and there could add to the overall quality of this release.  Sort of like how they've included some radio promos on other box sets?

Thoughts?

I can only imagine them being included in 15-30 second clips....not unlike the 'Dog Barking Session' from Pet Sounds Sessions. But I doubt the assemblers will want to 'waste' disc space with a lot of the psychedelic skits. Personally, I'd love to see a few minutes of that stuff included in the set - some of it shows a lot of insight into Brian's social scene at the time.


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: JohnMill on March 22, 2011, 02:12:42 PM
Getting off the "Truck Driving Man" topic for a minute.  Does anyone think the "Vosse Posse" segments have a place on this boxset?  I obviously don't expect them to include full length segments of these recordings but short excerpts here and there could add to the overall quality of this release.  Sort of like how they've included some radio promos on other box sets?

Thoughts?

I can only imagine them being included in 15-30 second clips....not unlike the 'Dog Barking Session' from Pet Sounds Sessions. But I doubt the assemblers will want to 'waste' disc space with a lot of the psychedelic skits. Personally, I'd love to see a few minutes of that stuff included in the set - some of it shows a lot of insight into Brian's social scene at the time.

Yeah that is really all I'd want as well and would even accept them as "hidden tracks" (which I why I started the discussion in this thread to begin with).  They are never going to be the "meat and potatoes" of the set but there are a lot of interesting recordings that Brian made during this time which probably would've never found official release on a conventional Beach Boys album but are nonetheless insightful as to the overall atmosphere of the sessions.  The session that has come to be known as "George Fell Into His French Horn" would be another interesting hidden track.  Not the entire session itself but just the bit with the "Talking Horns".


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: The Shift on March 22, 2011, 02:28:22 PM
Getting off the "Truck Driving Man" topic for a minute.  Does anyone think the "Vosse Posse" segments have a place on this boxset?  I obviously don't expect them to include full length segments of these recordings but short excerpts here and there could add to the overall quality of this release.  Sort of like how they've included some radio promos on other box sets?

Thoughts?

I can only imagine them being included in 15-30 second clips....not unlike the 'Dog Barking Session' from Pet Sounds Sessions. But I doubt the assemblers will want to 'waste' disc space with a lot of the psychedelic skits. Personally, I'd love to see a few minutes of that stuff included in the set - some of it shows a lot of insight into Brian's social scene at the time.

Yeah that is really all I'd want as well and would even accept them as "hidden tracks" (which I why I started the discussion in this thread to begin with).  They are never going to be the "meat and potatoes" of the set but there are a lot of interesting recordings that Brian made during this time which probably would've never found official release on a conventional Beach Boys album but are nonetheless insightful as to the overall atmosphere of the sessions.  The session that has come to be known as "George Fell Into His French Horn" would be another interesting hidden track.  Not the entire session itself but just the bit with the "Talking Horns".

I think these are too interesting to be thrown away as hidden tracks. As mentioned, they're a terrific insight into what was happening in Brian's circle while the band was away touring, and his ideas were developing.   The notion of "hidden track" strikes me as inappropriate for this stuff -  I'd like notes, about who the players are, what the date was, what was recorded that sam day or around that date, so that we can gain some insight into the part that skit played in inspiring Brian's creative studio processes.  All the "swim swim fishy fishy" stuff, for instance, puts me in mind of the Water Chant  (sorry, I mean "Wah-doo" Chant) but I don't know how they relate time-wise*.

Brian was a flbberdigibbet at the time and ioeas came and went in a nanosecond.

Hidden tracks tend not to have liner notes, due to the fact that they'd then not really be hidden. Everything important and relevant should be annotated. Notes is what we want.

Else how we gonna graduate from the University of SMiLE?

* I know, I know, I should go to Andrew's site, but I'm working and you guys is distracting me enough already!


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: The Shift on March 22, 2011, 02:31:19 PM
The session that has come to be known as "George Fell Into His French Horn" would be another interesting hidden track.  Not the entire session itself but just the bit with the "Talking Horns".

"Session"? How can you be sure this was a mere session? I suspect this was the missing fourth suite that would have made upSide Four of the double album we all know SMiLE was meant to be. The story of how Barnyard Billy and his pal George Gershwin fell into their instruments.

Dom's essay will reveal all!


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: bgas on March 22, 2011, 02:52:33 PM
Maybe Capitol could release the Vosse Posse sessions as a separate set.
"If you bought The Smile Sessions, you'll want these too!"
I know: send proof of purchase and $5 and we'll send you these sessions as a bonus....


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: buddhahat on March 22, 2011, 02:54:29 PM
Revised slightly...  Nothing better to do tonight than listen to the isolated vocal. :lol

I'll concede "Land" is in there, but it's definitely "I'm a gas man" and "I'm out of luck"!

Truck driving man do what you can
High-tail your load off the road
Out of night-life-I'm a gas man
I don't believe I gotta grieve
I'm out of luck
With a buck and a booth
Catchin' on to the truth
In the vast past, the last gasp
Land in the dust, trust what you must
Catch as catch can

How is it that we have the "reconnected telephone" lyrics but not this part that was actually recorded?  Where did the telephone lyrics originate from, Frank Holmes?

Who says it wasn't recorded ?  Granted we don't have a copy of it... but to my sure knowledge, no-one in the collector's world has a copy of "(Wouldn't It Be Nice To) Live Again" - but it exists. :)

Are you saying the recording of reconnected telephone line exists, but in that cryptic, indirect AGD way, or am I reading too much into your posts, as usual?


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: bgas on March 22, 2011, 03:01:34 PM
Ya'll lost me again. I'm doing my best to follow this, but what is >>recording of reconnected telephone line <<  ?


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: Rocker on March 22, 2011, 03:04:59 PM
Getting off the "Truck Driving Man" topic for a minute.  Does anyone think the "Vosse Posse" segments have a place on this boxset?  I obviously don't expect them to include full length segments of these recordings but short excerpts here and there could add to the overall quality of this release.  Sort of like how they've included some radio promos on other box sets?

Thoughts?


I don't think I have heard of the Vosse Posse segments. What are they?

You probably have heard them as they've all been around for quite a few years now.  They go by the titles on bootleg as "SMiLE Era Party", "Vega-tables Arguments" and all of the stuff encompassed on the "Psychedelic Sounds" bootleg.  They are basically tapes of Brian, Michael Vosse,  Jules Siegel and various others making experimental recordings during the "SMiLE" sessions.



Allright. Thanks ! Yes, I know them of course


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: buddhahat on March 22, 2011, 03:58:02 PM
Ya'll lost me again. I'm doing my best to follow this, but what is >>recording of reconnected telephone line <<  ?

some extra lyrics for cabinessence. I don't have them to hand. I remeber them being discussed in an old thread And I don't think anyone could work out where in the song they would have fit. I think one thought was that they may have been an equivalent to the truck driving man lyrics i.e. running underneath the who ran section. I may be wrong about all this.


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: ? on March 22, 2011, 03:59:21 PM
Taken from http://smilealbum.tripod.com/songs.html:

Quote
“These lyrics are out of ‘Cabin Essence’:

    ‘Reconnected telephone direct
    dialing;
    Different color cords to your
    Extension,
    Don’t forget to mention
    This is a recording.’

And below that, it has:

    ‘Even though the echoes through
    my mind
    Have filtered through the pines,
    I came and found my peace,
    And this is not a recording.’

Then there was:

    “Doobie doo,
    Doobie doo,
    Or not doobie!’”


-Frank Holmes (Endless Summer Quarterly, March 1997 -Beard & Dempsey, editors)

AGD had a good point though.  I should have said "released" rather than "recorded" in my earlier post.  I'd love to hear this segment if it exists.


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: bgas on March 22, 2011, 04:20:27 PM
Thanxx. I pulled out my copy and read it again.  


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: JohnMill on March 22, 2011, 04:25:29 PM
Getting off the "Truck Driving Man" topic for a minute.  Does anyone think the "Vosse Posse" segments have a place on this boxset?  I obviously don't expect them to include full length segments of these recordings but short excerpts here and there could add to the overall quality of this release.  Sort of like how they've included some radio promos on other box sets?

Thoughts?

I can only imagine them being included in 15-30 second clips....not unlike the 'Dog Barking Session' from Pet Sounds Sessions. But I doubt the assemblers will want to 'waste' disc space with a lot of the psychedelic skits. Personally, I'd love to see a few minutes of that stuff included in the set - some of it shows a lot of insight into Brian's social scene at the time.

Yeah that is really all I'd want as well and would even accept them as "hidden tracks" (which I why I started the discussion in this thread to begin with).  They are never going to be the "meat and potatoes" of the set but there are a lot of interesting recordings that Brian made during this time which probably would've never found official release on a conventional Beach Boys album but are nonetheless insightful as to the overall atmosphere of the sessions.  The session that has come to be known as "George Fell Into His French Horn" would be another interesting hidden track.  Not the entire session itself but just the bit with the "Talking Horns".

I think these are too interesting to be thrown away as hidden tracks. As mentioned, they're a terrific insight into what was happening in Brian's circle while the band was away touring, and his ideas were developing.   The notion of "hidden track" strikes me as inappropriate for this stuff -  I'd like notes, about who the players are, what the date was, what was recorded that sam day or around that date, so that we can gain some insight into the part that skit played in inspiring Brian's creative studio processes.  All the "swim swim fishy fishy" stuff, for instance, puts me in mind of the Water Chant  (sorry, I mean "Wah-doo" Chant) but I don't know how they relate time-wise*.

Brian was a flbberdigibbet at the time and ioeas came and went in a nanosecond.

Hidden tracks tend not to have liner notes, due to the fact that they'd then not really be hidden. Everything important and relevant should be annotated. Notes is what we want.

Else how we gonna graduate from the University of SMiLE?

* I know, I know, I should go to Andrew's site, but I'm working and you guys is distracting me enough already!

In essence I agree with everything you wrote but it's important to remember that this set will have to be marketed to the general public who probably will have little to no interest in the non-musical segments on this boxset.  That is why I feel that if they are included at all that a few of them will be slotted into the sessions portion of the boxset (again see the "Caroline No!" promos on "PSS") or hidden as bonus tracks at the end of the disc.  I think the "Talking Horns" would actually make a fine bonus track, it's irreverent and weird enough to stick at the end of the disc where the everyday listener would either have a laugh at it or think WTF is that which is just the kind of affect hidden tracks are supposed to have.


Title: Re: SMiLE Boxset - Hidden tracks?
Post by: hypehat on March 22, 2011, 05:03:41 PM
IIRC, and this is a bit of stretch of the old noodle, but the 'session' of Vegetable skits, Water skits, Brian falling in the mic and so on (not the cabbie, or Lifeboat tape) are from the day of the first Surf's Up session. Is that right? I think I read it on Project Smile, but have no idea of its veracity.