What If Paradox

[Pretty Funky]

We would be blaming some guy called Mike for saying "no" to his cousin Brian when he proposed a family singing group.


.......oh, and I would have had a lot of wasted time back!

[bgas]

We would be blaming some guy called Mike for saying "no" to his cousin Brian when he proposed a family singing group.


.......oh, and I would have had a lot of wasted time back!

So sad that you feel the time you've spent with us ihas been wasted....

[Pretty Funky]

Aahhh but it is only wasted because the band never existed remember!

[Mujan, 8@$+@Rc| of a Blue Wizard]

So this is pretty much the most pointless thread ever

[bgas]

So this is pretty much the most pointless thread ever

I thought this one was:   Here's a SMiLE Rearrangement Ive been working on. Feedback appreciated.

[Pretty Funky]

What if they were all born as girls? is up there IMO.



Need some news on the Brian movie and album desperately don't we?

[bgas]

What if they were all born as girls? is up there IMO.



Need some news on the Brian movie and album desperately don't we?

Yes that thread also.

And some news on the upcoming Capitol release of unreleased BBs songs

[Pretty Funky]

Wasn't there also talk about a C50 picture book? Guess that moment has passed. Time for a thread on promised Beach Boy projects me thinks!

[Mujan, 8@$+@Rc| of a Blue Wizard]

So this is pretty much the most pointless thread ever

I thought this one was:   Here's a SMiLE Rearrangement Ive been working on. Feedback appreciated.

Yeah, seeing as how it descended into 5 pages of people ironically complaining I was f***ing with the formula. 'Cause SMiLE mixes apparently have rules now.

[ThyRavenAscend]

This thread wouldn't exist.

It would.

But it would be about The Hollies.

Other people would write in it.

The moderators would be different folks too.

Um, wait, I see a philosophical problem emerging here...

Ah, but then the first post would be, "What if The Hollies didn't exist?"
And then someone would reply, "This thread wouldn't exist."
And then someone like you would say,

"It would.

But it would be about The Young Rascals.

Other people would write in it.

The moderators would be different folks too."

[Andrew G. Doe]

What if... Surfer had never been born ?

I like that idea, very much indeed.

[Mujan, 8@$+@Rc| of a Blue Wizard]

Wasn't there also talk about a C50 picture book? Guess that moment has passed. Time for a thread on promised Beach Boy projects me thinks!

Sounds interesting. I'd like that.

[Gabo]

Wasn't there also talk about a C50 picture book? Guess that moment has passed. Time for a thread on promised Beach Boy projects me thinks!

picture book! pictures of your mama taken by your paper a long time ago!

[Gabo]

What if... Surfer had never been born ?

I like that idea, very much indeed.

What if Surfer was your own son?

[Andrew G. Doe]

Were that true, the following would apply:

1 - his English grammar would be a helluva lot better...
2 - his manners would also be better...
3 - he wouldn't be asking so many damnfool questions. 

[Smilin Ed H]

Shave that beard off, Andrew, and you'll look like Chief Joseph!

[Andrew G. Doe]

Careful what you say around here on that topic - the Thought Police and PC Nazis will be on your case so fast your head will spin. 

[runnersdialzero]

remember that creed song called "what if" where scott stapp was freaking out going "WHOD EFF. WHOD EFF. WHOD EFF. WHOD EFF. WHOD EFF, AHH-HAAAA. WHOD EFF. WHOD EFF. WHOD EFF. WHOD EFF. WHOD EFF, AHH-HAAAA." over and over for eighteen minutes and it sold 17 copys on itunes and the world lost its motion to stop and recognize the genius of the smash hit rock single "whod eff" by scott stapp

[SMiLE Brian]

That's our childhood runners....

[Generation42]

So this is pretty much the most pointless thread ever

I thought this one was:   Here's a SMiLE Rearrangement Ive been working on. Feedback appreciated.

Yep, that one was much, much worse. 

[Mujan, 8@$+@Rc| of a Blue Wizard]

So this is pretty much the most pointless thread ever

I thought this one was:   Here's a SMiLE Rearrangement Ive been working on. Feedback appreciated.

Yep, that one was much, much worse. 

Again, I agree. Very proud of my mix, got some interesting ideas for how to improve it, but the thread itself is nothing but a Good Vibrations circle-jerk. Bah Whizzers on you guys and your formulas.

[Mikie]

So this is pretty much the most pointless thread ever

I thought this one was:   Here's a SMiLE Rearrangement Ive been working on. Feedback appreciated.

Agreed.  What a clusterfuck.

[Mujan, 8@$+@Rc| of a Blue Wizard]

So this is pretty much the most pointless thread ever

I thought this one was:   Here's a SMiLE Rearrangement Ive been working on. Feedback appreciated.

Agreed.  What a clusterfuck.

 

[Magic Transistor Radio]

To the original question, I can answer because in a previous incarnation I was a friend of Murry Wilson. After being fired by the Beach Boys he wished he had never been born. His gaurdian angel, Clarence made his wish come true. His wife Audree didn't know who he was. She was an unmarried librarian. His sons Brian, Dennis in Carl didn't exist thus the Beach Boys didn't exist. His Hawthorne home was owned by Dwight and Dorothy Hendrick (my grandparents). He saw a world where the Beatles were still wearing matching suits and mop tops in 1969. There music hadn't changed much.  The summer of love was just a bunch of druggies playing crappy music. In this world Smile DID come out, but it was a collection of kids songs from Seseme street inwhich Bruce Johnston wrote songs for. David Marks didn't know Murry, but he was part of the crappy summer of love scene and got a career in construction. Mike Love existed, but was forced to get married and get a job as a mechanic to support his child and girlfriend. They get married and he struggled through life. Murry couldn't take it! He said he wants to live! Thus the Beach Boys still exist and this board exists.

[Andrew G. Doe]

Who is this "Murray" of whom you speak ?