Brian Wilson on Bill Medley´s new album

[mikeyj]

Brian Wilson on Bill Medley´s new album "Damn Near Righteous", due Sept. 25, will feature Brian Wilson's "In My Room" with vocal contributions by Brian himself.

Just read this on Mt. Vernon.. pretty interesting I spose.. how many versions is that now:

In My Room (original)
In My Room (the version with the strings)
In My Room (country version)
In My Room (live at roxy)
In My Room (this new version)

Is there any more I'm missing?

[mikeyj]

Brian Wilson on Bill Medley´s new album "Damn Near Righteous", due Sept. 25, will feature Brian Wilson's "In My Room" with vocal contributions by Brian himself.

Just read this on Mt. Vernon.. pretty interesting I spose.. how many versions is that now:

In My Room (original)
In My Room (the version with the strings)
In My Room (country version)
In My Room (live at roxy)
In My Room (this new version)

Is there any more I'm missing?

Oops.. I didn't even take notice of the date.. thats a while ago. Ahwell, whatever. You can tell I havent been keeping up with all the news like that.. there was a period where I wasn't checking anything like that out for 10 or so weeks so this is news to me.

[dogear]

There was the duo version with Tammi Wynette (sorry if i spelled her wrong) and the German language version called "Ganz Allein" (= All Alone)

[Rocker]

Wasn't there a version by Wilson Phillips with Brian on piano and vocal? I believe it was on their "California"-album

[LostArt]

Just listened to this.  The harmonies are gorgeous, the arrangement's pretty good with some interesting bass lines.  Bill Medley's weathered voice is out front, even when he's singing the bass vocals.  It took a couple of listens before I got used to that.  Phil Everly sounds great.  Both Bill and Phil take liberties with their vocal parts, adding little soulful touches here and there.  You'd certainly expect that from Bill, but Phil really sounds good.  At one point Brian tries to do the same, but he just doesn't have that 'blues singer' mentality, so his attempt sounds a little awkward next to the other two more soulful voices.  Not bad overall, but I think I'll keep the Beach Boys' version on my mp3 player, thank you very much.

[mikeyj]

Yeh I spose you could count Ganz Allien and yes I do believe there was a version by Wilson Phillips, but not sure if it was featuring Brian (I Havent heard it)... But yeh thats the country version I was talking about (with Tammy Wynette)

[donald]

Who sang the one on the bw tribute ?

David Crosby?


Also, there is the little known Manson version, featuring the family on backing vocals.

[mikeyj]

Who sang the one on the bw tribute ?

David Crosby?


Also, there is the little known Manson version, featuring the family on backing vocals.

From memory I think it was David Crosby, Jimmy Webb and Carly Simon?

Are you sure they did In My Room? That is just weird. Do you know if its ever been released?

[donald]

I withdraw the Manson joke before it gets out of hand.   Sometimes I'm just a smart ass.   

[Chris Brown]

Who sang the one on the bw tribute ?

David Crosby?


Also, there is the little known Manson version, featuring the family on backing vocals.

From memory I think it was David Crosby, Jimmy Webb and Carly Simon?

Are you sure they did In My Room? That is just weird. Do you know if its ever been released?

Yes they did "In My Room"...it was one of the highlights of the tribute for me, actually.  The only release I know of is on the tribute DVD; I don't think there was a CD release of that.

And yes Brian was on the Wilson Phillips version of "In My Room" also.

[Awesoman]

I just heard a snippet of this version on www.allmusic.com.  So nice of Satan to record a cover of this.   

[SloopJohnB]

There are actually two versions with Tammy Wynette... A version with Brian on background vocals, and another one (unreleased on CD - you have to watch the Nashville Sounds DVD to hear it) with the Beach Boys on backing vocals.

And this new version is quite good!

[roll plymouth rock]

I liked hearing Brian singing harmony with Phil Everly...imagine if those two played a show/released an album together.

I also enjoy the Sagittarius version of In My Room that was released as a 45 and on their Blue Marble LP

[Sheriff John Stone]

There's also the live version from the Imagination - Words And Music CD. It features Brian, Timothy B. Schmitt, Bruce Johnston, and a couple of others. Decent version.

[roll plymouth rock]

I didn't realize that Bill Medley was a Righteous Brother...that is cool, an Everly Brother, a Righteous Brother and a Beach Boys on one song

http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=15251861

[Charles LePage @ ComicList]

Has anyone heard it yet?  If not:

http://www.rhapsody.com/goto?rcid=tra.16158467&variant=play&lsrc=RN_im

What do you think?

[roll plymouth rock]

I like it 
3 legends singing in harmony, what more could you ask for?

There is already a thread for it though...here:
http://smileysmile.net/board/index.php/topic,4616.0.html

[Aegir]

What do you think, Charles?

[Charles LePage @ ComicList]

So far, I think it's okay.  Three stars out of five.  I don't know that I've heard a sung version that didn't pale compared to the original.  People who cover it instrumentally seem to do it justice, though one poor fellow who did so ended up committing suicide.

[Chris Brown]

So far, I think it's okay.  Three stars out of five.  I don't know that I've heard a sung version that didn't pale compared to the original.  People who cover it instrumentally seem to do it justice, though one poor fellow who did so ended up committing suicide.

I agree.  It's a decent cover (you really can't go wrong covering such a great tune), but the original cannot be topped for me.  I've heard some good covers over the years, my favorite being the Tammy Wynette version with Brian and Carl doing the harmonies.  But there is something about that young Beach Boy blend that puts the original above all others.

[matt-zeus]

Blimey! Bill Medley sounds like a monster on this song - literally!
Brian sounds positively angelic compared to him!