Brother Records YouTube Copyright Claims

[XY]

Hello,
They once again deleted my Smile Mix, which is no problem of course. I'm just wondering why they always delete such things but that it's apparently no problem that the complete Pet Sounds, Smiley Smile & Wild Honey albums are available, also Brian's SMiLE & more complete albums. I think they should start there. Thanks.

On another note, Sony asked to remove the "Holy Man" video, because they want to make it available on YouTube after clearing some legal problems.

[Shady]

Brother Records are such a pain.

[NightHider]

Why doesnt Brothers Records freakin' release something instead of just policing youtube....

[Shady]

Why doesnt Brothers Records freakin' release something instead of just policing youtube....

Maybe they have something special in the pipeline

[thebaron]

Why doesnt Brothers Records freakin' release something instead of just policing youtube....

Someone has to justify their job.

[Jason]

Smart idea to bash BRI when THEY READ THE BOARD.

[The Shift]

Smart idea to bash BRI when THEY READ THE BOARD.

Then let's hope they read the board, gauge the mood and RELEASE SOMETHING! Can't get enough of the stuff...

Mind you, remember how all the SMiLE boots got taken off eBay once it was decided that Brian was going to restart work on it? Perhaps this is a harbinger of things to come?

Can't get enough of that sweet, sweet  stuff...

[Mark H.]

Smart idea to bash BRI when THEY READ THE BOARD.

Good....READ THIS......GET THIS STUFF OUT TO THE PUBLIC!

[Jasp]

Well, this was the third copyright complaint for that account and what happens when you get 3? They delete the complete account. So I wrote this in shock condition, forgive me dear Brother Records...

[endofposts]

How does that work?  Does BRI just e-mail YouTube and it gets taken down immediately and your account removed, or does YouTube investigate?  My understanding is that the copyright holders themselves have to show proof that they do own the rights to the material, not just anybody.  So, that might take some time to prove that they do own the rights to the material.  Does YouTube give you a warning and ask you to remove the video first, or do they just take it down and notify you after the fact (or do they even notify you at all that you violated the rules and are taking down a video you posted and/or suspending your account)?

[XY]

After copyright complaints, YouTube deletes videos without warning. The uploader then receives an email like

This is to notify you that we have removed or disabled access to the following material as a result of a third-party notification by Brother Records Inc claiming that this material is infringing.

Don't know how exactly it works, but Brother was able to delete Brian Wilson Solo material, so they obvioulsy don't take it too exact with the rights.
But it's clear, every fan who uploades BB material knows that he has no rights to do that, except maybe personal concert videos.
Brother should do himself a favor and open an official account. Don't underestimate the promotional aspect of YouTube. There are already a couple of official Knebworth clips by Eagle Entertainment BTW. And no, I'm not the funny person who runs the Bootleg account Brother Records. 

[endofposts]

Brother probably makes any and all complaints on behalf of the Beach Boys because they filed the paperwork with YouTube.  The way I read their terms of service, you have to submit written proof that you are the holder of the rights to certain works before they will take action.  Maybe BRI submitted this paperwork a long time ago, and claimed blanket rights to object to anything having to do with Beach Boys/BRI members or songs.  So, for example, if someone posts a video of Brian doing "Love and Mercy," BRI can lodge a complaint on behalf of BRI member Brian, even though that song is not something BRI has the actual rights to.

Thanks for clarifying how it worked in your case, Jasper.  I now regularly download favorite YouTube videos using Miro because I realize that YouTube might take them down.  They seem to do it a lot more since Google took them over. 

[chrismooremusic]

Why doesnt Brothers Records freakin' release something instead of just policing youtube....

Maybe they have something special in the pipeline

I hope they do!!! :-)

-Chris

[Surfer Joe]

They have to be a pain, to some degree, because if you neglect your rights you can lose them, or at least endanger them.

[Alf64]

  I recently had all 4 of my Bugaloos music videos removed by YouTube.  This is a mean and insensistive way to do this. Here is my idea. Though it probably is falling on deaf ears.

1. If there is an infringement, YouTube should send an email to let the person know how they can comply to send the viewer's eyes to the copyright parties. Such as I have for Carlene Carter's videos

2. If they refuse to do that in an alotted time. Give them an email requesting they remove the videos in an alotted time, or YouTube will.