A few questions and that

[thomasogg]

That's all great, ta. Yes, suspected the Manson girl rumour was a heap of old crap. I'd thought that it'd been a hooker too. Hmmm, but can people please stop pointing out when someone makes a spilling mistoke. It's petty and boring, if a debate is in full swing maybe their ain't time to double-check everything typed before it's sent, or maybe some people are just better at typing than others. Who cares...? And it's 'Dennnnnis', not 'Dennis'.

[Aegir]

Who double-checks things before they post?

I just spell things right the first time.

[thomasogg]

Bloody hell.

[Wilsonista]

What became the "River Song" intro.

To my ears part of the verse of Live Again sounds an awful lot like the last part of the chorus from Cuddle Up. 

[Goin’Bald]

A long time ago I read that Mark Linett prepared a DVD-A of Surf’s Up, including a.o. Live Again. Whatever happened to that project?

[Rocker]

A long time ago I read that Mark Linett prepared a DVD-A of Surf’s Up, including a.o. Live Again. Whatever happened to that project?

Yes, I think it was going to be released in 2004 but I don't remember what happened. Probably some legal things....

[Roger Ryan]

A long time ago I read that Mark Linett prepared a DVD-A of Surf’s Up, including a.o. Live Again. Whatever happened to that project?

Yes, I think it was going to be released in 2004 but I don't remember what happened. Probably some legal things....

If I remember correctly, Mark said the Surf's Up DVD-A was still in the planning stages when the project was dropped by Capitol - probably due to consumers' lack of interest in DVD-A's in general.

[♩♬🐸 Billy C ♯♫♩🐇]

Last time I made a "spilling mistoke", I ended up with a daughter...

Brian's solo take on "You've Lost That Lovin' Feelin'", and Denny's "Ecology", rough as it is. Brian wasn't the only Wilson who knew the value of recycling a good riff.

Oh hell yeah, Andrew...why wasn't that on 15 Big Ones? Unless it was recorded after, it was better than just about any thing on that album.  Brian's falsetto in the middle part was just..wow. At the very least it should have been on Love You.

[Andrew G. Doe]

"YLTLF" was recorded fall 1976.

[adamghost]

Adam can give you the chapter and verse the musical changes, but to these musically illiterate ears it's awfully close to the original in almost every respect, and the original is among the best three unreleased BB tracks I've ever heard. Utterly magnificent. Adam's band's version is merely awesome. Buy his CD, and judge for yourself.

Thanks Andrew.

The differences between the original recording and ours are thus:

(a)  The original is one whole step lower in key (we had to change to accommodate Evie's range).
(b)  We deleted a fairly long and repetitive guitar solo (basically three notes played over and over again).  This was probably a placeholder by Carl for a more developed solo that never was realized.
(c)  My Dennis-like response on the third verse was just an ad lib.  It's not on the original.
(d)  There's a minor electric piano (Wurlitzer) line on the second verse (basically doodling in the major scale) that we dropped fairly early on so we wouldn't have to use an extra keyboard on the song.
(e)  The ending vocal counterpoint isn't exactly the same but it's close.  Ours is a little sparser because we had to sing and play fairly complicated parts simultaneously.  Evie sings Mike's part, then John (IIRC) does Carl's and I sing Brian's part.

The block backing vocals through the rest of the song are identical to the original.

I've had a lot of people ask me through "back channels" for a copy of the song, but it was only in our hands as long as it took for us to learn it, so I can't help anyone!  Sorry. 

[♩♬🐸 Billy C ♯♫♩🐇]

"YLTLF" was recorded fall 1976.

Oh, well, that explains it.

[thomasogg]

 I've heard it said that it (Be With Me) isn't a Manson co-write, but then quite respectable books such as 'Dumb Angel', an otherwise great read, claim it is. What gives?


[/quote]


Seemed to get all side-tracked and that, anyone got an answer to the above?

[Andrew G. Doe]

The lyric sounds sufficiently Manson-ish - "She should be with me/It would set her free" - for such a supposition to carry some weight. Personally i think it is.

[thomasogg]

So no-one knows then. Hmmm, I agree that it sounds like it is... Spooky screaming at the end of the track. One of my fave 20/20 moments.